AI-generated illustration.
The bill is now formally announced, and its sponsors have added detail on the green card path that would follow an expired removal order.
California Democrats introduced the Protect Our Neighbors Act on Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026, according to a press release from Rep. John Garamendi. Led by Rep. Lateefah Simon and cosponsored by Reps. Garamendi, Zoe Lofgren and Juan Vargas, the bill would make final orders of removal expire after 10 years for people who have stayed continuously in the United States without a criminal conviction, and would amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to let those people apply for lawful permanent residence.
As reported earlier, the proposal was first described by ABC News the day before introduction. The sponsors’ release adds two conditions for the green card path, an application fee and confirmation of the applicant’s taxpaying status, and calls the measure bicameral, though no Senate sponsor has been named. A bill number had not been posted on Congress.gov as of Thursday evening.
What the Protect Our Neighbors Act would do
- Expiration: a final removal order would lapse 10 years after it was issued, if the person has been continuously present and has not been convicted of a crime, according to the release and ABC’s description of the text.
- Renewal: an immigration judge could renew an expired order only if the government shows by clear and convincing evidence a significant cause for the delay, unrelated to administrative or funding delays, and that renewal serves the public interest based on new evidence.
- Green card path: people whose orders expire could apply for permanent residence, subject to a fee and a check of their tax filing history. No fee amount or other eligibility rules have been published.
The renewal standard is the most consequential detail. By excluding “administrative or funding delays” as a justification, the bill would stop DHS from reviving an old order simply because it lacked the resources to carry it out. Today, under INA 241, a final order remains enforceable indefinitely, and relief from an old order generally depends on discretionary tools such as a stay, a late motion to reopen or prosecutorial discretion.
Who could benefit, and how many people have old orders?
The sponsors cite an American Immigration Council estimate that about 1.19 million people with removal orders remain in the United States. ABC News cited a higher figure, about 1.6 million people with final orders, from testimony by Todd Lyons, then acting ICE director, in February. The two numbers measure different things and come from different dates, and neither shows how many orders are more than 10 years old.
The release ties the bill to Harjit Kaur, a 73-year-old Bay Area resident who had lived in the United States for about three decades. According to the release, her asylum claim was denied in 2012 and she reported to ICE every six months for more than 13 years before she was detained at a check-in on Sept. 8, 2025, and deported to India on Sept. 19. ICE has said an immigration judge ordered her removed in 2005. Detentions at routine check-ins are also being challenged in court, as described in our coverage of the Atlanta class action.
Questions the bill text still has to answer
Until the full text is posted, several points remain open, and published descriptions differ on some of them:
- When the clock starts: ABC describes expiration 10 years after issuance; at least one other outlet describes 10 years of continuous residence after the order. On either reading, orders already more than a decade old appear to be covered, but no source says so expressly.
- What counts as a conviction: no description says whether any offense, including a minor misdemeanor, would bar expiration.
- Continuous presence: it is unclear how the bill treats short trips abroad or a prior removal followed by return, which today can trigger reinstatement of the old order.
- The name: one passage of the release refers to the “Protect Our Communities Act,” while the headline and press coverage use Protect Our Neighbors Act.
Reaction and outlook
No statement from DHS, ICE, the White House or a Republican member of Congress on the bill had been reported as of Nov. 19. Conservative commentators criticized it on social media as amnesty for people who avoided removal. Simon told ABC she had discussed the bill with Democratic leadership and was hopeful about bipartisan support. With the 119th Congress ending Jan. 3, 2027, a bill introduced in the lame-duck session will die unless enacted and would need to be reintroduced next year, when Democratic leaders have said they plan to move immigration measures, as reported in our Dream and Promise Act coverage.
Quick answers
- Is the Protect Our Neighbors Act law? No. It has only been introduced and has no legal effect.
- Does my old deportation order still count? Yes. Existing orders remain enforceable, and ICE check-in requirements still apply.
- Can I apply for a green card under this bill now? No. There is no application process unless the bill is enacted and implemented.
- What can someone with an old order do today? Options such as a motion to reopen based on changed circumstances, a stay of removal or a request for prosecutorial discretion depend on the facts and should be reviewed with counsel.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Rep. John Garamendi: Garamendi and Simon introduce legislation to protect long-term immigrant neighbors (Nov. 19, 2026)
- ABC News: House Dems to introduce bill establishing a 10-year expiration on final orders of removal (Nov. 18, 2026)
- American Bazaar: New bill could give people with removal orders a green card path (Nov. 19, 2026)
- Mwakilishi: New US bill seeks to cancel deportation orders for immigrants with clean records (Nov. 19, 2026)
- 8 U.S.C. 1231 (INA 241): Detention and removal of aliens ordered removed