AI Generated Image (not the actual Stinesville agreement)
A county lawsuit in southern Indiana raises a question the federal 287(g) statute never answers: who inside a local government has the power to commit its officers to immigration enforcement.
A 287(g) agreement lawsuit filed by the Monroe County, Indiana, board of commissioners asks a state judge to void the immigration enforcement deal that the town of Stinesville’s top police officer signed with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement without a vote of the town board. The suit, filed Nov. 10 in Monroe Circuit Court and reported by The Herald-Times of Bloomington on Nov. 17, puts the county at odds with the town and with Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita, who concluded in a formal opinion on Oct. 6 that the officer needed no one’s approval.
The fight is about paperwork, but the stakes reach beyond one small town. ICE has added local partners quickly since early 2025, many of them small departments whose agreements carry a single local signature. If an Indiana court decides that was not enough, similar agreements in the state would be open to the same challenge.
What Monroe County wants a judge to do
According to The Herald-Times, the commissioners want a declaration that Stinesville’s agreement is void and an order barring the town’s officers from using the federal powers it grants. The county says Stinesville officers have made stops under the agreement in unincorporated parts of the county and have moved people out of the county jail. They describe the dispute as one of process, not immigration policy, and say requiring a council vote “does not prohibit participation” in the program.
Stinesville’s town board voted on Nov. 10, the same day the suit was filed, to ratify the agreement, the newspaper reported. The commissioners plan to argue in an amended filing that a vote taken after the agreement was signed and already in use cannot fix a defective approval.
The attorney general’s opinion
Rokita’s opinion, addressed to the Stinesville Town Board, responds to a September county resolution that called the agreement unauthorized. He concluded that the town’s chief of police “had legal authority to enter into the 287(g) agreement,” that no state law or local ordinance required the board’s approval first, and that Indiana’s Interlocal Cooperation Act, the statute the county relies on, “does not apply to agreements between local entities and federal agencies.” He also warned that withholding county money to discourage the agreement would violate Indiana Code 5-2-18.2, the state law barring local limits on cooperation with federal immigration enforcement, which carries civil penalties of up to $10,000 per violation.
Rokita’s office told The Herald-Times it had not yet been served and would continue to oppose county efforts to interfere with immigration enforcement.
A gap Congress left to the states
Section 287(g) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, codified at 8 U.S.C. 1357(g), lets the federal government enter a written agreement with “a State, or any political subdivision of a State” so that trained local officers can carry out certain immigration officer functions. Participation is voluntary, and the statute does not say which official can bind a city, town or county. That is left to state law, which is why this case turns on Indiana statutes.
Indiana practice has not been uniform. The Herald-Times reported that the councils in Waterloo and Andrews approved their agreements before signing, while the town of Claypool suspended its marshal in July after he signed one without council approval. Statewide, ICE data reviewed by The B Square Bulletin, a Bloomington news site, showed 45 agreements with 42 Indiana agencies as of Sept. 5, 2026.
Nationally, DHS said in September 2025 that the program had passed 1,000 partnerships. A later analysis by FWD.us, an immigration reform advocacy group, counted more than 29,000 state and local officers deputized under 287(g) between January 2025 and October 2026; DHS has described the program as a tool to reduce crime and illegal immigration.
What to watch in the Stinesville case
The ratification vote is likely to be the pivotal issue. Governing bodies can often approve an agent’s act after the fact, so the county will need to show that Indiana law demanded approval in advance or that a later vote cannot rescue stops already made. A ruling for the county would mean elected boards, not chiefs or marshals, must sign off, which would slow participation but not bar it. A ruling for the town would confirm Rokita’s reading statewide.
Fights over local cooperation are also playing out elsewhere, from the New York sheriffs’ challenge to that state’s 287(g) ban to Houston’s cooperation order under Texas law. For checking a local department, see how to tell if local police work with ICE.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- The Herald-Times: Monroe County lawsuit challenges authority behind ICE agreements (Nov. 17, 2026)
- Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita, opinion letter to the Stinesville Town Board (Oct. 6, 2026)
- 8 U.S.C. 1357(g), Immigration and Nationality Act Section 287(g)
- DHS: 287(g) reaches more than 1,000 partnerships (Sept. 17, 2025)
- The B Square Bulletin: Indiana police agencies have signed dozens of ICE agreements (Sept. 6, 2026)
- NPR: Partnerships between ICE and local police surge, report finds (Oct. 28, 2026)