AI Generated Image (not the people or facilities involved in this story)
The Seventh Circuit sent a deported man’s motion to reopen back to the BIA, holding that the Board ignored his equitable-tolling request and confused a U visa with the inadmissibility waiver he asked an immigration judge to grant.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit on Nov. 10, 2026, granted a petition for review in Panton v. Blanche, No. 25-2528, and remanded to the Board of Immigration Appeals. Judge Frank H. Easterbrook wrote the signed opinion for a panel that included Judges Michael Y. Scudder and John Z. Lee, after oral argument on Oct. 26. The court held that the Board’s denial of Robert Savio Panton’s motion to reopen could not stand because the Board never addressed the arguments he actually made.
For practitioners, the ruling matters for three reasons. It reaffirms that the 90-day motion-to-reopen deadline is not jurisdictional and can be equitably tolled. It separates a U visa, which only U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services can grant, from the inadmissibility waiver under 8 U.S.C. § 1182(d)(3)(A), which Seventh Circuit precedent says immigration judges can also grant. And it flags open waiver questions that the Supreme Court may soon touch.
The case
According to the opinion, Panton came to the United States from Jamaica as a lawful permanent resident in 1970, when he was four. He was convicted in 1992 for taking part in a large drug conspiracy in the late 1980s and sentenced to life in prison. A district court granted compassionate release in 2020, and removal proceedings began the day he left prison. An immigration judge ordered him removed after rejecting a Convention Against Torture claim, and the Seventh Circuit denied review in a June 15, 2023, nonprecedential order.
Panton had also applied for a U visa as a crime victim, and that petition is still pending with the Department of Homeland Security. The New York Police Department took about three years to sign the required law-enforcement certification, finally doing so on Dec. 11, 2023. Panton then moved to reopen so an immigration judge could waive his inadmissibility. In the alternative, he asked the Board to close his case while DHS decides the U visa. The opinion notes he has since been removed to Jamaica.
What the court held
Equitable tolling. The Board treated the motion as more than 90 days late and said sua sponte reopening was the only option left. The panel said the 90-day limit is not jurisdictional and can be extended on equitable grounds, citing Mejia-Padilla v. Garland (7th Cir. 2021), Ramos-Braga v. Sessions (7th Cir. 2018) and, by comparison, the Supreme Court’s 2025 decision in Riley v. Bondi. “The Board ignored the possibility of equitable tolling,” the court wrote, even though Panton had asked for it explicitly. The court called the Board’s statement that he had claimed no exception false. It did not decide whether tolling applies; that is for the Board on remand.
Visa versus waiver. The Board reasoned that only USCIS can issue U visas. The panel agreed that is true but said it has nothing to do with Panton’s request, which was for an immigration judge to waive inadmissibility under § 1182(d)(3)(A). The Board, the court said, seemingly treated the two as the same. The opinion points to circuit precedent recognizing immigration judges’ authority to grant such waivers, L.D.G. v. Holder (2014) and Baez-Sanchez v. Sessions (2017), later enforced in Baez-Sanchez v. Barr (2020).
Closure. The Board “did not so much as mention” Panton’s alternative request to close proceedings while DHS acts on the U visa, the court said.
Harmless error and Chenery. Government counsel conceded that the Board had confused a visa with a waiver and had not responded to Panton’s arguments, but argued the errors were harmless. The court was not persuaded, saying it would be hard to call the error harmless unless the open waiver questions were resolved against Panton. Relying on SEC v. Chenery Corp. and the Supreme Court’s 2025 decision in FDA v. Wages and White Lion Investments, it said an agency decision rests on the agency’s own reasons, not on new reasons offered by its lawyers in court. When those reasons are deficient, the court wrote, “the normal course is a remand so that the agency can reconsider.”
What the court left open
The panel expressly did not resolve several questions the government raised. These include whether a retroactive waiver can come only from DHS (as the Third Circuit held in Sunday v. Attorney General, 2016), and whether the Attorney General’s waiver authority has passed to DHS. Both remain open in the Seventh Circuit, the court said. It also noted that a government argument about who counts as “seeking admission” under § 1182(d)(3)(A)(ii) is in tension with the circuit’s 2026 decision in Cirrus Rojas v. Olson (cert. petition pending, No. 26-572), and that the Supreme Court will decide Roney v. Barbosa da Cunha, No. 26-104 (cert. granted Oct. 1, 2026). Because Panton is now outside the United States, the court suggested that tension may not matter to him.
The Board does not have to revisit its refusal to reopen on its own motion. The court said that decision is not judicially reviewable, citing Anaya-Aguilar v. Holder (2012). The opinion does not discuss the post-departure bar.
Practical takeaways
- Ask for tolling explicitly, and show why. Panton’s express request is what made the Board’s silence reversible. Delays in law-enforcement certification are a concrete reason a U visa applicant may miss the 90-day window.
- Frame the relief precisely. In motions tied to a pending U visa, separate the visa (USCIS) from the § 1182(d)(3)(A) waiver (available from an immigration judge under Seventh Circuit law), and request closure in the alternative.
- Watch for confessed error. When government counsel concedes the Board misread a motion, Chenery limits how far harmless-error arguments can rescue the decision.
- Outside the Seventh Circuit, check local law. The opinion cites decisions from the Third, Fourth and Eleventh Circuits on waiver authority; practitioners elsewhere should confirm their own circuit’s rule.
Dates and decisions to watch
- BIA decision on remand in Panton’s case (no deadline set).
- DHS action on Panton’s pending U visa petition.
- Roney v. Barbosa da Cunha, No. 26-104: Supreme Court merits decision.
- Cirrus Rojas v. Olson, No. 26-572: pending cert. petition.
Related coverage: BIA Appeal Final Rule Explained: 10-Day Deadline, Summary Dismissal and Reinstatement Order Appeal: Tenth Circuit Shuts Door on Late Filings.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Panton v. Blanche, No. 25-2528, opinion — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, Nov. 10, 2026
- 7th Circ. Orders BIA To Reconsider Deported Man’s Visa Bid — Law360, November 2026
- Seventh Circuit Sends Panton’s Motion Back to the BIA — VisaVerge, Nov. 12, 2026
- 8 U.S.C. § 1182 (inadmissible aliens; waivers) — Cornell LII