Photo by Hert Niks on <a href="https://www.pexels.com/photo/urban-surveillance-security-camera-close-up-41070991/" rel="nofollow">Pexels.com</a>
Security cameras outside the Bishop Henry Whipple Federal Building at Fort Snelling recorded plain-clothes officers making an ICE re-arrest of two men seconds after they walked out the front doors, freed on orders from federal judges, MPR News reported Nov. 20. The previously unpublished footage, dated Sept. 9 and Sept. 25, puts pictures to a tactic that has divided the federal bench in Minnesota, and at least one judge there is now writing new limits into his release orders to stop it.
The legal stakes are larger than two arrests. A habeas corpus petition under 28 U.S.C. 2241 is the main way a detained immigrant can challenge custody in federal court, and its remedy is release. If ICE can hand someone release papers and take him back into custody at the threshold, the government can say it obeyed the order while the person never spent a free minute. Whether a release happened at all is a question of fact, and video is exactly the kind of evidence that settles questions of fact.
The Sept. 9 recording shows Pablo Hernandez Franco, 32, of Mexico, whom U.S. District Judge Jeffrey Bryan had ordered released “immediately.” In a sworn statement, Hernandez said his shoulder was dislocated during the arrest; the deportation officer involved stated under oath that Hernandez did not express pain to him, according to MPR. Bryan later found the re-arrest violated his order, reasoning that because ICE “immediately swarmed” Hernandez, he “was not released from custody.” ICE let him go on Sept. 25. That same morning, cameras caught the re-arrest of Alejandro Corro Guzmán, 34, also from Mexico. Chief U.S. District Judge Eric Tostrud refused to order him freed again and called the argument that he had never been released “not persuasive.”
Those two outcomes capture the split. MPR has confirmed at least eight men in Minnesota who were re-arrested this way after a judge ordered each released, one of them twice. Bryan and Judge John Tunheim have found violations; Tostrud and Judge Jerry Blackwell have not. Earlier coverage of the Minnesota and Colorado contempt fights traced how the practice spread.
ICE re-arrest limits move into the release order itself
Tunheim has shifted from finding violations after the fact to heading them off. In two habeas orders issued the Monday before the footage ran, MPR reported, he wrote that “Respondents SHALL NOT re-detain Petitioner” without adequate notice and a pre-detention bond hearing, citing the station’s reporting. That tracks Colorado, where judges have required advance notice to the court before any re-detention and where U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney held the government in contempt but imposed no sanction after an ICE official testified the practice had stopped.
The government’s position deserves to be stated plainly. DHS has said ICE “may seek to rearrest the alien in a way that complies with the judicial decision,” and an ICE official told MPR this month that enforcement options can include re-arresting someone. ICE officials in Minnesota have said agency lawyers review release orders for re-arrest candidates, and that when a judge finds the first arrest was made without a warrant, ICE treats the ruling as room for a “do-over,” according to MPR. That theory has real footing: an order curing an unlawful arrest does not, on its own terms, bar a new and lawful one, and Bryan himself wrote that a release order does not prevent future re-arrest. The fight is over timing and process, not over whether ICE may ever detain these men again.
The practical effect is a district where protection depends on the judge and the drafting. A detainee whose order carries Tunheim’s notice and bond-hearing terms has a shield that a detainee before another judge in the same courthouse lacks. Expect lawyers to ask for that language in every petition, and for the government to push back against limits it did not have before. A division this sharp among judges of one district is the kind of question likely to reach the Eighth Circuit. Similar challenges are already moving elsewhere, including a class action over re-detention in Atlanta and at least 20 re-arrest cases nationwide.
For one man the debate is not abstract. Tha Im, a Cambodian man representing himself, was re-arrested at Whipple on Oct. 19 and was still held at the Kandiyohi County Jail a month later, MPR reported.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- MPR News: Security videos show instant ICE re-arrests at Whipple Federal Building (Nov. 20, 2026)
- MPR News: ICE admits instant re-arrest strategy (Oct. 13, 2026)
- MPR News: Colorado judge finds ICE in contempt for instant re-arrests (Nov. 18, 2026)
- 28 U.S.C. 2241, power to grant writ of habeas corpus