AI Generated Image (not the people studied in this report)
A new Cato Institute study puts the immigrant fiscal impact on American governments at a $14.6 trillion reduction in federal, state and local deficits from 1900 through 2023. The libertarian think tank’s paper, released Nov. 17, argues that immigrants paid more in taxes than they received in benefits in every one of those 124 years, and that their net contribution relative to the economy is about twice what it was in the early 20th century.
The timing matters. Deportations are running near historic highs, legal admissions are falling, and a Democratic Congress takes over in January with immigration bills queued. Fiscal claims sit at the center of that fight. This week a study by Harvard economist George Borjas reported a wage penalty for US workers in high-skill fields, and last month the White House circulated a $166,716 per-person cost estimate for illegal immigration. The Cato paper is the broadest counterweight yet on the budget side.
What the Cato immigrant fiscal impact study measures
Policy Analysis No. 1024, by David J. Bier and Julián Salazar, extends a February 2026 Cato model covering 1994 to 2023 that uses Census Bureau survey data and a framework adapted from the National Academies of Sciences. Earlier years rely on an indirect method that the authors say tracks the detailed model within 1 percent where the two overlap. Taxes are assigned by immigrants’ share of income; spending on schools, prisons, Social Security and welfare by their share of users; most other spending by population share.
| Measure | 1913 | 2023 |
|---|---|---|
| Immigrants’ net fiscal surplus | $11 billion (2024 dollars) | About $585 billion |
| Surplus as share of GDP | 0.8% | About 2.1% |
| Immigrant share of government spending | 9.7% | 7.8% |
| Immigrant share of government revenue | 21.7% | 17.4% |
| Net surplus per immigrant | $796 | $11,899 |
According to the study, 86 percent of the cumulative surplus accrued after 1965, the year Congress replaced national-origin quotas with today’s family and employment preference system.
The assumptions that drive the number
Public goods. The single biggest choice in any fiscal estimate is how to treat spending that does not grow when the population does. Cato assigns immigrants none of the cost of defense, veterans and foreign affairs (12.9 percent of 2023 spending), science and subsidies (1.5 percent), or interest on past debt (13.5 percent). The authors call that conservative; it is also the assumption that does the most work.
The National Academies’ 2016 report, the reference point for nearly everyone in this debate, showed why it matters. Under its baseline, first-generation immigrants’ combined fiscal impact from 1994 to 2013 was less favorable than that of the native-born. Assigning immigrants zero cost for public goods flipped the comparison in their favor. The same report found long-run effects generally positive at the federal level and generally negative for states and localities, largely because of the cost of educating immigrants’ children.
Children. Cato counts US-born children only in households where both parents are immigrants. Including them cuts the 124-year total to $6.3 trillion, a reduction of more than half, based on the study’s own figures. Children in mixed households are left out entirely, which tends to understate education costs.
Legal status. Census data cannot separate legal from unauthorized immigrants, so the 1900 to 2023 series does not either. The paper cites a Pew Research Center estimate that about 27 percent of immigrants were unauthorized in 2023.
How it compares with other estimates
The Congressional Budget Office, using a narrower federal-only lens, projected in July 2024 that the recent immigration surge would lower federal deficits by $0.9 trillion over 2024 to 2034. CBO did not estimate state and local effects and said they were likely to be net costs.
The Center for Immigration Studies, which favors lower immigration levels, reaches a sharply different result for one group. Its research director, Steven Camarota, told a House Oversight subcommittee in September 2024 that each illegal immigrant imposes a lifetime net fiscal cost of $68,390, using scenarios from the National Academies model. No outside group had published a response to the new Cato paper as of Nov. 18.
The gap between these numbers is less a dispute over data than over accounting rules: whether newcomers share the cost of the Navy and the national debt, whether their children’s schooling is a cost or an investment, and whether the population being measured is all immigrants or one subset.
Where the study could land in policy fights
The authors caution that pre-1940 figures are indirect and that results could change if tax rates fall, benefits expand or the immigrant population’s makeup shifts. That last caveat is the live one: the OECD reported a 14 percent fall in US permanent immigration in 2025, and the administration’s deportation push set new records in fiscal 2026.
The study is likely to surface in next year’s arguments over scoring legalization bills and enforcement budgets. Supporters of higher immigration will cite the long-run surplus; advocates of lower levels will point to the public-goods assumption and the state and local costs the National Academies documented.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Cato Institute, Policy Analysis No. 1024, “Immigrants’ Historical Effects on Government Budgets: 1900–2023” (Nov. 17, 2026)
- Cato Institute blog, study announcement (Nov. 17, 2026)
- National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, “The Economic and Fiscal Consequences of Immigration” (2016)
- Congressional Budget Office, “Effects of the Immigration Surge on the Federal Budget and the Economy” (July 2024)
- Steven Camarota, Center for Immigration Studies, testimony to the House Oversight Committee (Sept. 2024)