Image generated by AI.
The full 24-page CPT order shows Judge Kobick stayed SEVP’s August broadcasts for everyone, enjoined DHS only as to the plaintiffs’ members and their students, and refused to order notice to schools or reversal of past actions.
The featured image accompanying this article was generated by AI and does not depict real people or events.
The written order behind the Nov. 17 CPT ruling is now public, and it answers the biggest open question about the decision: who it protects. In a 24-page memorandum and order in Association of American Universities v. Department of Homeland Security, No. 1:26-cv-14520 (D. Mass.), U.S. District Judge Julia E. Kobick stayed the Student and Exchange Visitor Program’s two August broadcasts on Curricular Practical Training so that they “may not be enforced or applied pending judicial review,” with no limit to the plaintiff groups. As reported earlier, the ruling blocked DHS’s narrowed reading of CPT, but the order’s text was not available at the time and early reports did not say whether it reached every school.
Two layers of relief: a universal stay and a narrower injunction
The order grants the universities’ motion in two parts. The first is a stay under 5 U.S.C. 705 of SEVP’s Broadcast Messages of Aug. 12, 2026 (“Reminder of Liability for DSOs Regarding CPT Authorization”) and Aug. 24, 2026 (“Guidance for Designated School Officials regarding Curricular Practical Training”). Because a Section 705 stay operates on the agency action itself rather than on particular parties, the court found nationwide relief appropriate, citing the “chaos and confusion that a party-specific order would inevitably generate.” In practical terms, the broadcasts are suspended for every SEVP-certified school, not only members of the plaintiff associations.
The second part is a preliminary injunction that is narrower. It bars DHS, ICE and those acting with them from implementing or enforcing the broadcasts’ interpretation “as to the plaintiffs and each of their members, including their members’ employees and students.” Notably, the injunction also covers CPT approvals made before the broadcasts were issued, which protects students whose elective, credit-bearing training was authorized under the old reading. The plaintiffs are large networks: the order describes the Association of American Universities as having 69 member institutions, the Presidents’ Alliance nearly 600 in 42 states, D.C. and Puerto Rico, the Association of Independent Colleges and Universities in Massachusetts 55, and NAFSA more than 9,000 individual members. The court required no bond.
What the court declined to order
Two requests were turned down. The court would not order DHS to rescind adverse actions already taken in reliance on the broadcasts, finding that the record showed only that the government had started to implement the new standard, not that it had taken adverse action against a school. It also refused to require written notice of the ruling to all SEVP-certified institutions, calling that request untethered to the plaintiffs before the court and citing the Supreme Court’s 2025 decision in Trump v. CASA on limits to relief beyond what the parties need.
That gap matters for schools outside the plaintiff networks. They benefit from the universal stay, but DHS is not required to tell them so, and the order does not direct any school to resume elective CPT. The decision to authorize CPT still rests with each designated school official under 8 C.F.R. 214.2(f)(10)(i), which the ruling leaves unchanged. A compliance tracker maintained by HenryKnows lists the University of Alabama, the University at Buffalo, the University of Pittsburgh and Western Michigan University as having updated their public CPT statements on Nov. 17, the day of the order. Students should check their own school’s current guidance rather than assume a policy has changed.
How the court reached its decision
The opinion clears three hurdles DHS had raised. On standing, the court found each association could sue for its members, noting that broadcasts that expressly threaten liability need not wait for an enforcement action. On finality, it held both broadcasts were final agency action despite disclaimers, rejecting DHS’s argument that they were mere reminders; SEVP “cannot escape judicial review under the APA simply by including these disclaimers,” the court wrote.
On the merits, the court reached only the first of the universities’ four claims: that the broadcasts were arbitrary and capricious because they were a “fundamental departure” from the government’s reading since a 1991 final rule, later INS cables, a 2013 SEVP newsletter and SEVP training materials, without acknowledging the change or weighing schools’ and students’ reliance interests. It did not decide which reading of the regulation is correct, and it did not address the notice-and-comment claim. For irreparable harm, the court pointed to 15 declarations, including Columbia’s denial of CPT to more than 120 students, at least 13 Grinnell students who lost internships, and the threat of losing SEVP certification or DSO liability for false statements.
The ruling follows the Nov. 16 decision by a different Boston judge that struck down the duration of status rule. Unlike that final judgment, the CPT order is preliminary.
What to watch
- An appeal: no notice of appeal or stay motion had been reported as of Nov. 18; a government appeal would go to the First Circuit.
- SEVP guidance: whether SEVP issues a broadcast acknowledging the stay, or follows through on the draft CPT guidance its Study in the States site says it plans to release for comment.
- School policies: which universities reopen elective, credit-bearing CPT for spring and summer, and whether non-member schools rely on the universal stay.
- Remaining claims: the court left the universities’ other APA counts, including notice-and-comment, for later in the case.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Memorandum and Order on Plaintiffs’ Motion for a Preliminary Injunction and Stay of Agency Action, AAU v. DHS, No. 1:26-cv-14520-JEK, ECF No. 36 (D. Mass., Nov. 17, 2026)
- DHS Study in the States, Curricular Practical Training Guidance (undated, accessed Nov. 18, 2026)
- AILA, District Court Temporarily Enjoins SEVP Policies Restricting CPT, AILA Doc. No. 26111705 (Nov. 17, 2026)
- HenryKnows, CPT tracker: what universities are saying publicly about CPT (updated Nov. 17, 2026)
- The Daily Northwestern, Court order instates preliminary injunction of August Curricular Practical Training interpretation (Nov. 18, 2026)