Photo by Da Na on <a href="https://www.pexels.com/photo/chinese-national-flag-in-shenzhen-s-autumn-sky-28635322/" rel="nofollow">Pexels.com</a>
Immigration practitioners are reporting denials of applications by Chinese nationals to change to F-1 student status inside the United States. The decisions rest on Presidential Proclamation 10043, a 2020 order that was written for visa applicants abroad.
Immigration Analytics reported earlier that U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services had been issuing Notices of Intent to Deny that cited the proclamation in these cases. Practitioners now say some of those notices are ending in denials. The applicants are typically longtime U.S. residents who lost their jobs. None had been accused of wrongdoing.
It is not clear how many such applications USCIS is approving, or whether denials are the rule. But the reasoning in the denials practitioners describe follows a consistent script. It treats the very act of applying from inside the country as a reason to say no.
A Proclamation Aimed at the Border
President Trump signed Proclamation 10043 on May 29, 2020. It was published in the Federal Register on June 4, 2020 (85 Fed. Reg. 34353). It suspends the entry of certain citizens of the People’s Republic of China who seek to come to the United States on F or J visas to study or do research.
Its reach is narrower than its reputation. It covers graduate students and researchers with ties to an entity in China that implements or supports Beijing’s “military-civil fusion strategy.” Those ties include receiving funding from such an entity, working for it, or studying or doing research there, now or in the past. The proclamation defines that strategy as China’s effort to acquire foreign technology, especially critical and emerging technology, to advance its military capabilities.
Undergraduate study is excluded. So are students and researchers in fields that would not contribute to military-civil fusion. The State Department has never published a list of the Chinese institutions it considers covered.
Applied to People Who Never Crossed the Border Under It
The proclamation governs entry. It says nothing about changing status inside the country. Its only reference to circumvention concerns fraud, willful misrepresentation or illegal entry.
According to practitioners, USCIS does not dispute that the proclamation applies only to people seeking admission. The agency’s reasoning runs the other way. An applicant who came to the United States before June 2020 was never screened under the proclamation. If that applicant had applied for an F-1 visa at a consulate, the proclamation would have been considered. By changing status from inside the country instead, USCIS reasons, the applicant avoided that evaluation. The agency treats the possibility of evasion as a serious negative factor and weighs it against everything else in the record. That reasoning does not require a finding that the proclamation would actually apply.
The people caught by this reasoning tend to share a profile. They came years ago as F-1 students or H-1B workers, built careers in American technology companies and stayed. After a layoff, they enrolled in a U.S. master’s program and asked USCIS to change their status to F-1. Because they entered before June 2020 and never applied for a new student visa, they were never evaluated under the proclamation. Under USCIS’s logic, that is now the problem.
Clean Records Have Not Been Enough
Practitioners report denials even where applicants showed that the proclamation had nothing to do with them. Applicants have submitted sworn statements that they have never worked for, been funded by or done research for any Chinese government or military-linked entity. They have shown that their degrees and careers had no connection to the technologies the proclamation targets, and that the program they want to enter is non-technical.
USCIS has reportedly given such statements little weight. It treats them as unsupported assertions that do not rule out an undisclosed affiliation or the risk that the applicant could be co-opted. That leaves applicants with a problem that has no clear answer: how do you document an absence of ties?
Positive factors have not carried the day either. Practitioners describe denials in which USCIS acknowledged years of maintained status, timely filing, full-time enrollment and professional contributions, then concluded that none of it outweighed the proclamation concern.
Proving You Are Not an Intending Immigrant
The proclamation is not the only hurdle. An F-1 student must have a residence abroad that he or she has no intention of abandoning, and USCIS is testing that requirement closely. For an applicant who has spent a decade working in the United States, the bar is high, especially one whose former employer filed an immigrant petition.
The Security Backdrop
The denials come as national security concerns about technology flowing to China dominate the conversation in Silicon Valley. Nvidia co-founder Jensen Huang resigned as chief executive on Nov. 12, two weeks after reports that U.S. intelligence officials believe a woman he had a relationship with was gathering information for Beijing. She was an early leader of Megaspeed International, a Singapore data center company that U.S. authorities have been investigating over whether it steered Nvidia chips to China in violation of export controls. Megaspeed has said there is no evidence of such exports. Nothing reported so far shows that Huang knowingly passed information to anyone.
A week later, federal prosecutors in San Francisco charged a Russian national, Igor D’iu, with acting as an unregistered agent of Moscow.
The applicants seeking F-1 status are not accused of anything resembling either case. But the climate helps explain why USCIS is treating the risk of technology transfer as a reason to deny, even when no connection is shown.
B-2 Is No Easy Way Out
Many workers who lose a job have turned to B-2 visitor status to buy time. That route has narrowed. On March 31, 2026, USCIS archived its guidance for nonimmigrant workers after a job loss. That guidance had described looking for work as a permissible B-1/B-2 activity. Practitioners report that USCIS now treats an open-ended job search as inconsistent with a temporary visit, and that RFEs and denials on these requests are common.
A B-2 applicant must show a genuine visitor purpose, with a detailed itinerary covering the entire stay requested, the money to support it without working, and ties abroad.
Going Home to Come Back
For many, that leaves one path: leave the United States and apply for an F-1 visa at a U.S. consulate. That means facing the proclamation head-on, because the applicant is now seeking entry. Some law firms tracking the proclamation have reported that many visas have been refused under it.
Without a published list, consular officers look at the whole picture:
- Field of study. Programs tied to critical and emerging technologies draw the most attention. These include artificial intelligence, semiconductors, quantum computing, big data, 5G, aerospace and advanced nuclear technology.
- Prior schools in China. Officers look closely at the “Seven Sons of National Defence” universities, institutions on the Commerce Department’s Entity List and others with defense research ties.
- Funding. Support from the China Scholarship Council or other government programs raises questions.
- Work and research history. Officers look at work or research for state laboratories, defense-linked companies or military-affiliated institutes.
Graduate students in technical fields with any of those links face the greatest risk of refusal. Applicants in non-technical fields with no such history face less risk from the proclamation, though not none.
Chinese applicants are widely worried about administrative processing, and they should plan for it. Some Chinese graduate applicants may receive a 221(g) notice at the interview while their case undergoes further review, rather than a visa that day. Anyone planning this route should build in extra time and talk to the school about deferring the start date if needed.
The consular interview brings the usual tests as well: the presumption of immigrant intent under section 214(b), home-country interview rules and social media vetting. Our guide, Why US Consulates Refuse Nonimmigrant Visas, explains how those decisions are made.
What This Means
For Chinese nationals in the United States who lose a job and are weighing graduate study, a change of status to F-1 now carries real risk, however clean their background. The time to think through the options is before the grace period runs out, not after a denial. Anyone in this position should get individual legal advice early.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts.