The John J. Moakley Federal Courthouse in Boston, U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts photo (public domain).
The refugee green card freeze that has stalled tens of thousands of permanent residence cases met a skeptical federal judge in Boston on Friday. At a Nov. 20 hearing in Partnership for the Advancement of New Americans v. Edlow, U.S. District Judge Myong Joun questioned whether the administration can halt refugee adjustment applications indefinitely and said he was struggling to understand a new rule that gives refugees 10 days, instead of 30, to fight the termination of their status, Reuters reported. He did not rule from the bench.
The hearing put the case squarely before the judge who will decide it. Judge Julia Kobick paused the 10-day rule in late October to hold things in place until another judge could take the case, and that pause was reported extended to Dec. 4. Reuters said the rule remains on hold while Joun considers the challenge. The far larger practical question, the freeze on green cards, has had no court order against it at all.
Three policies, one set of refugees
The class action filed Oct. 26 attacks three linked measures. A November 2025 memo from USCIS Director Joseph Edlow stopped processing of green card applications from refugees admitted under the Biden administration and ordered those refugees re-reviewed and re-interviewed. An interim final rule published at 91 FR 65077 then took effect Oct. 14, 2026, without advance comment, and cut the response window in 8 CFR 207.9 from 30 days to 10. The plaintiffs, resettlement groups and four refugees from Afghanistan, Ethiopia, Colombia and Iran, argue the freeze and re-vetting have no footing in the Refugee Act of 1980 and that the rule skipped required public comment.
The scale is the reason the case matters. Reuters reported that about 113,000 refugee green card applications are pending. The plaintiffs say the 10-day rule could reach as many as 186,000 refugee cases. Their complaint, citing agency data, says USCIS decided 121 refugee adjustment applications from January through March 2026, compared with 17,569 in the same three months of 2025, a drop that tracks the collapse in refugee and asylee decisions in USCIS quarterly reports.
What each side told the court
An assistant U.S. attorney defended the measures as security steps, arguing that lax vetting in past years let “bad apples” in and justified a second look at everyone admitted under the prior administration. On the deadline, he told the court, “I believe it’s important to act swiftly when it’s determined that an individual is not entitled to refugee status,” according to Reuters. Erez Reuveni of Democracy Forward, who represents the plaintiffs, said more than 100,000 refugees were being put at risk.
Joun pressed on whether 10 days is realistic for gathering records, comparing it to renewing his dog’s license, which he said takes about 45 days. Bloomberg Law reported that he found nothing tying the shorter deadline to the national security concerns the government cited. That observation matters legally. An agency that skips notice and comment must show “good cause” under 5 U.S.C. 553(b)(B), and courts usually ask whether the stated emergency actually connects to the rule adopted.
Why the freeze is the harder claim, and the bigger one
Section 209 of the Immigration and Nationality Act, 8 U.S.C. 1159, requires refugees to come back for inspection after a year in the United States and lets them adjust with no annual numerical cap. It also backdates the green card to the refugee’s arrival date. That detail cuts both ways. A delayed card does not cost a refugee time toward naturalization, which weakens a harm argument. But until the card issues, the person remains a refugee whose status can be terminated under INA 207(c)(4), which is exactly where the 10-day rule bites. The freeze and the rule work as a pair: one keeps refugees in the category the other makes easier to end.
Challenging a hold is legally harder than challenging a rule. The plaintiffs must persuade Joun that an open-ended pause is either action unlawfully withheld or unreasonably delayed under the Administrative Procedure Act, or a final policy that exceeds the agency’s authority. The government’s best ground is the broad discretion the statute gives DHS over how and when it vets. Joun’s question about an “indefinite” halt suggests the duration, not the existence, of extra review is what troubles him, which points toward relief that sets limits rather than ends the re-vetting outright. The administration has signaled no softening on refugee policy, and an agency report this week urged keeping the refugee admissions ban into 2027.
What to watch
- Joun’s ruling on preliminary relief, which could address the green card hold, the re-interview order, the 10-day rule, or all three.
- Dec. 4, the date the existing pause on the 10-day rule was reported to run through.
- A final rule from DHS after comments on docket USCIS-2026-0397 closed Nov. 13, which could change the procedural fight.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Reuters: US judge questions Trump administration’s policies targeting refugees (Nov. 20, 2026)
- Bloomberg Law: Shortened Window for Refugees to Defend Status Troubles Judge (Nov. 20, 2026)
- Complaint, Partnership for the Advancement of New Americans v. Edlow, No. 1:26-cv-14817 (D. Mass., filed Oct. 26, 2026)
- Federal Register: Removing 30-Day Refugee Termination Notice, 91 FR 65077 (interim final rule, Oct. 14, 2026)
- 8 U.S.C. 1159 (INA Section 209), Adjustment of status of refugees
- Featured image: John J. Moakley Federal Courthouse, U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts photo (public domain)