AI Generated Image (does not depict the Golden Bear or any real vessel)
ICE deportation ships are off the table, at least for now. Acting ICE Director David J. Venturella told two senior Democrats on the House Armed Services Committee in a letter sent Monday, Nov. 16, that the Department of Homeland Security “will not use ships” to remove people from the United States, The New York Times reported, closing out nearly six weeks of debate over whether a retiring California maritime training vessel, the Golden Bear, could be refitted to carry deportees to Central and South America.
The letter has not been made public, and so far the Times is the only established outlet to report its contents. According to the Times, Venturella wrote that DHS is “continually evaluating options for effective and efficient ways to carry out its missions” before ruling out vessels. Rep. John Garamendi, a California Democrat and senior Armed Services member, called the commitment a “major win for accountability.”
The idea surfaced on Oct. 8, when the Times reported that DHS and Defense Department officials were weighing ships for removals, with the Golden Bear among the vessels discussed. The roughly 40-year-old ship spent three decades training cadets at the Cal Poly Maritime Academy in Vallejo and is owned by the federal government through the Maritime Administration. A MARAD spokesperson told The Sacramento Bee in late October that the agency was maintaining the ship for the academy’s training needs until its replacement, the Golden State, arrives in summer 2027.
On Oct. 27, Garamendi and Rep. Salud Carbajal, the top Democrat on the House Coast Guard and Maritime Transportation Subcommittee, wrote to DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin urging him to drop any ship plan. Their letter warned of “enormous operational, safety and legal challenges,” according to Carbajal’s office, and argued that sea voyages would take days, tie up large numbers of security personnel and cost taxpayers millions of dollars. No public DHS reply to that letter was reported before this week, and no agency ever announced a decision to use the Golden Bear.
Why ICE deportation ships never made operational sense
The practical case against ships was always stronger than the political one. Removals from the interior run almost entirely on chartered aircraft, which move a full planeload of detainees to Guatemala, Honduras or El Salvador in a few hours. A vessel would hold people in federal custody for days at sea, raising the same detention-standards, medical-care and access-to-counsel questions that already shadow ICE’s land facilities, now in an environment where monitoring is far harder. The Coast Guard does return migrants it intercepts at sea, but that is a different program from carrying people already ordered removed from inside the country.
The wording of the letter matters too. “Will not use ships” is a policy statement, not a regulation or a binding commitment, and the line about continually evaluating options leaves the agency room to revisit transport methods later. Lawmakers who pressed the issue are likely to treat the letter as a marker they can cite in future oversight, including in the fight over Homeland Security funding and in hearings such as Mullin’s Nov. 18 House hearing.
For people facing removal, nothing changes in practice: deportations will keep moving by air and, at the southern border, by land. The broader questions about detention capacity and oversight remain live, as the New Jersey lawsuit over Delaney Hall and the surge in South Texas reentry prosecutions show.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- The New York Times, report on the ICE letter ruling out ships (Nov. 17, 2026)
- The New York Times, report on DHS and Pentagon discussions of deportation ships (Oct. 8, 2026)
- Office of Rep. Salud Carbajal, release on the Oct. 27 letter to Secretary Mullin (Oct. 28, 2026)
- The Sacramento Bee, report on the Golden Bear and MARAD’s statement (Oct. 29, 2026)