AI Generated Image (not an actual court filing in these cases)
Federal judges in Nashville have ruled against ICE in five cases over Nashville ICE detentions so far this month, ordering two people released and barring three others from deportation while their cases proceed, WKRN reported on Nov. 18. The orders from the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee involve people arrested in the community, at an ICE check-in and after rapid transfers out of state, and two of the judges wrote that the government was pressing an argument courts had already rejected.
None of the orders breaks new legal ground. Together they show the government losing the same detention fight in the same courthouse, and bringing it anyway, while the Supreme Court prepares to settle the question nationwide.
Three judges, five orders, one repeated argument
According to WKRN, Chief Judge William L. Campbell Jr. on Nov. 13 ordered the release of a woman arrested in Middle Tennessee on Nov. 6 and then moved across the state. Campbell wrote that judges in the district had already rejected the government’s “exact argument as meritless,” the station reported. Judge Aleta A. Trauger granted release to a Cuban man detained in Nashville on Oct. 26, finding he had been held almost two weeks without a hearing in violation of his due process rights, and noting that district courts across the Sixth Circuit had considered and rejected the government’s position multiple times.
Judge Waverly D. Crenshaw Jr. handled the other three. He barred the removal of two Russian citizens detained after a scheduled check-in at the Nashville ICE office on Oct. 19, ordered individualized detention hearings within five days, and barred ICE from moving them out of the Middle or Western Districts of Tennessee while his injunctions stand. He also temporarily blocked the deportation of a man arrested in Nashville and transferred within four days to the Central Louisiana ICE Processing Center, writing that the balance favored giving the petitioner “an opportunity to be heard.”
An ICE spokesperson told the station the agency is “enforcing the immigration laws enacted by Congress,” that it is ending what it called catch-and-release, and that everyone in its custody receives full due process.
Why the Sixth Circuit keeps saying no
WKRN’s account does not name the statute behind the rejected argument, but the dominant detention dispute in federal courts this year is well defined. Since the Board of Immigration Appeals decided Matter of Yajure Hurtado, 29 I&N Dec. 216 (BIA 2025), the government has treated people who entered without inspection, even long ago, as “applicants for admission” subject to mandatory detention under 8 U.S.C. 1225(b)(2)(A), with no bond hearing before an immigration judge. The traditional reading placed long-term residents under 8 U.S.C. 1226(a), where bond is available.
In Tennessee, that question is settled for now. On May 11, the Sixth Circuit held in Lopez-Campos v. Raycraft that noncitizens who did not attempt lawful entry “are not ‘seeking admission’ and are thus not subject to § 1225(b)(2)(A)’s mandatory detention scheme.” That decision binds every district court in Tennessee, Kentucky, Ohio and Michigan, which is why Nashville judges describe the government’s position as already rejected. Other circuits have gone the other way, including the Eighth, whose no-bond rule now governs ICE’s new Appleton, Minnesota, facility.
The Supreme Court granted review on Oct. 1 in Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha, No. 26-104, on exactly that question: whether section 1225(b)(2)(A) mandates detention of people present without having been admitted. No argument date appears on the docket yet. Until the justices rule, the practical effect is a two-tier system in which the same arrest produces a bond hearing in Nashville and none across the Eighth Circuit line.
The transfer orders matter as much as the releases. A habeas petition generally must be filed in the district where the person is held, so a fast move to Louisiana can take a case out of a court bound by Lopez-Campos and place it under a different circuit’s law. Crenshaw’s no-transfer orders keep the petitioners where Sixth Circuit law applies. The same pattern has played out elsewhere, from re-arrest and contempt fights in Minnesota and Colorado to Seattle prosecutors declining to defend many ICE habeas cases and a UC Berkeley student released after a judge faulted ICE on a bond hearing.
For families of people arrested in Middle Tennessee, the lesson is speed: these petitions were filed while the person was still in the district, and the court acted within days. For the government, the open question is whether relitigating a settled circuit rule will start to carry costs, as judges elsewhere have signaled with contempt findings. A Supreme Court decision in Barbosa da Cunha, expected by the end of the term next summer, would end the split in one direction or the other.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Federal judges in Nashville rebuke ICE over unlawful detentions, WKRN (Nov. 18, 2026)
- Lopez-Campos v. Raycraft, Nos. 25-1965 et al., U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit (May 11, 2026)
- Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha, No. 26-104, docket, Supreme Court of the United States
- Question presented, No. 26-104, Supreme Court of the United States