AI-generated illustration.
Vice President JD Vance has rejected Oklahoma Gov. Kevin Stitt’s call for a bipartisan deal built around state-issued work permits, exposing a split inside the GOP over what immigration reform should look like in 2027.
Vice President JD Vance on Thursday, Nov. 19, publicly rejected a call by Oklahoma Gov. Kevin Stitt, a Republican and former chair of the National Governors Association, for President Trump to use his remaining two years to negotiate immigration reform with Democrats. In a post on X, Vance said the proposal sounded like an effort to give amnesty to people who broke the law and called that “morally and electorally disastrous,” according to USA Today and other outlets that reported the post.
Stitt had told Politico on Nov. 18 that national reform should include work permits for unauthorized immigrants whose employers vouch for them, with governors issuing those permits, but not automatic citizenship, USA Today reported. The exchange matters less for what it changes today, which is nothing, than for what it signals about a middle-ground idea that governors of both parties have backed since before the Nov. 3 midterm elections: legal work status without a path to citizenship.
What did Stitt propose, and what did Vance say?
Stitt’s idea is not new. He has pushed state-issued “workforce permits” for most of the year. In February, as NGA chair, he told News9 that governors should be allowed to issue them, pointing to agriculture and other industries that rely on workers who may lack status. At the NGA’s summer meeting in August, he asked members of Congress to give governors discretion to issue migrant work permits, the Deseret News reported, while Utah Gov. Spencer Cox, who leads a bipartisan NGA task force with Delaware Gov. Matt Meyer, asked, “Work permits, can we start there?”
Vance’s response drew a line between two kinds of legislation:
- What he said he would support: measures making it harder for large companies to abuse the visa system or for employers to violate immigration law. He did not name a bill.
- What he rejected: any arrangement that gives legal status to people who entered or remained unlawfully, which he characterized as amnesty.
Several outlets, including Forbes, noted the tension with President Trump’s own recent remarks. In a Nov. 8 60 Minutes interview, Trump said his approach may have been too tough and that he would like to do something on immigration. The next day, as reported earlier, he told reporters there would be no amnesty. Forbes reported that the White House appeared to downplay any gap between the two men. The administration has not announced a reform framework.
Can a state issue work permits to unauthorized immigrants today?
No. Under current law, the authority to permit a noncitizen to work belongs to the federal government. The Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986, codified at 8 U.S.C. 1324a, makes it unlawful for employers to knowingly hire workers who are not authorized, and authorization comes from federal status or a DHS-issued employment authorization document under 8 C.F.R. 274a.12. In Arizona v. United States (2012), the Supreme Court held that a state law penalizing unauthorized immigrants for seeking work was preempted because Congress had built a comprehensive federal framework for employment of noncitizens.
Utah tested the state route in 2011. Its guest worker law would have let people in the state without status obtain a two-year permit after paying a fine and passing a background check, but it depended on a federal waiver that never came, NPR reported in 2014. Lawmakers repeatedly delayed its start date, and by 2016 state legislators were discussing repeal, according to the Associated Press. That history is why Stitt and other governors are asking Congress, not acting on their own.
Is there a bill that would let states sponsor workers?
Yes. On Aug. 3, Sen. John Curtis (R-Utah) introduced a voluntary state-sponsored visa bill, with Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Ariz.) as a cosponsor, the Deseret News and the Cato Institute reported. As Cato describes the bill, S. 5197:
- Is opt-in: states would choose to participate, and DHS would have to approve each state’s program.
- Grants a renewable status: three years at a time, tied to continued residence in the sponsoring state.
- Is capped: 500,000 total, with a minimum allotment per state plus a pool distributed by population.
- Reaches some people already here: states could sponsor people physically present in the U.S. as of Dec. 31, 2016, even if they are now out of status.
That last feature is exactly where Vance’s objection would bite. A state-sponsored status that covers long-present unauthorized workers is a form of legalization, even without citizenship. A version limited to new arrivals, or paired with stronger employer enforcement, is closer to what Vance said he could accept. The bill has not received a committee vote, and Cato’s description reflects an advocacy group’s reading, so the final text should be checked before relying on any detail.
What this means for immigrants and employers now
- Nothing has changed legally: no state work permit program exists, and no one should pay a consultant or “notario” claiming to file for one.
- Employers: Form I-9 and, where required, E-Verify rules are unchanged. A state document cannot substitute for federal work authorization.
- Long-term residents: existing routes such as TPS, DACA, cancellation of removal or family-based petitions remain the only relief available. DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin has signaled openness to a DACA green card deal while opposing broader amnesty.
- Watch January: a new Congress convenes in January, and any reform proposal, from a comprehensive bill to narrower work-permit legislation, would need to pass both chambers and win the president’s signature.
Quick answers
- What is Vance’s position on immigration reform? He says he would back tougher rules on visa fraud and employer violations but opposes legal status for people who broke immigration law.
- Does Trump support bipartisan immigration reform? He has said he would like to do something on immigration, and also that there will be no amnesty. No White House framework has been released.
- Is there a new immigration bill on work permits? The Curtis-Kelly state-sponsored visa bill, introduced Aug. 3, is the main pending proposal. It has not advanced.
- Can my governor give me a work permit? Not under current federal law. Congress would have to create that authority.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- USA Today (via Yahoo News): Vance skeptical of bipartisan push for immigration reform (Nov. 19, 2026)
- Forbes: JD Vance blasts call for bipartisan immigration reform (Nov. 19, 2026)
- The National News Desk (ABC News 4): Vance on amnesty (Nov. 19, 2026)
- News9: Gov. Stitt on governors issuing workforce permits (Feb. 2026)
- Deseret News: Governors ask Congress for authority to issue migrant work visas (Aug. 3, 2026)
- Cato Institute: Bipartisan bill would let states sponsor foreign workers (Aug. 2026)
- NPR: Three years on, Utah’s immigrant guest worker law still stalled (July 31, 2014)
- KSL/AP: Utah plans to repeal guest worker law that never took effect (Feb. 5, 2016)
- Cornell LII: Arizona v. United States (2012)
- 8 U.S.C. 1324a, unlawful employment of aliens