AI Generated Image (not the actual ceremony or people involved in this story)
The Egyptian author’s prison memoir won the nonfiction prize in New York while he watched from Europe. The law gives him, and the audience that wanted to hear him, almost no way to challenge the refusal.
Abdelrahman ElGendy, the Egyptian writer who was denied a U.S. visa days before the ceremony, won the National Book Award for nonfiction on Wednesday for “Huna: A Memoir of Revolution, Prison, and Becoming,” his account of years as a political prisoner in Egypt. He followed the week’s events remotely from Europe, and a second finalist, Syrian writer Samar Yazbek, nominated in translated literature, was also refused a visa, according to the National Book Foundation, The Associated Press reported.
The case lands at an awkward intersection: a prize that celebrates American letters, a foreign author it chose to honor, and the one corner of immigration law where the courts almost never look. The State Department declined to discuss either applicant, the AP reported, but said the administration “continues to put America and its interests first by fully enforcing U.S. immigration laws and ensuring lawful travel through our visa process,” adding Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s line that “a visa is a privilege, not a right.” The foundation said in a statement that it “feels unjust that some, but not all, of our finalists are able to participate in in-person programming to recognize their exceptional books.” At a reading the night before, fellow nominee Omar El Akkad read on ElGendy’s behalf.
Why a visa refusal is so hard to contest
A consular officer’s decision to refuse a visa is, as a rule, not reviewable in court. Congress has never created a review process, and the Supreme Court has repeatedly declined to build one. The leading case has an uncomfortably close fit with this one. In Kleindienst v. Mandel (1972), American professors invited the Belgian Marxist writer Ernest Mandel to speak at universities, and the government refused to waive his ineligibility. The professors argued that the First Amendment protected their right to hear him. The Court ruled 6-3 that when the executive gives a “facially legitimate and bona fide reason,” judges will not look behind it or weigh it against the audience’s interests.
The Court narrowed the opening further in Department of State v. Muñoz (2024), holding 6-3 that even a U.S. citizen has no fundamental liberty interest in a noncitizen spouse’s admission. If a citizen’s own marriage does not unlock judicial review, a literary foundation’s invitation is very unlikely to. The practical effect is that public pressure, not litigation, is the main channel available to the foundation and to ElGendy’s fellow nominees, who issued a joint statement saying they “stand in solidarity” with him, according to Publishers Lunch.
Neither the State Department nor the foundation has said on what legal ground either visa was refused, and that detail matters. A visitor refused under section 214(b) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, the presumption that applicants intend to immigrate unless they show otherwise, can reapply with new evidence of ties abroad. A case held under section 221(g) for administrative processing is technically refused but still open. A finding under the security grounds of section 212(a)(3) is far harder to overcome. Without the refusal notice, which only the applicant receives, outsiders cannot tell which situation applies.
Yazbek’s case may turn on something else. Syria was added to the list of countries whose nationals face a full suspension of entry when President Trump expanded his travel ban proclamation in December 2025, The National reported at the time. Those proclamations allow case-by-case exceptions in the national interest, but the decision rests with the State Department, and the same limits on court review apply. The proclamation’s reach into cultural events is not new: it recently kept contestants from two African countries out of a U.S.-hosted pageant, as coverage of the Miss Universe withdrawals showed.
The eligibility question that followed
The refusal also raised a question about whether ElGendy qualified for the award at all. Democracy Now reported that he lived in the United States for three years before leaving in 2025, fearing arrest by ICE over his opposition to Israel’s war in Gaza and his criticism of U.S. relations with Egypt, and that the awards require authors to be U.S. citizens, permanent residents or people who “maintain their primary, long-term home in the United States.” Publishers Lunch reported that The New York Times raised the issue and that the foundation said it does not “have any concerns regarding the eligibility of his title.” The foundation evidently stood by that view on Wednesday.
That thread is a reminder that immigration status now shapes cultural institutions in ways their rules never anticipated. Prize committees, festivals and universities that invite foreign guests are operating inside a visa system that has grown markedly more restrictive this year, from visa refusals for foreign lawmakers to new worldwide public charge screening now under legal challenge and a steep drop in immigrant visa issuance. For organizers, the lesson of this week is timing: an invitation that depends on a visa interview weeks before the event is an invitation the State Department, not the host, ultimately controls.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Associated Press: Hannah Lillith Assadi’s ‘Paradiso 17’ wins the National Book Award for fiction (Nov. 18, 2026)
- Associated Press: A global National Book Awards lineup, but 2 finalists can’t enter the US (Nov. 18, 2026)
- Democracy Now: Egyptian Writer Abdelrahman ElGendy Blocked from Entering the U.S. (Nov. 18, 2026)
- Publishers Lunch: NYT calls NBA nominee’s eligibility into question (Nov. 18, 2026)
- U.S. Supreme Court: Kleindienst v. Mandel, 408 U.S. 753 (1972)
- U.S. Supreme Court: Department of State v. Muñoz (2024)
- The National: Trump adds Syria and other countries to travel ban (Dec. 16, 2025)