The Kenneth B. Keating Federal Building and U.S. Courthouse in downtown Rochester, N.Y., where CBP had sought space for a Border Patrol station with holding cells. Photo: General Services Administration (2007), via the Federal Judicial Center (public domain, U.S. government work).
U.S. Customs and Border Protection has dropped its plan to put a Rochester Border Patrol station, complete with holding cells, inside the Kenneth B. Keating Federal Building, the downtown tower that also houses the city’s federal courts. New York Sens. Chuck Schumer and Kirsten Gillibrand and Rep. Joe Morelle announced on Nov. 20 that the General Services Administration had told the U.S. District Court for the Western District of New York that CBP withdrew its request for new space in the building and would look at other options.
The decision ends, for now, a nine-month fight over a project that would have put immigration holding cells on the same floor as some judges’ chambers and, according to WXXI News, one floor above a child care center. Neither CBP nor GSA has made a public statement, and the Democrat and Chronicle and WXXI reported that CBP did not respond to their questions.
What CBP wanted to build on State Street
Border Patrol works out of leased space on Pattonwood Drive in Irondequoit. CBP has sought a downtown move since 2019, WXXI reported, and GSA pitched the federal building as a way to save on that lease. In late February, GSA moved to give CBP the former first-floor post office space over objections from court administrators.
The design grew more contentious as details surfaced. A March 5 letter from Schumer, Gillibrand and Morelle said a 2021 version of the plan envisioned holds of roughly one to three hours, while the newer plan reportedly contemplated round-the-clock detention and multi-day holds. In May, Morelle said DHS had described detention holding areas, secure transfer zones and expanded perimeter fencing, with construction set to begin May 23. WXXI described at least three temporary holding cells plus K9 kennels; the Democrat and Chronicle, citing earlier documents, said the cells could hold people for up to 72 hours. Construction never started on schedule, WHAM reported.
That 72-hour figure is not arbitrary. CBP’s National Standards on Transport, Escort, Detention, and Search (TEDS) say detainees generally should not be held in CBP hold rooms longer than 72 hours. A site built to that ceiling is a processing station rather than an ICE detention center, but it is where an arrest becomes custody: fingerprints, records checks, and the decision to release, issue a Notice to Appear or transfer the person to ICE.
Why the withdrawal is narrower than it sounds
Nothing announced on Friday limits Border Patrol’s work in western New York. Rochester sits on Lake Ontario, an international boundary, and agents’ statutory search authority near the border extends up to a “reasonable distance,” which federal regulations set at 100 air miles from an external boundary. The agency still needs a station, and the Democrat and Chronicle noted that the withdrawal does not rule out a holding facility elsewhere in the Rochester area.
The court’s role also needs a careful reading. GSA’s notice went to the court, but no lawsuit over the project appears in public dockets. The district court is a tenant of the building, and its administrators objected to the plan as occupants. The practical effect is an administrative retreat, not a ruling, so nothing legally stops CBP from reviving a version of the plan.
The lawmakers framed it as a community win. Morelle called it “a major victory for the people of Rochester,” and Schumer said Border Patrol “needs to be reined in and reformed from top to bottom – not expanded,” according to WHAM. Mayor Malik Evans said in a statement reported by WROC that the administration “backed down because we fought back from day one.” Federal officials have not given their own reason for pulling the request. The lawmakers said they remain opposed to new or expanded Border Patrol detention in the region, where ICE’s Batavia facility is already drawing scrutiny.
Local pushback is increasingly shaping where federal custody lands, from the Tacoma detention center sale to the Marana license fight, while the GAO questions ICE’s detention spending and lawyers press for phone access for children in CBP cells.
What to watch
- A new site: any GSA lease solicitation or CBP request for Border Patrol space elsewhere in Monroe County.
- The Irondequoit lease: whether Border Patrol stays at Pattonwood Drive while it looks.
- Funding: the Dec. 11 deadline for FY2027 appropriations, which sets CBP’s facilities budget for the year.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- WXXI News: Feds abandon plans for Border Patrol station in downtown Rochester (Nov. 20, 2026)
- Democrat and Chronicle: Border Patrol drops Rochester detention center plan (Nov. 20, 2026)
- WHAM: Trump admin no longer planning detention center in downtown Rochester, Democrats say (Nov. 20, 2026)
- WROC: ICE detention facility plans in downtown Rochester halted (Nov. 20, 2026)
- Schumer, Gillibrand and Morelle letter on the proposed Rochester facility (March 5, 2026)
- Rep. Joe Morelle statement on DHS construction plans (May 2026)
- WXXI News: Rochester’s federal courthouse could double as immigrant detention center (Feb. 27, 2026)
- CBP National Standards on Transport, Escort, Detention, and Search (2015)
- 8 CFR 287.1, definition of “reasonable distance”
- Image: Kenneth B. Keating Federal Building, General Services Administration (2007), via the Federal Judicial Center (public domain)