AI Generated Image (not a real case document)
Final removal orders would expire 10 years after they are issued for many long-settled immigrants under a House bill that California Democrats plan to introduce on Thursday, Nov. 19. The Protect Our Neighbors Act, led by Rep. Lateefah Simon, would cover people who have remained continuously in the United States without a criminal conviction and would open a path to permanent residence once their orders lapse, ABC News reported on Nov. 18.
The bill goes after a feature of immigration law that rarely draws notice outside deportation defense: a final order of removal never goes stale. An order an immigration judge entered in 2006 can be enforced in 2026 exactly as if it were signed last week. That permanence matters more as ICE detains people at routine check-ins they have attended for years, a practice now challenged in cases such as ICE Re-Detention Policy Challenged in Atlanta Class Action.
How the 10-year limit on final removal orders would work
According to ABC News, an order would expire a decade after issuance if the person has been continuously present and has no criminal conviction. An immigration judge could renew an expired order only on clear and convincing evidence that there was significant cause for the delay and that renewal is in the public interest based on new evidence. People whose orders expire could then seek lawful permanent residence. The cosponsors are Reps. John Garamendi, Zoe Lofgren and Juan Vargas, all California Democrats. ABC said the measure was inspired by Harjit Kaur, who was deported to India in 2025 after reporting for an ICE check-in.
“Those deportation orders need to be again turned off,” Simon told ABC. Garamendi said the administration has “repeatedly decided to cruelly deport residents” who have been working and paying taxes.
Nothing like this exists in current law. Under Section 241 of the Immigration and Nationality Act, an order stays enforceable indefinitely; a motion to reopen is generally due within 90 days of the final order; and someone who leaves and returns unlawfully faces reinstatement of the old order. Today’s escape routes, such as a late motion to reopen, a stay or prosecutorial discretion, all depend on someone’s discretion. A statutory expiration would work differently: the order would end by operation of law, and reviving it would require a showing before a judge.
A backlog far larger than removal capacity
Todd Lyons, then acting ICE director, said in February that about 1.6 million people had final deportation orders, ABC reported. Removals run well below that number. TRAC at Syracuse University, using DHS enforcement records obtained through Freedom of Information Act litigation, counted 316,601 removals from August 2025 through July 2026, about 29% below the fiscal 2024 record of 446,180. Based on those figures, even if every removal came from the final-order population, which they do not, working through 1.6 million cases would take about five years at the current pace.
That gap is why many people live with orders for a decade or longer, the group the 10-year line is drawn around. The administration’s answer has been pressure rather than expiration: 8 U.S.C. 1324d allows daily civil penalties for willful failure to depart, and DHS has moved to collect them, as covered in Failure to Depart Fines: DHS Moves to Lock In Past ICE Penalties. Immigration judges also ordered more than 100,000 voluntary departures in fiscal 2026, against about 9,000 in fiscal 2024, according to TRAC, a shift explained in ICE Deportations Record Comes as Formal Removals Decline.
Odds in Congress and the questions the text must answer
ABC described the bill as unlikely to pass this year, and its report quoted no Republican response; all four sponsors named are Democrats. No public response from DHS or the White House had been reported as of Nov. 18. President Trump told “60 Minutes” he would “love to do something on immigration” with Democrats, ABC noted, which falls short of support for this bill. Any bill still pending when the 119th Congress ends on Jan. 3, 2027, dies and must be reintroduced. Democratic leaders have said they will push immigration bills early next year, as reported in Dream and Promise Act: Jeffries Vows Early Vote in Next Congress, and a narrow provision like this one could resurface inside a larger package such as the Dignity Act.
For anyone with an old order, the practical answer today is simple: nothing changes. The bill is a proposal, not law, and an existing order stays enforceable. When the text is posted, three details will decide its real reach:
- Retroactivity: whether orders already more than 10 years old would expire on enactment, which would affect a much larger group than orders issued going forward.
- What counts as a conviction: whether any offense, including a minor misdemeanor, would bar expiration.
- Continuous presence: how the bill treats people who were briefly detained, removed and returned, or who left and came back.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- ABC News: House Dems to introduce immigration bill establishing a 10-year expiration on final orders of removal (Nov. 18, 2026)
- TRAC, Syracuse University: Immigration Removals Fall During the Second Trump Administration (Nov. 11, 2026; data through August 2026)
- 8 U.S.C. 1231 (INA 241): Detention and removal of aliens ordered removed
- 8 U.S.C. 1229a(c)(7) (INA 240): Motions to reopen
- 8 U.S.C. 1324d: Civil penalties for failure to depart