AI Generated Image (not the actual court filing)
Lawyers for the class of children protected by the Flores settlement have asked a federal court in Los Angeles to rule that minors in U.S. Customs and Border Protection custody have a right to phone the attorneys who enforce that agreement. The motion for clarification, filed Nov. 13 as Docket No. 1837 in the long-running Flores case, No. 2:85-cv-04544 (C.D. Cal.), is set for a Dec. 18 hearing before Chief U.S. District Judge Dolly M. Gee, inewsource reported on Nov. 20.
The request sounds modest, and that is the point. If a child in a holding cell cannot reach the lawyers who enforce the settlement, enforcement depends largely on data the government reports, at a time when CBP holds children longer than its own standards allow.
Six phone numbers and a G-28
A declaration attached to the motion lays out what happened when class counsel tried to reach a child at a CBP facility in McAllen, Texas. Counsel called a public number and “was transferred or directed to six different additional numbers,” the declaration says. One agent said CBP policy was that the “client has to call you.” Counsel was then told to email a Form G-28, the attorney’s notice of appearance, to CBP’s Rio Grande Valley chief counsel office.
The same declaration cites data the government produced under Paragraph 28.A of the settlement on children held past 72 hours. Those records show one child held in CBP custody for 27 days and another for 11. At an Oct. 30 meet-and-confer, according to the declaration, the government “reiterated their position” that counsel and class members are “not entitled under the Settlement to confidential legal calls.”
In a Nov. 13 statement, the three groups serving as class counsel, the Center for Human Rights and Constitutional Law, the National Center for Youth Law and Children’s Rights, said CBP often does not let children use a phone even though interviews and telephonic hearings happen during detention. “We should not have to seek intervention of the Court to ensure that children can call their lawyers,” said Sarah Kahn, a senior staff attorney at the Center for Human Rights and Constitutional Law. DHS and CBP did not respond to inewsource, which reported that the government had not yet answered the motion.
A custody problem the court has already measured
Judge Gee’s August 2025 order found that CBP’s time in custody “likely violate[s]” the settlement. Her August 2026 order appointed a special master and independent monitor for CBP custody in the Rio Grande Valley, El Paso and San Diego sectors, finding that “it does not appear that CBP has been processing class members as expeditiously as possible.” The government figures in those orders show improvement that has not held.
| Period | Average CBP time in custody, family units (hours) |
|---|---|
| February 2025 | 177.39 |
| June 10, 2025 | 77.84 |
| March 2026 | 121.75 |
| June 10, 2026 | 85.81 |
The 2026 order put the number of minors held more than 72 hours at about 156 in March and about 164 in May. Every average in the table exceeds 72 hours, the general limit in CBP’s own custody standards.
Phone access is not new to the case. The 2025 order noted the plaintiffs’ allegation that CBP “denies access to telephones” but granted no relief because their proposed order had not asked for any. The new filing closes that gap.
Why clarification, not enforcement
The choice of motion matters. A motion to enforce asks a judge to find a breach. A motion for clarification asks the court to say what the agreement already means. If Judge Gee reads the settlement to include calls to class counsel, CBP would have to build a way to place them, likely starting in the three sectors the monitor already covers. The government’s position, as the declaration describes it, is that the settlement creates no such entitlement.
Any ruling lands on unsettled ground. The government’s bid to terminate the settlement is pending at the Ninth Circuit in No. 25-6308, and its appeal of the 2025 order is pending in No. 25-6567. A win for either side could be short-lived if the appeals court ends the agreement. Until then, a child in a CBP cell reaches a lawyer only when the agency allows a call.
Related coverage: Dilley detention center hearings, a Louisiana site testing limits on holding migrant children, the MVM family separation settlement and October’s record-low border encounters.
What to watch
- Government response: the opposition brief to Docket No. 1837, due before the hearing.
- Dec. 18: hearing before Chief Judge Gee in Los Angeles, per inewsource.
- Ninth Circuit: argument and decision in the termination appeal, No. 25-6308.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Flores, Motion for Clarification re Legal Calls and declaration, Dkt. 1837 (C.D. Cal., filed Nov. 13, 2026)
- Flores, Order Discharging Order to Show Cause and Appointing Special Master and Independent Monitor, Dkt. 1827 (Aug. 17, 2026)
- Flores, Order re Plaintiffs’ Motion to Enforce, Dkt. 1638 (Aug. 15, 2025)
- Defendants-Appellants’ Response, Ninth Circuit No. 25-6567 (Mar. 16, 2026)
- Children’s Rights, statement of Flores class counsel (Nov. 13, 2026)
- inewsource: Migrant children in Border Patrol custody are being denied phone calls, attorneys say (Nov. 20, 2026)