AI Generated Image
Opinion. The Labor Department wants the green card labor market test to finally mean something. Here is the strongest case for its PERM proposed rule, the strongest case against it, and the evidence that should decide between them.
The PERM proposed rule published on Nov. 17 is the biggest rewrite of employer-sponsored green card recruitment since the PERM system began in 2005, and it arrives with almost everyone already sure of their verdict. To some, it closes a loophole that let companies go through the motions of looking for American workers. To others, it adds months of delay to a system that already makes skilled immigrants wait years. Both camps have a serious argument, and with comments open until Jan. 16, 2027, both deserve a hearing at full strength before the Labor Department decides.
The facts first. The proposal, Federal Register document 2026-23370, would replace today’s 30-day state job order and two Sunday newspaper ads with at least 90 days of mostly online recruitment. It would bar an employer from filing if it laid off U.S. workers in the same or similar occupation at the place of employment in the prior two years, end Schedule A pre-certification for nurses and physical therapists, compare each sponsored job’s requirements with the employer’s ordinary postings, and require the employer itself to sign every application. This site’s provision-by-provision guide covers the details.
The case for: a test that has stopped testing
Start with what the law asks. Before an employer can sponsor a foreign worker for most EB-2 and EB-3 green cards, the Labor Department must certify that no able, willing and qualified U.S. worker is available for the job. That is a promise to American workers, written into the statute, and the case for the rule is that the current process keeps the form of that promise without its substance.
Consider who PERM actually serves. In fiscal 2024, 57.6 percent of applications were filed for workers already in H-1B status, the department said in a March 2026 proposal. In most of those cases the “open position” is a job someone already holds, and the recruitment is run to confirm a decision the company made long ago. Sunday print ads that few job seekers read, a 30-day posting and requirements that can be drafted around one candidate’s resume make it easy for that recruitment to find no one. In fiscal 2026, about 93 percent of decided cases were certified, according to Office of Foreign Labor Certification data.
On this view, each new rule answers a specific weakness. A longer, online search reaches the people who actually look for work today. Comparing PERM requirements with an employer’s unsponsored postings targets the tailored job description. And the layoff bar addresses the hardest thing for the public to accept: a company cutting U.S. workers in an occupation while telling the government it cannot find any for the same work. A program that depends on public consent has to survive that test.
The case against: the wrong cure for the wrong bottleneck
The opposing case begins with the same 57.6 percent figure and reads it the other way. Most PERM workers are not displacing anyone. They are already employed, already paid at least the wage their employer attested to on an H-1B labor condition application, and already part of the teams sponsoring them. A longer advertising period for a job that is filled measures very little, and it costs the one thing these workers cannot spare: time.
Time matters because of how the law is built. An H-1B worker generally hits a six-year limit, and extensions past it depend on a labor certification or green card petition having been filed early enough. Adding at least two months of recruitment, plus a two-year bar that a single layoff can trigger, pushes some workers past those deadlines through no fault of their own. And PERM is not where the green card line is long. Annual numerical limits and per-country caps, not labor certification, are why workers born in India wait years after approval.
The broader costs fall on employers who have done nothing wrong. A layoff at a worksite can freeze sponsorship for every worker in the same or a similar occupation there, including people whose jobs were never at risk. Ending Schedule A moves nurses and physical therapists, occupations the government pre-certified as being in short supply, into the full recruitment process. On this view, the proposal raises the price of every legitimate case to catch the bad ones, when targeted enforcement against bad actors, the kind the department has already shown it is willing to use, would do the job with less collateral damage.
What should settle it
Both cases rest on an empirical claim the public record does not yet answer: how often does PERM recruitment turn up a qualified U.S. worker who would take the job? If the answer is almost never because almost none exist for these specialized roles, the critics are right that a longer search adds cost without benefit. If the answer is almost never because the search is designed not to find them, the department is right that the test needs rebuilding.
The comment period is the place to produce that evidence, and both sides should bring it. Employers can show recruitment results from real cases, including how many U.S. applicants they interviewed and why they were rejected. The department can show what its audits have found. The Schedule A question deserves separate treatment, because the shortage case for nurses rests on different data than the case for software developers, who accounted for 22.9 percent of certifications in fiscal 2026.
Two narrower questions would also lower the temperature. Should the layoff bar reach every similar job at a worksite, or only the positions actually cut? And should cases already in recruitment when a final rule takes effect be finished under the old rules? Good answers to both would keep the rule’s core aim, a labor test that tests something, while sparing the workers whose only error was being mid-process when the rules changed.
Neither side should get the rule it wants by assertion. The department should have to show that the old test failed to find available Americans, and its critics should have to show that the new one will not. That is a debate worth having on the record before Jan. 16.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Labor, Modernizing the Labor Market Test and Improving Protections for U.S. Workers in the PERM Immigrant Visa Program, proposed rule, FR Doc. 2026-23370 (Nov. 17, 2026)
- U.S. Department of Labor, Improving Wage Protections proposed rule, FR Doc. 2026-06017 (March 27, 2026), fiscal 2024 PERM data
- DOL Office of Foreign Labor Certification, Permanent Employment Program Selected Statistics, FY 2026 (data as of Sept. 30, 2026)
- Regulations.gov docket ETA-2026-0133 (comments due Jan. 16, 2027)