AI Generated Image (not the actual court order in this case)
A federal appeals court has paused the order requiring the government to bring Kenis Lopez Gonzalez back from the Central African Republic, leaving the Minnesota man in a third-country deportation limbo while the case is appealed. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit granted the government’s request to temporarily halt the district court’s return order, FOX 9 reported on Nov. 20, describing the decision as coming Thursday. The stay remains in place while the appeal proceeds.
The order reverses the practical result of two earlier rulings by U.S. District Judge Jeffrey Bryan. His Oct. 30 preliminary injunction in Lopez Gonzalez v. Mullin found that ICE likely violated its own regulation, 8 C.F.R. 241.13, when it revoked Lopez’s supervised release in January without the required notice, and told the government to arrange his return. Bryan then refused to pause that order on Nov. 9, which sent the government to the Eighth Circuit. Lopez, a Nicaraguan who ran a construction business in Minnesota, had been granted protection from removal to Nicaragua because of the risk of torture, before ICE flew him to the Central African Republic, a country where he has no ties.
The Eighth Circuit’s order could not be reviewed for this article, and FOX 9 did not report whether the panel explained its reasoning. The government’s arguments, as described in its filings, show what it asked the court to weigh. It said forcing officials to seek a deportee’s return “impermissibly interjects the court into” diplomacy with a foreign sovereign, and that the danger to Lopez is overstated because the Central African Republic gave diplomatic assurances that deportees would not be tortured or persecuted. His lawyer, Simon Sandoval-Moshenberg, told FOX 9, “we’re confident the law is on Mr. Lopez Gonzalez’s side.” He said Lopez has been diagnosed with malaria. The State Department rates the country at Level 4, “Do Not Travel,” its highest warning.
A stay pending appeal turns on the four factors in Nken v. Holder: likely success on the merits, irreparable harm, harm to others and the public interest. Bryan had found the balance of harms favored Lopez. An appellate stay suggests the panel saw at least a serious question on the merits or gave real weight to the foreign-affairs argument, though a stay is not a ruling on the appeal. The foreign-affairs point carries extra force after the Supreme Court in June 2025 stayed a nationwide order restricting third-country removals in DHS v. D.V.D., a signal that the justices are wary of lower courts managing deportations to other countries.
Bryan’s ruling rested on something narrower: a single release revocation that skipped ICE’s own procedure. That makes the appeal a test of whether a court that finds an unlawful arrest can order the government to undo a completed removal abroad. Similar orders in other third-country cases have run into the same question of compliance. For now, the weekly status reports Bryan required are likely to go quiet, and the next documents to watch are the Eighth Circuit’s briefing schedule and any request by Lopez’s lawyers to expedite the appeal.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources: FOX 9, “Appeals court pauses order to return Minnesota immigrant deported to Africa,” Nov. 20, 2026; Order granting preliminary injunction, Lopez Gonzalez v. Mullin, No. 26-cv-04507 (D. Minn. Oct. 30, 2026); 8 C.F.R. 241.13; State Department, Central African Republic travel advisory. Featured image: AI generated.