AI Generated Image
Two Democratic senators want USCIS to suspend a three-month-old asylum interview rescheduling policy that, they argue, lets a missed appointment push an applicant into removal proceedings.
USCIS’s asylum interview rescheduling policy came under formal challenge from Capitol Hill on Thursday. Sens. Edward J. Markey of Massachusetts and Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut sent a Nov. 19 letter to Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin and USCIS Director Joseph B. Edlow asking the agency to suspend the standard it has applied since Aug. 21, which requires affirmative asylum applicants to show “exceptional circumstances” before an interview will be moved. The senators asked for answers by Dec. 9.
The stakes are concrete for anyone with a pending Form I-589. As the letter describes it, an applicant who asks in advance to reschedule and is turned down, or simply hears nothing before the interview date, must show up anyway or be treated as having failed to appear. That can mean dismissal of the application, referral to immigration court, possible termination of parole and consequences for work authorization.
What changed on Aug. 21
USCIS set out the standard on a web page titled “Establishing Exceptional Circumstances for Rescheduling Affirmative Asylum Interviews,” which the senators cite as last updated Sept. 4. According to the letter, the agency defines exceptional circumstances as compelling events beyond the applicant’s control, offering abuse, serious illness and the death of certain close relatives as examples, and warns that “less compelling circumstances” will not qualify.
The letter lists two other changes: USCIS removed failure-to-appear warning language from the Form I-797C interview notice, and applicants who miss an interview now get 10 calendar days to submit an explanation and supporting records. Under the earlier good-cause procedure, the senators say, applicants could ask within 45 days after the interview date. The letter also cites a Catholic Legal Immigration Network field alert reporting that USCIS representatives told practitioners the agency “may take up to 30 days” to decide a rescheduling request, which can be after the interview has come and gone.
The statutory argument: two doors, not one
The legal core of the letter is a reading of INA § 208(d)(5)(A)(v), which allows consequences when an applicant “fails without prior authorization or in the absence of exceptional circumstances” to appear for an interview or hearing. The senators read that as two separate paths. An applicant can get permission ahead of time, or can explain a missed appointment afterward by showing exceptional circumstances. Requiring exceptional circumstances for the advance request, they argue, collapses the first path into the second, and they say USCIS’s own regulations at 8 C.F.R. §§ 103.2(b)(13)(ii) and 208.10 preserve the same distinction.
The second argument is procedural. Section 208(d)(5)(B) lets the government add asylum procedures “by regulation,” and the senators contend that a nationwide standard announced on a web page skips notice-and-comment rulemaking under the Administrative Procedure Act. They note that a 2020 rule tightening these procedures was later vacated, with the earlier language restored in 2022. “A missed appointment should not become a backdoor route into removal proceedings,” they wrote.
The procedural argument is likely the more consequential one in any lawsuit, since a web-posted standard that officers must apply is the kind of document challengers describe as a legislative rule issued without rulemaking. USCIS would likely answer that rescheduling is internal case management left to its discretion. The letter asks which officials approved the policy, whether officers must follow it, and what data justified it, including rescheduling and no-show counts by asylum office.
Why a referral costs more than time
For an applicant without other lawful status, a referral after a missed interview typically means a Notice to Appear and a removal case, where the asylum claim can be renewed before an immigration judge. That is not the end of the claim, but the forum is harsher now. The Justice Department has cut the deadline to appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals to 10 days, and the Board’s precedent in Matter of K-L-S- warns that speculative appeals are legally inappropriate. A missed interview can also stop the 180-day asylum employment authorization clock, since delays the government attributes to the applicant do not count toward eligibility.
The letter follows earlier fights over affirmative asylum, including a rule allowing officers to skip interviews and a court fight over child asylum interviews. The letter does not bind the agency, and the policy remains in effect. The practical effect for now is that applicants with scheduled interviews should expect the appointment on the notice to stand unless USCIS grants a change in writing.
What to watch
- Dec. 9: the senators’ deadline for USCIS to answer their questions and produce memos, training and processing data.
- Possible litigation: whether an applicant referred to court after a denied or unanswered request challenges the policy under the Administrative Procedure Act.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Letter from Sens. Markey and Blumenthal to DHS Secretary Mullin and USCIS Director Edlow (Nov. 19, 2026)
- Office of Sen. Markey: Sens. Markey, Blumenthal: Stop Punishing Asylum Seekers for U.S. Immigration Agency Scheduling Errors (Nov. 19, 2026)
- USCIS: Establishing Exceptional Circumstances for Rescheduling Affirmative Asylum Interviews
- 8 U.S.C. § 1158 (INA § 208), Asylum
- 8 C.F.R. § 208.10, Failure to appear for an interview