Department of Justice Building
A Nov. 20 policy memorandum folds two 2011 ethics guides into one code that now also binds the administrative law judges who hear employer cases.
The EOIR ethics canons issued on Nov. 20 replace the conduct rules that have governed the nation’s immigration judges and Board of Immigration Appeals members since 2011. Policy Memorandum 27-01, signed by Acting Director Sirce E. Owen of the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) and effective the same day, sets one code for every EOIR adjudicator, including, for the first time, the administrative law judges of the Office of the Chief Administrative Hearing Officer (OCAHO), who decide Form I-9, hiring discrimination and document fraud cases against employers.
Most of its 18 pages restate federal ethics law that already applied. The news is in the framing and a handful of new notes. The memo says its purpose is to “restore, preserve, and promote public confidence” in the adjudicator corps and to promote professionalism and ethical behavior, “characteristics which may have eroded in the recent past.” It does not say whose conduct, or what period, it has in mind.
What the EOIR ethics canons add
- Outside pressure: A note to the neutrality canon says “partisan pressure from Congress or public clamor stoked by stakeholders through sympathetic media outlets” are not appropriate bases for deciding a case. The note names Congress and outside stakeholders but not the executive branch; the canon’s main text bars being swayed by “partisan interests” generally.
- Ex parte contacts: A note says internal discussions solely among EOIR or Justice Department employees “do not generally constitute ex parte communications,” except where the presiding adjudicator and one party are both department employees, such as a Civil Rights Division lawyer in an OCAHO discrimination case.
- Memberships: Adjudicators may not belong to organizations engaged in unlawful activity, such as discrimination barred by federal law. The memo adds that “some adjudicators” have argued the First Amendment lets them join any group, and says EOIR still believes they should avoid organizations “perceived as biased or discriminatory.”
- Advocacy groups as prohibited sources: The gift rules list as prohibited sources law firms representing people before EOIR and organizations whose members mostly fit that description, giving “most immigration advocacy or immigration legal service organizations” as the example. Gifts from such sources are generally capped at $20 per occasion and $50 a year from any one source.
- Social media and politics: Immigration judges and appellate immigration judges are classed as “less restricted” under the Hatch Act; administrative law judges and Senior Executive Service adjudicators are “further restricted.” All may not like, comment on or repost a social media post that solicits political donations, on or off duty.
Some long-standing positions survive. Judges may still give “procedural and scheduling courtesies” to pro bono lawyers under a 2020 policy, and a temperament canon bars yelling, “bullying” comments and slurs while preserving a judge’s power to be “firm and decisive” in running a hearing.
A code for a bench EOIR is rebuilding
Immigration judges are Justice Department employees, not Article III judges, and their conduct rules come from agency policy. The department published proposed codes of conduct for immigration judges and board members in a June 2007 Federal Register notice; the 2011 guides followed and covered only those two groups. OCAHO’s judges, who can impose civil penalties for Form I-9 violations, had no EOIR ethics guide at all.
The timing tracks a bench in rapid turnover. EOIR’s hiring table shows 753 permanent immigration judges on board on Sept. 30, 2026, after 312 hires in fiscal 2026, and two swearing-in ceremonies since then have, by EOIR’s count, pushed the bench past 800 judges. Many of the newest judges, and new Chief Immigration Judge Jamee E. Comans, will apply these canons from their first day.
The membership note lands amid a live dispute over judges’ First Amendment rights. The National Association of Immigration Judges, a voluntary group, asked the Supreme Court on Nov. 17 to let it challenge EOIR’s speaking restrictions in federal court, in a case that names Owen as respondent, as covered here earlier this week. The canons do not resolve that fight; they restate that outside speaking and writing need prior approval.
What it means for people in immigration court
Very little changes directly for respondents, employers or their lawyers. The memo calls itself “an internal management directive” that creates no right or benefit “enforceable at law” and does not limit a judge’s independent judgment. A party who believes a judge is biased still seeks recusal under the existing regulations, and complaints about conduct still run through EOIR’s misconduct process, which the memo cross-references.
The practical effect is on discipline. Violations, “particularly those related to impartiality and neutrality,” may bring corrective or disciplinary action, and the code now gives supervisors a single written standard to cite. The open question is how EOIR will apply the neutrality note on congressional pressure in 2027, when Democrats take control of the House and congressional scrutiny of immigration agencies is likely to intensify. The memo treats lawmakers’ pressure as something adjudicators must not decide cases on; it says nothing that would limit Congress’s oversight of EOIR as an agency, and members are likely to test where that line sits.
Practitioners will also watch whether the “prohibited source” language keeps judges away from bar events and trainings run by legal service groups; free attendance at widely attended gatherings already requires written approval. The code arrives weeks before the 10-day appeal deadline at the Board of Immigration Appeals takes effect on Dec. 17.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- EOIR Policy Memorandum 27-01, Ethics and Professionalism Canons for Executive Office for Immigration Review Adjudicators (Nov. 20, 2026)
- EOIR Adjudication Statistics, Immigration Judge Hiring (data through FY 2026)
- EOIR press release on the chief immigration judge, 27 immigration judges and 5 temporary immigration judges (Nov. 19, 2026)
- Codes of Conduct for the Immigration Judges and Board Members, 72 Fed. Reg. 35510 (June 28, 2007)