AI Generated Image (not the actual subpoena)
New Jersey wants a federal judge to force DHS to say yes or no on releasing medical and use-of-force records from the Delaney Hall immigration detention center in Newark.
The Delaney Hall lawsuit filed Nov. 17 moves New Jersey’s fight over the Newark immigration detention center from inspectors at the door to a federal courtroom in Washington. Attorney General Jennifer Davenport sued the Department of Homeland Security, saying the agency has sat for three months on a state civil rights subpoena for records about how detainees are treated, leaving the private operator, GEO Group, unable to answer. The case does not ask a judge to rule on conditions inside the facility. It asks something narrower and, for states, more consequential: whether DHS can block a state investigation of an ICE contractor simply by not deciding.
- Court: federal court in Washington, D.C., according to Politico and News 12 New Jersey.
- Claim: unreasonable agency delay under the Administrative Procedure Act, Patch reported, with the state asking for a firm deadline for DHS to decide.
- The subpoena: issued in August to GEO Group under New Jersey’s Civil Rights Act and Law Against Discrimination, seeking records on medical care, use of force, injuries and facility conditions, News 12 reported.
- The facility: a 1,000-bed center that reopened in May 2025, where three detainees have died in federal custody, according to Politico.
Why GEO says it cannot answer New Jersey
The procedural knot is a federal regulation most people outside immigration practice have never heard of. Under 8 C.F.R. 236.6, no state or local government or privately operated facility that houses ICE detainees may disclose information about those detainees; the regulation treats that information as federal records controlled by federal law. DHS also has “Touhy” regulations, at 6 C.F.R. Part 5, that require its approval before employees or records are produced in response to subpoenas in cases where the United States is not a party. Put together, a state that subpoenas a private jail contractor about detainee care runs into a wall the contractor did not build.
That is what New Jersey says happened. GEO told the state it could not comply without DHS authorization and forwarded the request, News 12 reported, and the complaint says GEO’s refusal came “at the direction of DHS,” according to Politico. The state says repeated requests over the past three months produced no decision. “There are far too many reports of inhumane treatment of the people held at Delaney Hall,” Davenport said, as quoted by Politico. “But what we have received for months from both GEO Group and DHS is plain stonewalling.”
DHS did not immediately respond to Politico, and GEO deferred to the department. When New Jersey sued GEO in June to win full access for health inspectors, DHS called that suit “frivolous” and said “ICE is committed to transparency, and Delaney Hall complies with all required state and local laws,” NJBIZ reported at the time. Politico also reported that an ICE compliance inspection in September found 22 deficiencies but rated the facility acceptable.
A delay claim, not a conditions case
The choice of an APA delay claim is telling. Section 706(1) lets a court “compel agency action unlawfully withheld or unreasonably delayed,” and in the D.C. Circuit such claims are judged under the six-factor test from Telecommunications Research and Action Center v. FCC (1984), which weighs how long the agency has taken, whether a statute sets a timetable, and whether human health and welfare are at stake. That last factor is where New Jersey’s allegations about medical care and three deaths do their work. A three-month wait is short by the standard of many delay cases, so the state’s best argument is that the stakes, not the calendar, make the delay unreasonable.
Even a win would be modest on its face. The relief New Jersey describes is an order requiring DHS to decide and notify the state and GEO, News 12 reported, not an order releasing the records. DHS could decide to refuse, and that refusal would set up a second, harder fight over whether the federal government can shield a contractor’s records from a state civil rights investigation at all. That is the question with reach beyond New Jersey. Oversight fights over immigration detention are multiplying, from a Senate probe of the Appleton facility purchase to a lawsuit over the ICE detainee locator, as private operators reshape their detention portfolios.
For families of people held at Delaney Hall, nothing changes immediately. The state’s separate June case against GEO over health inspector access, filed in Superior Court in Essex County, remains pending, Patch reported. The next marker in the federal case is the government’s answer, ordinarily due 60 days after service when a federal agency is sued, unless DHS decides on the subpoena first and makes the delay claim moot.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources: Politico, New Jersey sues DHS for ‘stonewalling’ investigation at Delaney Hall detention center (Nov. 17, 2026); News 12 New Jersey, New Jersey sues DHS over Delaney Hall records request (Nov. 17, 2026); Patch, NJ sues Homeland Security after being ‘stonewalled’ about ICE prison (Nov. 17, 2026); NJBIZ, NJ sues Delaney Hall operator (June 2, 2026); 8 C.F.R. 236.6, Information regarding detainees; 6 C.F.R. Part 5, DHS disclosure regulations; 5 U.S.C. 706.