AI-generated illustration.
A Bay Area lawyers group says the backlog at the Concord court is near 200,000 cases and that asylum claims are being cut off before a hearing.
The National Lawyers Guild’s San Francisco chapter said on Nov. 11 that the Concord, Calif., immigration court is now carrying a backlog of nearly 200,000 cases and asked Bay Area attorneys with immigration experience to volunteer. The group said government lawyers are increasingly filing motions to pretermit, which ask a judge to deny an asylum claim on the written application without a full hearing, and that many people are losing their cases because they miss the short window to respond, Bay City News and KALW reported on Nov. 12.
As reported earlier, Concord took over San Francisco’s docket after EOIR closed that court this year, and court watchers documented record removal orders and very few grants of relief. The new statement moves the focus from mass hearings to a different pressure point: written motions that can end an asylum case before the applicant ever testifies. Here is what that means for people with cases in Concord.
How big is the Concord backlog now?
The Guild puts the figure at nearly 200,000 cases. The Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse (TRAC) at Syracuse University counted roughly 170,000 pending cases at Concord at the end of September, according to Bay City News. In October, The San Francisco Standard put the backlog at about 172,000. EOIR has not published its own court-level count for November, so the 200,000 figure should be treated as the Guild’s estimate rather than an official number. Either way, Concord remains the largest immigration court on the West Coast.
What is a motion to pretermit, and why does it matter in Concord?
Pretermission lets an immigration judge deny an asylum or withholding application without an evidentiary hearing if the application, read in the light most favorable to the applicant, does not show prima facie eligibility. The Board of Immigration Appeals approved the practice in Matter of H-A-A-V- (2025), where DHS had asked for it, and in September held in Matter of G-R-B- that judges may do so on their own, without a DHS motion.
According to the Guild, ICE attorneys in Concord are filing these motions more often, and the result is that hearings that would otherwise be scheduled are not. The group said response deadlines are short and that notices are sometimes missed or arrive in a language the recipient does not read. When no response is filed, the judge may rule on the paper record alone.
What should someone with a Concord case do now?
- Check the case status regularly. The Guild says hearings set years out are being moved into 2026 and that some hearings have been moved to earlier dates or times. EOIR’s Automated Case Information portal and the court’s phone line (925-680-9015) show the current date and location.
- Keep the address current. Notices go to the address on file. A change of address has to be reported to the court and, separately, to DHS. A missed notice can lead to an in absentia removal order.
- Read every government filing right away. A motion to pretermit usually comes with a deadline set by the judge. The deadline on the motion or the judge’s order controls, and it may be short.
- Make the written application complete. After H-A-A-V- and G-R-B-, the Form I-589 and declaration may be all the judge reviews. Each harm should be tied to a protected ground, and any particular social group should be defined in the filing, not left for testimony.
- Watch the appeal clock. A notice of appeal to the BIA generally must be received within 30 calendar days of the judge’s oral or written decision under 8 C.F.R. § 1003.38(b).
What is the Guild asking lawyers to do?
The chapter’s Immigration Justice Program trains law students who speak Spanish, Mandarin, Hindi, Arabic, Farsi and Dari to prepare responses to pretermission motions and related appeals. It is asking for licensed attorneys to supervise up to three students each, review and approve their filings, and join a weekly video call. The work is remote, takes a few hours a week, and is limited to those motions. Volunteers do not take on full representation. Bay City News reported that interested attorneys can write to migrantjustice@nlgsf.org.
The Guild also said judges at the court have held mass hearings where only one person had a lawyer. EOIR has defended faster scheduling as a way to avoid unnecessary delay, and the Justice Department has said the San Francisco closure was a cost decision.
Where is the Concord court, and are hearings still held in San Francisco?
EOIR lists the court at 1855 Gateway Boulevard, Suite 850, Concord, CA 94520, open 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. on weekdays, with the filing window on the 8th floor and free visitor parking on levels 5 to 8 of the garage. When EOIR announced the San Francisco closure in May, it said a Sansome Street site would stay in use as a Concord hearing location. The hearing notice and the ACIS portal show which site applies to a given case.
What to watch
Two things will show whether the pressure eases or grows. The first is TRAC’s next court-level release, which will confirm or revise the backlog estimate. The second is in the federal courts: challenges to pretermission without a hearing are likely to be argued as due process claims in the circuit courts, and the Ninth Circuit’s view will decide what Concord judges must do. More context on the Board’s rulings is in our earlier coverage of pretermission without a DHS motion and on pop-up immigration courts.
Quick answers
Can a judge in Concord deny asylum without a hearing? Yes. Under BIA precedent, a judge may pretermit an application that does not show prima facie eligibility, with or without a DHS motion.
Why did my Concord hearing date change? According to the Guild, the court has been moving later hearings earlier and changing some dates and times. Check ACIS and the latest notice.
What happens if I miss a hearing? The judge can order removal in absentia. Reopening generally requires a motion within 180 days showing exceptional circumstances, or proof at any time that proper notice was not received.
How long do I have to appeal? Generally 30 calendar days from the judge’s decision for the BIA to receive the notice of appeal.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Bay City News / Local News Matters: National Lawyers Guild makes plea for help at backlogged Concord Immigration Court (Nov. 12, 2026)
- KALW: Lawyers group says Concord immigration court is backlogged by almost 200,000 cases (Nov. 12, 2026)
- EOIR: Concord Immigration Court
- EOIR: Notice of San Francisco Immigration Court closure (May 1, 2026)
- Matter of H-A-A-V-, 29 I&N Dec. 233 (BIA 2025)
- Matter of G-R-B-, 30 I&N Dec. 102 (BIA 2026)
- 8 C.F.R. § 1003.38 (eCFR)
- The San Francisco Standard: Inside the West Coast’s largest immigration court (Oct. 15, 2026)