AI Generated Image (not the people or courtroom in this story)
The Justice Department has a new chief immigration judge: Jamee E. Comans, a former Immigration and Customs Enforcement trial attorney and Louisiana immigration judge, now runs the office that sets operating policy for the nation’s immigration courts. The Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) lists her as appointed in November 2026, taking over a system that has shed hundreds of thousands of pending cases in a year and is about to absorb a new 10-day appeal deadline.
The clearest record of the change is EOIR’s Office of the Chief Immigration Judge page, updated Nov. 16, which now carries her biography at the top, along with that of a newly appointed assistant chief, Brian J. Counihan. For the more than 3.3 million cases pending before the courts, and the lawyers on both sides, the question is what kind of manager she will be.
A career on both sides of the courtroom well
Comans spent most of her legal career on the government’s side of removal cases. According to her EOIR biography, she was an assistant chief counsel with ICE’s Office of the Principal Legal Advisor in Memphis from 2012 to 2018, then deputy chief counsel in Jena and Oakdale, Louisiana, until 2021. She took the bench at the LaSalle Immigration Court in 2021, became an assistant chief immigration judge in January 2023 overseeing courts first in Baltimore and Hyattsville and later in LaSalle, Oakdale, New Orleans and Baton Rouge, and moved to EOIR’s policy office as acting assistant director in December 2025, holding the permanent post from June to October 2026. She also served in the Navy Reserve from 2001 to 2022, including as an intelligence officer.
Her name is already familiar outside immigration circles. In April 2025, presiding in the courtroom inside the ICE detention center in Jena, she found that the government’s determination that former Columbia graduate student Mahmoud Khalil’s presence carried adverse foreign policy consequences was “facially reasonable,” making him deportable, CBS News reported at the time. The ruling rested on a memo from Secretary of State Marco Rubio.
Counihan, a former ICE trial attorney and state prosecutor who sat as an immigration judge in Batavia and Buffalo, New York, follows a similar arc. EOIR’s page also shows three regional deputy chief judges appointed between July and October 2026, so almost the whole top tier of court management has turned over in five months.
What the chief immigration judge controls, and what she does not
The chief immigration judge does not decide cases. The office “establishes operating policies and oversees policy implementation for the immigration courts,” in EOIR’s words, and sets priorities for judges in 72 immigration courts and three adjudication centers. In practice that means docketing priorities, case-management directives, scheduling rules, judge assignments and performance expectations. A directive on how fast detained cases must move, or when continuances may be granted, can reshape thousands of hearings without any judge’s ruling changing.
Much of the workforce she inherits is new to the bench. EOIR data show 753 immigration judges on board at the end of fiscal 2026, 312 of them hired during that year, or about 41 percent based on EOIR figures. Pending cases fell from 3,722,534 at the end of fiscal 2025 to 3,300,793 at the end of fiscal 2026, an 11.3 percent drop calculated from EOIR data, as judges completed 973,669 cases against 528,889 new receipts. TRAC, the Syracuse University data center, counted a lower 3,037,800 active cases at the end of September 2026 under a different method.
The timing compounds the job. The Justice Department’s final rule on Board of Immigration Appeals procedures, published Nov. 17, cuts the time to appeal an immigration judge’s decision to 10 days starting Dec. 17. That puts new weight on how quickly courts serve written decisions and how judges handle oral rulings, both areas the chief judge’s office can shape through guidance. Practitioners already counting the shorter deadline will watch for any memo on service of decisions.
Both new managers came up as ICE trial attorneys, and supporters and critics of the administration’s enforcement agenda are likely to read that background differently. Her years on detained dockets in Louisiana, at the prosecution table and on the bench, bear directly on the hardest-pressed corner of the system. The record so far is a résumé, not a policy. Her first operating policies and procedures memoranda will be the real test, and the ongoing fight over immigration judges’ independence gives every such memo a wider audience than usual.
What to watch
- New OCIJ memoranda: any operating policies on continuances, detained dockets or service of decisions issued under Comans.
- EOIR’s next quarterly data: whether completions keep outpacing receipts as the new judges settle in.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- EOIR, Office of the Chief Immigration Judge leadership biographies (updated Nov. 16, 2026)
- EOIR Adjudication Statistics: Pending Cases, New Cases and Total Completions (data generated Oct. 22, 2026)
- EOIR Adjudication Statistics: Immigration Judge Hiring (FY 2026)
- Federal Register, Appellate Procedures for the Board of Immigration Appeals, final rule (Nov. 17, 2026)
- TRAC Immigration Court Quick Facts (through September 2026)
- CBS News, ruling in Mahmoud Khalil’s immigration case (April 11, 2025)