ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations Special Response Team officers staff a high-risk charter removal flight from Texas, December 2019. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement photo (public domain). File photo, not from the events in this story.
An Associated Press account from Juba describes hunger and payments to guards among men the U.S. sent to South Sudan, less than three weeks before the Supreme Court hears the government’s appeal over third-country deportation procedures.
Men removed from the United States to South Sudan under the administration’s third-country deportation policy went without adequate food and water while relatives wired money to guards, according to an Associated Press report published Nov. 20. The account lands as the Supreme Court prepares to hear Department of Homeland Security v. D.V.D. on Dec. 9, the case that will decide how much notice and chance to object a deportee must get before being sent to a country that is not his own. No court filing links the two, but the report puts a concrete record beside an abstract question: what happens after the handover, and who answers for it.
What the AP says it found in Juba
The men at the center of the report are the eight deportees with criminal convictions whose removal became the first big test of the policy. All had finished their U.S. sentences. Their flight was halted midway by a federal judge in May 2025, they were held for weeks at the U.S. base in Djibouti, and they reached Juba in July 2025 after the Supreme Court cleared the way. Their home countries include Mexico, Cuba, Vietnam, Laos, Myanmar and South Sudan. AP reported that five remain in custody in a gated building in the capital; at least two of the original eight have since been returned to their home countries.
AP said it reviewed money-transfer receipts and messages between guards and relatives of four detainees, showing transfers of $100 to $1,000. Ngoc Phan, a U.S. citizen whose husband, Tuan Phan, was held for nearly a year before being repatriated to Vietnam in June 2026, told AP she paid about $4,000 for food, water and a phone and that guards kept most of it. Tuan Phan told AP he lost about 20 pounds. Relatives described days without food or clean water. Those are the families’ accounts, attributed as such by AP, which is so far the only outlet to report them.
South Sudan’s Foreign Ministry denied the claims, telling AP that detainees receive adequate food, water and medical care and that the government covers all costs. It added that the United States “fully relinquished responsibility and no longer has any legal jurisdiction over, or ties to, these individuals.” A congressional aide told AP that U.S. Embassy staff were instructed during an August 2025 visit not to check on the detainees. The State Department did not address that point, AP reported.
Why the Supreme Court case turns on procedure, not conditions
The justices will not be asked whether detention conditions in Juba are acceptable. The questions the Court framed are narrower: whether the district court in Massachusetts had jurisdiction over the class’s claims, whether 8 U.S.C. 1252(f)(1) allowed it to grant classwide declaratory relief and vacatur, and whether DHS’s guidance on third-country removals is unlawful under 8 U.S.C. 1231(b), the Due Process Clause or the law implementing the Convention Against Torture.
That guidance, dated March 30, 2025, lets DHS proceed without further procedures when the receiving country has given diplomatic assurances against persecution and torture. Without assurances, the government has said, officers generally wait at least 24 hours after serving a notice of removal and screen any fear claim. The district court’s Feb. 25, 2026 final judgment declared the guidance unlawful, vacated it and held that class members are entitled to “meaningful notice” and “a meaningful opportunity to raise a country-specific claim.” The First Circuit largely affirmed on Sept. 18. On Sept. 29 the Supreme Court stayed that judgment and agreed to hear the case, with Justices Sotomayor, Kagan and Jackson saying they would have denied the stay.
The practical effect is that the policy is operating now, under a stay, while the Court decides. The Foreign Ministry’s position, that U.S. responsibility ended at handover, mirrors the government’s structural argument in its strongest form: once removal is complete, the receiving state is sovereign, and diplomacy rather than courts governs what happens next. The judgment the class won points the other way, treating the hearing before the plane leaves as the only check that reliably exists. Read either way, the AP account shows how little a U.S. court can see once a deportee is abroad.
Lower courts are already testing the edges. In Minnesota, an order to bring a Nicaraguan man back from the Central African Republic was paused by the Eighth Circuit on Nov. 19 after the government pointed to that country’s diplomatic assurances. Return orders in other third-country cases have raised the same questions about what a court can compel once a person is gone.
For people with final orders, the open question is the one the Court will answer first: whether any court can hear a classwide challenge at all. If the government wins on jurisdiction or on 1252(f)(1), individual habeas petitions filed in the hours before a flight would become the main remaining route, which is how many recent cases have reached judges.
Dates to watch in D.V.D.
- Dec. 1: the government’s reply brief is due at the Supreme Court.
- Dec. 9: oral argument in No. 26-426.
- By the end of the term: a decision, with the Sept. 29 stay in place until the Court’s judgment issues.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Associated Press, “US deportees in South Sudan went hungry as guards pocketed money from relatives, families say,” Nov. 20, 2026 (via Arab News)
- Associated Press, “Vietnamese man deported from U.S. to South Sudan is repatriated after year in detention,” June 2026 (via PBS NewsHour)
- Supreme Court docket, Department of Homeland Security v. D.V.D., No. 26-426
- Questions presented, No. 26-426
- Government’s application for a stay, No. 26A406 (Sept. 24, 2026)
- 8 U.S.C. 1231 and 8 U.S.C. 1252
- Featured image: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement on Flickr (public domain)