AI Generated Image (not the people or hospital in any specific case)
The Labor Department’s long-awaited PERM overhaul is out. It would scrap the Schedule A shortcut used for foreign nurses and physical therapists and keep employers from filing for two years after laying off U.S. workers in the same job.
The Labor Department’s PERM proposed rule, announced Nov. 16, would rewrite how employers prove they could not find U.S. workers before sponsoring a foreign employee for a green card. It would also end Schedule A, the pre-certified list that lets hospitals sponsor nurses and physical therapists without testing the labor market, and bar an employer from filing if it laid off U.S. workers in the same or a similar occupation and area during the previous two years, up from the six-month window that generally applies today. The document, which covers the labor certification step behind most EB-2 and EB-3 green cards, is on public inspection at the Federal Register and is scheduled for publication Tuesday, Nov. 17, with a 60-day comment period, Newsweek reported.
Nothing changes yet for pending cases. This is a proposal, and the current rules in 20 CFR Part 656 govern every PERM application until a final rule takes effect. The timing still matters. This is the first comprehensive rewrite of a program DOL says has not been comprehensively modified since 2004, and it lands while the department is already suspending major employers from PERM and finishing a separate rule that raises the wages those employers must offer.
What the PERM proposed rule would change
- Recruitment: an overhauled labor market test replacing the 2004 recruitment formula (today a 30-day state job order, two Sunday newspaper ads and, for professional jobs, three more steps).
- Layoffs: a two-year look-back covering U.S. workers laid off in the same or a similar occupation and area, according to Newsweek’s account of the proposal.
- Schedule A: eliminated, so employers of nurses and physical therapists would generally have to run the standard labor certification process.
- Compliance: stronger rules on nondiscriminatory recruitment, hiring and record retention, three goals DOL listed in its regulatory agenda entry for the rule (RIN 1205-AC29).
DOL cites its authority under INA section 212(a)(5)(A), which bars employment-based immigrants unless the Labor Secretary certifies that qualified U.S. workers are not available and that wages and working conditions will not suffer. DOL’s announcement describes the goal as “strengthening protections for American workers.”
Why the layoff bar hits H-1B workers hardest
The two-year layoff rule looks like an employer restriction, but much of its cost would fall on foreign workers already in the country. In fiscal 2024, about 57.6 percent of PERM applications were filed for workers already in H-1B status, DOL stated in its March 2026 wage proposal. At companies that have cut jobs in waves, a two-year look-back could freeze sponsorship for whole job families.
That matters because of how the H-1B clock works. Under AC21, an H-1B worker can extend beyond the six-year limit only if a PERM application or I-140 was filed at least 365 days earlier. A worker whose employer cannot file because of a layoff in the preceding two years could hit year six with no way to stay. Layoffs elsewhere in a company could end a worker’s ability to stay, even if that worker’s own job was never at risk.
Ending Schedule A reverses a recent direction
Schedule A long predates the 2004 PERM system. Under it, an employer files a Form I-140 directly with USCIS, with an uncertified ETA-9089, because DOL has already found a shortage. In December 2023, the previous administration’s Labor Department published a request for information asking whether to expand Schedule A to STEM and other occupations. The new proposal goes the opposite way and closes the list entirely.
For hospitals, that would mean full recruitment, a prevailing wage determination and DOL adjudication for every foreign-educated nurse, instead of a filing that skips DOL altogether. The Schedule A change is likely to draw the heaviest comments from health systems, while the administration’s case rests on the argument written into the statute: certification should come only after a real test of the U.S. labor market.
From proposal to final rule
The rule has moved quickly. The White House regulatory office received it in September, Bloomberg Law reported, and cleared it in late October. DOL’s companion wage proposal was published in March and reached White House review as a final rule in November, about seven months later. A similar pace would put a final PERM rule on track for mid-2027. A court challenge is unlikely before then, because a proposal is generally not final agency action under the Administrative Procedure Act.
The two rules compound. Higher prevailing wages, a longer layoff bar and tougher recruitment would together raise the cost of every new case, which makes filings under today’s rules, against current DOL processing times, the most predictable path for now.
What to watch
- Nov. 17: scheduled Federal Register publication, which starts the 60-day comment clock (about Jan. 16, 2027, if it publishes that day).
- Transition rules: the published text should show whether applications filed before a final rule’s effective date keep current-rule treatment.
- Wage rule: publication of the final H-1B and PERM prevailing wage rule, now at the White House.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Labor news release: proposal to modernize permanent labor certification recruitment (Nov. 16, 2026)
- Federal Register public inspection: Modernizing the Labor Market Test and Improving Protections for U.S. Workers in the Permanent Labor Certification Immigrant Visa Program (FR Doc. 2026-23370)
- Unified Agenda entry, RIN 1205-AC29 (abstract and legal authority)
- DOL proposed rule, Improving Wage Protections (FR Doc. 2026-06017, March 27, 2026), FY2024 PERM data
- DOL request for information on modernizing Schedule A (FR Doc. 2023-27938, Dec. 21, 2023)