AI Generated Image (not an actual State Department document)
The case that struck down the 75-country immigrant visa ban has a new target: the public charge screening the State Department now applies to every immigrant visa applicant.
The public charge lawsuit that ended the State Department’s 75-country immigrant visa ban has been rewritten to go after the department’s worldwide public charge rules. In a First Amended and Supplemental Complaint filed Nov. 6 in Catholic Legal Immigration Network v. Rubio in federal court in Manhattan, legal service groups and immigrant visa applicants ask Judge Jeannette A. Vargas to “enjoin and vacate the Consular Rules,” a set of cables that the plaintiffs say now govern public charge decisions at consulates everywhere, not only for nationals of the 75 countries.
The original ban is already gone: Judge Vargas granted partial summary judgment on Aug. 21 and vacated the policy, which the department announced on Jan. 14, 2026, and made effective Jan. 21. The amended complaint argues that the screening that replaced it produces many of the same refusals through a different door.
What the public charge lawsuit now challenges
The complaint, brought by the Catholic Legal Immigration Network, African Communities Together and 19 individual plaintiffs, names three layers of policy:
- The Consular Processing Cable. Sent to consular officers worldwide on Nov. 6, 2025, it is the starting point, according to the complaint, for what the plaintiffs call “sweeping new discriminatory rules governing public-charge determinations.”
- The Public Charge Directives. Later cables, including ones dated Sept. 1 and Sept. 10, 2026, issued after the court vacated the ban.
- A “Review and Override Policy.” Cables and guidance from Sept. 14 and Sept. 21, 2026, that the complaint says set up “centralized supervisory and managerial review globally” and “impermissibly overrides officer discretion in order to achieve visa refusals.”
The legal theory rests on the text of the public charge ground, INA section 212(a)(4), 8 U.S.C. 1182(a)(4). The statute asks whether an applicant is likely to become a public charge and directs officers to weigh, at a minimum, age, health, family status, assets and financial status, and education and skills. The plaintiffs argue that inquiry is individualized and that the law “has never deemed a person inadmissible merely because they have received, or may one day need, non-cash public benefits.” They also invoke the Immigration and Nationality Act’s bar on nationality discrimination in immigrant visa issuance, 8 U.S.C. 1152(a)(1)(A), the Administrative Procedure Act, and the Accardi doctrine, which requires agencies to follow their own rules.
The department framed the original policy around risk. The January cable was titled “Pausing Immigrant Visa Issuances for Nationalities at High Risk of Public Charge,” and the department’s public notice on the policy was headed “Immigrant Visa Processing Updates for Nationalities at High Risk of U.S. Public Benefits Reliance.” No government response to the amended complaint appears in the filings reviewed for this article.
Why a global rule is a harder target than a country list
A ban sorted by nationality invited a challenge under the nondiscrimination provision; screening rules that apply to every applicant do not. Individual consular refusals are generally shielded from court review under the doctrine of consular nonreviewability, so the plaintiffs are careful to attack “final, Department-level policies,” the same approach that let the court rule on the ban. The open question is whether Judge Vargas sees the new cables as binding rules that dictate outcomes, as the plaintiffs say, or as guidance that leaves each decision to an officer, which would make them much harder to set aside.
In an Oct. 5 declaration, the department said officers had decided about 706 cases from Aug. 21 through Sept. 30 in which the ban was at least one ground for refusal: about 318 were issued or approved and about 388 were refused again on other grounds. The plaintiffs put refusals based solely on the ban at about 43,000. Every one of those reopened cases, and every new immigrant visa interview, now runs through the screening the amended complaint attacks, as earlier coverage of the expanded public charge interview describes.
The appeal also hangs over the case. On Oct. 19 the Second Circuit refused to pause the vacatur of the ban but paused the part of the judgment requiring new decisions on refusals based only on it, leaving applicants already refused dependent on the department’s internal review, as covered here in October. A ruling against the new cables would reach far more people than the original ban did, which makes another stay fight likely.
What to watch
- Nov. 20: the next joint case letter to Judge Vargas under the court’s Oct. 21 scheduling order.
- The government’s answer or motion to dismiss the amended complaint, which will show whether it argues the cables are unreviewable guidance.
- The Second Circuit panel’s ruling on the full stay motion in appeal No. 26-2573.
Background: the end of the 75-country immigrant visa pause and the judge’s refusal to pause her ruling.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- First Amended and Supplemental Complaint, Catholic Legal Immigration Network v. Rubio, No. 1:26-cv-00858 (S.D.N.Y. filed Nov. 6, 2026)
- Government’s response to order to show cause, with Oct. 5, 2026 declaration (adjudications Aug. 21 to Sept. 30, 2026)
- Plaintiffs’ proposed enforcement order (Oct. 15, 2026)
- Government’s notice of Second Circuit stay order, No. 26-2573 (Oct. 19, 2026)
- Scheduling order on amended complaint and joint case letter (Oct. 21, 2026)
- U.S. Department of State, Immigrant Visa Processing Updates for Nationalities at High Risk of U.S. Public Benefits Reliance
- 8 U.S.C. 1182(a)(4), public charge ground of inadmissibility