AI Generated Image (does not depict the actual site)
The Texas concertina wire settlement announced Nov. 19 commits the federal government to leave the state’s razor wire in place along a long stretch of the Rio Grande for three decades. Under the deal, the Department of Homeland Security, U.S. Customs and Border Protection and the Border Patrol may not cut, damage or remove Texas’s wire on non-federal land within 25 miles of the border in the Border Patrol’s Del Rio Sector, except in narrow emergencies, according to Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton’s office.
The agreement turns a court-ordered truce into a long-term federal promise. It ends, at least for this sector, a fight that went to the Supreme Court in January 2024, when Border Patrol agents in Eagle Pass were cutting the same wire Texas now has a 30-year pledge to protect. The shift says as much about the change in federal border policy as it does about the law: the agencies that once argued they needed to cut through the barrier have now agreed in writing to stand down.
What the Texas concertina wire settlement allows
The attorney general’s release, which names Gov. Greg Abbott, DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin and CBP Commissioner Rodney S. Scott as parties to the deal, describes these terms:
- Who is bound: DHS, CBP and the Border Patrol, including current and future officials.
- Where: non-federal land within 25 miles of the border in the Del Rio Sector, which includes Eagle Pass.
- How long: the release’s headline says “up to 30 years,” while its text says the agreement remains in effect for 30 years. The release does not explain the difference.
- Exceptions: emergency aid, apprehending and processing people, responding to serious public-safety threats, and repairing federal border infrastructure.
- Conditions: federal officials must notify Texas within 72 hours of any such action, temporarily repair the barrier where feasible, and coordinate with the state before any non-emergency work.
“Through coordination between federal and state authorities, this settlement ensures that concertina wire will remain in place to protect our southern border,” Paxton said in the release. DHS and CBP had not issued their own public statements on the agreement as of Thursday, and the signed agreement, which the attorney general’s office posted as a PDF, could not be reviewed for this article.
How a razor-wire standoff became a contract
Texas sued DHS in federal court in Del Rio on Oct. 24, 2023, after agents cut wire near Eagle Pass, claiming the cuts destroyed state property. Chief U.S. District Judge Alia Moses denied a preliminary injunction that November while sharply criticizing the Border Patrol’s conduct. The Fifth Circuit then blocked federal interference pending appeal, but on Jan. 22, 2024, the Supreme Court vacated that order by a 5-4 vote, with Justices Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch and Kavanaugh saying they would have denied the government’s application. That order let agents keep cutting while the case continued.
On Nov. 27, 2024, a divided Fifth Circuit panel ruled for Texas. Judge Stuart Kyle Duncan, joined by Judge Don Willett, held that the state was likely to win its state-law trespass claim and that the Administrative Procedure Act waived federal immunity for the relief Texas sought. Judge Irma Carrillo Ramirez dissented. The court barred agents from damaging the wire “in the vicinity of Eagle Pass,” but still let them cut it for enforcement or emergencies where they lacked access to both sides.
The settlement goes further than that injunction in reach and in time. It covers the whole 25-mile band of the Del Rio Sector rather than one city, and it runs for decades rather than for the life of a lawsuit. The wire is extensive. Texas had spent about $11 million on 70,000 rolls by late 2023, the Texas Tribune reported, and Abbott’s office said in April 2024 that the state had laid more than 100 miles of it.
The open questions for a 30-year promise
The release does not say whether a judge will enter the agreement as an order or whether the case will simply be dismissed. That matters. A court-entered decree can be enforced by contempt, and either side could later ask to modify it under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b) if circumstances change. A private settlement would leave Texas to sue again for breach. Either way, a future administration that wants agents to have freer access to the riverbank is likely to test how firmly today’s officials can bind their successors.
The deal also leaves the federal enforcement mission intact on paper. Agents may still cut the wire to apprehend and process people, which was the federal government’s core concern in 2024. The practical effect is to shift the default: the wire stays unless agents can point to one of the listed exceptions, and the state gets notice and a repair duty when they do.
Money is part of the backdrop. The federal government has reimbursed Texas $7.5 billion against more than $11 billion in Operation Lone Star spending, the Texas Tribune reported in September. The state side of the deal will soon pass to Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa, who takes office in January and is already at odds with DHS over Texas cooperation with ICE under 287(g). The release does not address her position on the wire. Her stance on local enforcement has already shaped Austin’s ICE policy rewrite, and border construction remains contested elsewhere, including in the Big Bend wall contracts and the administration’s tariff threat over a migrant caravan.
Watch for a filing in Texas v. Department of Homeland Security in the Western District of Texas that shows whether the agreement becomes a court order, and for the agreement text, which would settle the gap between “up to 30 years” and a flat 30-year term.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Office of the Texas Attorney General, release on the concertina wire settlement (Nov. 19, 2026)
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, Texas v. DHS, No. 23-50869, opinion (Nov. 27, 2024)
- Supreme Court of the United States, DHS v. Texas, No. 23A607, order (Jan. 22, 2024)
- Office of the Texas Governor, razor wire deployment release (April 5, 2024)
- Texas Tribune, district court ruling on the concertina wire (Nov. 30, 2023)
- Texas Tribune, federal reimbursement for Texas border spending (Sept. 18, 2026)