AI Generated Image
A federal judge in Boston on Monday issued a final ruling against the Department of Homeland Security’s duration of status rule, which would have capped how long international students and exchange visitors could stay without asking the government for more time. Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts found the rule “arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, and otherwise not in accordance with law,” according to STAT, which so far is the only outlet to have reported the decision. The practical result is continuity: students and scholars stay on “D/S,” the open-ended admission that lasts as long as they remain in their program. DHS counted 1,816,480 F-1 and 514,170 J-1 admissions in fiscal 2024, according to the rule (admissions count entries, not individual people).
The ruling turns a temporary pause into the court’s last word, at least at the trial level. On Sept. 14, one day before the rule was set to take effect, Saylor postponed it nationwide, Forbes reported at the time. Monday’s decision followed cross-motions for summary judgment filed Oct. 30. The plaintiffs, a coalition including the Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, NAFSA, the American Federation of Teachers and the United Auto Workers, had asked the court to set the whole rule aside.
What the duration of status rule would have changed
Published by ICE on July 17, 2026 (91 Fed. Reg. 44976), the final rule would have replaced D/S with a fixed clock for three groups. Its core provisions:
- F-1 students and J exchange visitors: admission for the length of the program, but never more than four years, with any additional time requiring an extension of stay from USCIS.
- Foreign media (I visas): admission tied to the assignment, capped at 240 days for most.
- Grace period: the window to depart after finishing studies or post-completion OPT would have shrunk from 60 days to 30.
- Language programs: an aggregate 24-month limit on stay, including breaks and vacations.
DHS argued that D/S leaves the government with too few set points to verify that students are complying and creates room for fraud. It cited SEVIS records showing more than 2,100 people who first entered as F-1 students between 2000 and 2010 still in active F-1 status as of April 6, 2025. The agency estimated the rule’s cost at $443.1 million to $448.6 million a year over 2027 to 2036, and it received close to 22,000 public comments during a 32-day comment period, according to the rule itself.
The challengers attacked the cost-benefit analysis, the short comment window, DHS’s handling of comments and its failure to consider less burdensome alternatives, and in September the court found them likely to succeed on their arbitrary-and-capricious claims, according to the plaintiffs’ case page. A ruling on those Administrative Procedure Act grounds faults how DHS reasoned, not whether Congress allows fixed admission periods at all.
The government’s next move, and the limits of a win
No public DHS response to Monday’s ruling had been reported as of this writing. The government appealed the September order to the First Circuit on Sept. 30, then asked the appeals court on Nov. 3 to pause that appeal for 30 days because a final judgment was expected soon, according to the plaintiffs’ case page. That earlier appeal is likely to be folded into, or replaced by, an appeal of the final judgment.
The more durable risk for students is a second rulemaking. A rule faulted for thin reasoning can be rewritten with a fuller cost analysis, a longer comment period and fuller answers to critics. This is the second time the idea has stalled: a 2020 proposal to end D/S was withdrawn in 2021, and the current version moved from proposal in August 2025 to final rule in under a year. Any redo would restart notice-and-comment, which typically takes many months. The ruling also leaves untouched other pressures on international enrollment, from the proposed OPT fee on universities to new limits on curricular practical training now being litigated in a separate case.
For now, the rules that applied before July 17 still govern. Students need not file extension-of-stay applications to remain past four years, the 60-day departure period after a program or OPT ends is unchanged, and schools keep handling program extensions through the Form I-20 and SEVIS. Doctoral students and postdocs, whose programs routinely run past four years, have the most at stake if an appeal or new rule revives the cap, at a moment when new international enrollment has fallen sharply and the drop has been steepest at graduate schools.
What to watch
- Whether the government files a notice of appeal of the final judgment; under the federal rules it generally has 60 days.
- How the First Circuit disposes of the pending appeal of the September order, now paused at the government’s request.
- Any new proposed rule on fixed admission periods in the Federal Register or the regulatory agenda.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- STAT: Federal judge issues final ruling blocking U.S. plan to limit visa length for grad students, postdocs (Nov. 16, 2026)
- Federal Register: DHS final rule establishing a fixed time period of admission for F, J and I nonimmigrants, 91 Fed. Reg. 44976 (July 17, 2026)
- Forbes: Judge blocks immigration rule limiting students to four years (Sept. 15, 2026)
- Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration: Duration of status litigation case page (plaintiffs’ docket summary)