AI Generated Image (not the actual letters)
New York has opened a fresh front against the Batavia ICE facility expansion. Two state agencies, the Department of Environmental Conservation and the Department of Health, are demanding that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and its contractor explain how they are building a soft-sided detention unit for up to 100 women outside Buffalo without the environmental consultation and public notice the state says were required, according to letters Gov. Kathy Hochul released on Nov. 18, ABC News reported. The unit is an addition to ICE’s Buffalo Service Processing Center in Batavia, which now holds only men, according to the Washington Examiner.
The letters are the most formal step yet in a months-long dispute, and they shift New York’s argument from politics to regulation. Hochul has complained since summer that DHS was expanding detention in the state without telling anyone. Now two agencies with permitting and inspection powers are asking, in writing, for specifics on facility conditions, medical care, food and construction, with a response requested by next week, according to ABC News.
What the state agencies are asking ICE and Akima
The letters are directed at ICE and Akima Infrastructure Protection, the firm building the structure, ABC News reported. The agencies argue that ICE “failed to coordinate or conduct proper environmental consultations and public notifications before construction began.” The commissioners also wrote that federal oversight agencies have documented unsanitary conditions and gaps in medical services, a pointed reference to the record of the existing Batavia center. A DHS spokesperson did not immediately respond to ABC’s request for comment.
Even the price is in dispute. ABC News reported that DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin, in a letter New York lawmakers released last month, put the tent facility’s expected cost at about $8.7 million. The Washington Examiner reported a figure of $17 million, citing earlier local reporting on federal spending records. Neither outlet reconciled the two numbers, which may reflect different scopes, such as construction alone versus a multiyear operating total. Until DHS or the contract records settle it, both figures should be treated as estimates.
The dispute did not start this week. In a July 13 letter to Mullin, Hochul wrote that New York had learned of three federal detention projects, in Rochester, Batavia and Newburgh, from press reports and procurement records rather than from DHS. She noted that the Batavia center was already overcrowded and had been cited by the DHS inspector general, and she asked where DHS was building, at what capacity and under what authority.
How much power New York actually has over a federal detention site
The legal ground here is narrow. Under the Supremacy Clause, states generally cannot regulate or block the operations of a federal agency on federal property, a principle DHS has invoked against local governments elsewhere, including in its recent dispute with Fresno over city property limits. Courts have also struck down several state efforts to bar immigration detention outright, a history that shadows Oregon’s proposed detention ban.
Environmental and health law is the exception New York appears to be testing. Congress has required federal facilities to comply with state pollution-control requirements in statutes such as the Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. 1323) and the Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. 7418). A new 100-bed unit needs water, wastewater handling and food service, and that is likely where the state’s strongest leverage lies. A demand for information carries no penalty on its own, though. The practical effect is to build a record that could support a permit enforcement action or a lawsuit if ICE declines to answer.
That is the path New Jersey has already taken. The state went to court after DHS ignored a subpoena tied to the Delaney Hall detention center in Newark, as covered here Nov. 17. Members of Congress have pressed similar questions about ICE’s purchase of a facility in Appleton, Wisconsin, and the agency has put seven unused detention sites up for sale, a sign of how quickly its footprint is shifting.
For families and attorneys in upstate New York, the near-term stakes are concrete. Batavia is the main immigration detention center in western New York, and a women’s unit there would likely change where women arrested in the area are held, which in turn affects attorney access and family visits. The next markers are ICE’s reply to the state, or its silence, by the deadline the agencies set, and whether DHS releases a final cost figure and construction timeline for the Batavia ICE facility annex.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- ABC News: Hochul demands information from ICE about new immigration tent facility for women (Nov. 18, 2026)
- Washington Examiner: Hochul presses DHS for information on ICE detention center for women (Nov. 18, 2026)
- Office of Gov. Kathy Hochul: Letter to Secretary of Homeland Security (July 13, 2026)
- 33 U.S.C. 1323, federal facilities pollution control (Clean Water Act)
- 42 U.S.C. 7418, control of pollution from federal facilities (Clean Air Act)