AI-generated illustration.
The Princeton student’s lawyers say she has a pending asylum case, a work permit and no criminal record, and argue ICE had no basis to arrest her without a warrant.
Lawyers for Eva Yi Xie, the Princeton neuroscience doctoral student detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement on Nov. 19, have filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, according to The Daily Princetonian. The case appears on the federal docket as Xie v. Warden, Detention Center, No. 1:26-cv-03839. Her attorney, Kerry Doyle, said Xie is an asylum seeker whose case is still pending in immigration court, with a hearing set for early 2028.
That fills in the biggest gap in the story so far. As reported earlier, her immigration status and the reason for the arrest had not been disclosed. ICE still has not given a reason, according to Doyle, and the agency did not respond to the Princetonian’s requests for comment.
What her lawyers say about her status
According to Doyle’s account to the Princetonian and The Washington Post, as summarized by IBTimes:
- Arrival. Xie came to the United States from China in 2016 as a minor and entered lawfully. Her original visa later expired.
- Asylum. Her family applied for asylum within a year of arriving. The claim was later referred to immigration court; Doyle said she does not yet know when. IBTimes reported the hearing date as January 2028.
- Work authorization and record. Doyle told the Post that Xie holds valid employment authorization and has no criminal history.
Doyle is a partner at Green & Spiegel and formerly served as ICE’s principal legal adviser and as a DHS deputy general counsel; the Princetonian reported that the university arranged her representation. A Virginia law office is co-counsel. Xie remained Friday at ICE’s holding site in Chantilly, Virginia, both outlets reported.
The legal argument: a warrantless arrest
The petition’s core claim, as described by her lawyers, is that ICE arrested Xie without a warrant when nothing justified skipping one: there was no recent change in her circumstances and no sign she was about to leave the country. They ask the court to order her release.
The argument tracks the statute. Under 8 U.S.C. 1357(a)(2), an immigration officer may arrest without a warrant only with reason to believe the person is in the country unlawfully and is likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained. A person who has lived openly at the same address for years, attends a university and has a scheduled court date is, her lawyers argue, the opposite of a flight risk. Courts have taken that requirement seriously in recent cases, including a Maine ruling this week that found a warrantless arrest of a teenager unlawful.
The Princetonian has also reported that a judge ordered ICE not to move Xie out of Virginia. The text of that order, the judge’s name and any hearing schedule were not available for review at publication. Orders of that kind are common in detention habeas cases, because they keep a detainee within reach of the court while it decides the petition.
Can ICE detain someone with a pending asylum case?
Yes. A pending asylum application protects a person from being removed while the case is decided, but it does not by itself bar detention. ICE can hold people in removal proceedings, and a work permit based on a pending asylum claim does not change that. What a pending case does is give the person a route to challenge custody: a bond request before an immigration judge, where the discretionary detention provision applies, or a habeas petition in federal court arguing that the arrest or detention itself is unlawful. Xie’s lawyers have chosen the federal route.
Reactions
Sen. Cory Booker, D-N.J., said in a written statement to the Princetonian that his office had contacted ICE and had not received a response, and that he expects “a prompt and full explanation.” Sen. Andy Kim’s office said it is in direct contact with Xie and working on the case. Graduate School Dean Rodney Priestley said the university hopes she can soon resume her studies.
Quick answers
Why was Eva Yi Xie detained? ICE has not said. Her lawyer says no reason was given.
What is her immigration status? According to her lawyer, she is an asylum applicant with a pending immigration court case, a work permit and no criminal record.
Where is she held? At ICE’s holding site in Chantilly, Virginia, as of Nov. 20.
What happens next? The government will be expected to respond to the habeas petition in the Eastern District of Virginia, which could order her release or deny the petition.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- The Daily Princetonian: Xie, a Princeton Ph.D. student and asylum seeker (Nov. 20, 2026)
- CourtListener: Xie v. Warden, Detention Center, No. 1:26-cv-03839 (E.D. Va.)
- IBTimes: ICE Detains Princeton PhD Student After Science Conference (Nov. 20, 2026)
- 8 U.S.C. 1357, Cornell Legal Information Institute
- Princeton Alumni Weekly: Neuroscience Doctoral Student Detained by ICE (Nov. 20, 2026)