AI Generated Image
A peer-reviewed study of hedge funds found that firms which won more H-1B visas in the random lottery went on to earn higher risk-adjusted returns, while hiring fewer domestic STEM workers.
A new H-1B hedge fund study published in the journal Management Science finds that investment firms which happened to win more H-1B visas in the government’s random lottery delivered measurably better performance afterward. The research, by economists Jun Chen, Shenje Hshieh, Melvyn Teo and Feng Zhang, arrives as the H-1B program operates under a $100,000 payment requirement and a reworked selection system, which gives its findings fresh policy relevance.
Most arguments about H-1B workers rest on wage comparisons or anecdotes. This study uses the lottery as a natural experiment: when demand exceeds the cap, two similar firms can end up with very different numbers of visas through luck alone, which lets researchers measure what the workers added rather than what firms say they added.
What the H-1B hedge fund study measured
The authors matched monthly fund returns from October 2000 to September 2016 with roughly 5.5 million Form I-129 petitions obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request, plus Labor Department labor condition application data. The lottery tests use 2008, 2009 and 2014 through 2016; a second test uses the fiscal 2004 drop in the annual cap from 195,000 to 65,000, when a temporary increase enacted by Congress expired.
| Measure | Reported result |
|---|---|
| Funds hiring at least one H-1B worker vs. funds hiring none | 2.16 percentage points a year higher risk-adjusted return |
| One standard deviation (42.7 points) higher lottery success | 1.46 points higher annual return; 2.09 points higher alpha |
| Top vs. bottom portfolio by lottery win rate | 3.28 points a year, after risk adjustment |
| H-1B-dependent funds after the FY2004 cap cut | Return down 3.00 points; alpha down 5.46 points a year |
| Share of hedge funds hiring H-1B workers in a given year | 13.5% of funds, managing 28.4% of industry assets |
The authors attribute the gains to H-1B workers helping funds build distinctive strategies, exploit well-known stock anomalies and get around capacity limits. They also report that alpha generation was greatest among workers from countries with the longest waits for permanent residency, in practice mainly workers from India and China, who face the longest employment-based green card backlogs.
The finding both sides of the debate can use
The study does not settle the labor-market argument, and one of its results cuts the other way. Funds that secured more H-1B workers posted fewer job openings for domestic STEM workers, even as they posted more for domestic workers with complementary skills outside economics, finance and STEM. Supporters can point to productivity and spillover hiring; critics can point to substitution in the technical roles American graduates want.
That second reading lines up with the White House’s stated rationale. Proclamation 10973, signed Sept. 19, 2025, said the program “has been deliberately exploited to replace, rather than supplement, American workers with lower-paid, lower-skilled labor,” and conditioned entry for covered new petitions on a $100,000 payment. A follow-on proclamation signed Sept. 18, 2026 extended the restriction to Sept. 21, 2027. The Cato Institute, a libertarian think tank, published a summary of the study by its authors on Nov. 11, which ties the results to the debate over restrictions on high-skilled immigration.
Readers should keep the limits in view. Hedge funds are a small, high-paying corner of the H-1B universe, and quantitative finance is exactly where specialized skills are easiest to monetize. The data end in 2016, well before the current fee and the proposed repeal of the 60-day grace period. The results say little about staffing firms or the outsourcing model the administration has targeted.
Why the next study will look different
The research design depended on a purely random draw, and that draw no longer exists in the same form. DHS has moved to a selection process weighted toward higher wage levels, which is likely to favor exactly the kind of high-salary employer this study examined. Combined with the $100,000 payment, the practical effect is a program tilted toward firms that can pay the most, such as quantitative funds, and away from lower-wage sponsors. Whether that sorting produces the productivity gains this study found, or simply narrows who gets visas, is the open question the next round of data will answer.
For employers, the more immediate signals are the prevailing wage final rule now at the White House, which would raise required pay levels, and corporate retreats such as IBM’s end to visa sponsorship for most consulting roles. The Cisco hiring bias case shows how much of the fight now turns on H-1B data.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Chen, Hshieh, Teo and Zhang, “Immigrants in Finance: Evidence from Hedge Funds,” Management Science (2026)
- Cato Institute, Research Briefs in Economic Policy No. 509 (Nov. 11, 2026)
- Proclamation 10973, Restriction on Entry of Certain Nonimmigrant Workers (Sept. 19, 2025)
- Proclamation extending the H-1B entry restriction to Sept. 21, 2027 (Federal Register public inspection, Sept. 2026)
- USCIS: DHS Changes Process for Awarding H-1B Work Visas