AI Generated Image (not the people involved in this story)
ICE has released University of Maryland freshman Maria Jose Flores Garcia and her mother, Mirna Aracely Garcia Cabrera, nearly two weeks after detaining them at a routine check-in in Baltimore. The release ends their time in a Louisiana detention center but leaves the central legal question open: whether the government can still carry out a third-country removal to Mexico, even though an immigration judge barred sending them to El Salvador in 2021. That question now reaches far beyond one family, because a grant of protection in immigration court no longer guarantees that a person stays in the United States.
University President Darryll J. Pines said the university learned of the release on the night of Nov. 17, and the family’s attorney confirmed it, FOX 5 DC reported. The Washington Post also reported on Nov. 18 that the student had been freed. Federal officials have not publicly explained the terms of the release, and FOX 5 reported that authorities have not said whether they still plan to deport the two women to Mexico. Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.), who had pressed for their release, said in a statement reported by FOX 5 that they never should have been detained.
The case has also come into sharper focus since this site’s Nov. 11 report on the check-in arrest, which described a 2021 removal order. The family’s attorney, Justice Haynes, told FOX 5 that an immigration judge in Baltimore granted both women protection under the Convention Against Torture on Feb. 23, 2021, that the same decision barred their removal to El Salvador, and that DHS never appealed it or moved to end the protection. DHS, for its part, has said Flores Garcia entered the country illegally, was arrested in the Rio Grande Valley in December 2016 and was ordered removed in February 2021, and that her mother had been removed once before. Neither woman has a criminal record, according to their legal team.
How a removal order and torture protection can both be true
The two accounts are less contradictory than they sound. When an immigration judge grants withholding or deferral of removal under the Convention Against Torture, the judge first orders the person removed and then bars carrying out that order to the specific country where torture is likely. The regulations at 8 C.F.R. 1208.16 and 1208.17 make the protection country-specific. It is not a green card, it does not lead to one, and it does not stop removal to a different country that will accept the person under section 241(b) of the Immigration and Nationality Act.
That gap is what third-country removal exploits. Under March 2025 DHS guidance, ICE may send a person to a third country without further process if that country has given diplomatic assurances the government considers credible; otherwise the person must be told where they are being sent and can raise a fear claim for screening. A federal judge in Massachusetts ordered more procedural protections in D.V.D. v. DHS, but the Supreme Court stayed that injunction on June 23, 2025, letting the policy operate while the litigation continues. The attorney’s account of a planned removal to Mexico fits that framework.
What release does and does not change
Release from custody does not cancel the 2021 order. People in this position are typically placed back under an order of supervision with regular check-ins, and the same check-in that led to this arrest can lead to another. Re-detention of people already released is itself under legal attack, as the class action over ICE’s re-detention policy in Atlanta shows, and the detention of a USF professor who holds withholding of removal shows the same pattern for people with similar protection.
For anyone holding CAT protection or withholding, the practical lesson is that the protection shields them from one country, not from detention or from a removal elsewhere. If ICE names a third country, the main tool is a fear claim about that country, and a federal habeas petition remains the route for challenging the detention itself. The open question in this case is whether DHS moves forward with Mexico, seeks to reopen the 2021 grant, or lets the women remain under supervision. The answer is likely to draw scrutiny when Democrats take control of Congress in January and begin the oversight they have promised over ICE detention.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- FOX 5 DC: UMD freshman and her mother released from ICE custody, heading home from Louisiana (Nov. 18, 2026)
- FOX 5 DC: ICE plans to deport UMD student, mother to Mexico as court order bars El Salvador deportation, attorney says (Nov. 2026)
- The Washington Post: University of Maryland student who was valedictorian is freed from ICE custody (Nov. 18, 2026)
- Office of Sen. Chris Van Hollen: Statement on ICE detaining University of Maryland student
- 8 C.F.R. 1208.16: Withholding of removal, including under the Convention Against Torture
- 8 C.F.R. 1208.17: Deferral of removal under the Convention Against Torture
- 8 U.S.C. 1231 (INA 241): Detention and removal, including countries of removal
- Supreme Court docket, DHS v. D.V.D., No. 24A1153