AI Generated Image (not the actual court filing or documents in this case)
Seven months after removing him to Mexico, the federal government now calls Brian José Morales García a U.S. citizen, in the same filing that asks a judge to end his lawsuit.
The Justice Department has conceded in federal court that a deported U.S. citizen, Brian José Morales García of Austin, is an American, while asking a judge to dismiss his damages suit over the removal. A motion to dismiss filed Friday, Nov. 20, by U.S. Attorney Justin R. Simmons describes the Denver-born 25-year-old as “a dual citizen of the United States and Mexico,” the Texas Tribune reported, calling it the first time a Trump administration official has acknowledged his citizenship in plain terms. The motion argues the government is immune from suit for immigration enforcement. U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman has not ruled.
The concession matters because it closes the factual dispute that defined this case. In April, federal officials publicly insisted that “CBP did NOT arrest a U.S. citizen,” according to the Tribune, and said Morales García had admitted he was a Mexican national who entered illegally. The government’s position now is narrower: he may be a citizen, but the United States should not have to pay for what happened to him. The case is now about accountability, not facts.
Five days from a window-tint stop to Mexico
Morales García was a passenger in a pickup with coworkers headed to an air-conditioning job when a Texas Department of Public Safety trooper stopped the truck near Fredericksburg on April 3, the Tribune reported in April. He told the trooper he had a birth certificate and a Social Security card. Immigration officers were called, ICE asked that he be held, and Border Patrol took custody after he was booked into the Gillespie County jail. He says agents accused him of lying and warned he could go to prison, so he told them he had entered illegally. He signed papers, and DHS says he was removed on April 7.
His lawyers later filed hospital records, witness affidavits and a certified Colorado birth record. A Mexican ID spells his name “Bryan” and lists a different birth date, an error his mother blames on a clerk. The government let him reenter on Aug. 30 under an agreement with his attorneys, according to the Tribune.
Legally, the citizenship question was never close once the birth record held up. A person born in Denver is a citizen under the Fourteenth Amendment and 8 U.S.C. 1401(a), Mexican nationality changes nothing, and removal powers reach only “aliens.” Under 8 U.S.C. 1481 and Afroyim v. Rusk, citizenship ends only through a voluntary act intended to give it up, never through a statement made in custody. The practical lesson is how much weight an on-the-spot admission carried against documents sitting at his home.
The immunity fight now at the center
The suit against ICE, DPS and the Gillespie County Sheriff’s Office seeks unspecified damages. Public reporting has not said which legal theories it rests on, and the motion was not available for review, but the terrain is well mapped. Tort claims against the United States go through the Federal Tort Claims Act, which waives sovereign immunity but excludes “discretionary functions” under 28 U.S.C. 2680(a). Damages claims against individual federal officers have been sharply limited since Egbert v. Boule (2022), in which the Supreme Court refused to extend a Bivens remedy against a Border Patrol agent. Claims against state and county officers raise qualified immunity.
The local layer is where the case reaches beyond one family. DPS and the Gillespie County Sheriff’s Office both take part in ICE’s 287(g) program, the Tribune has reported. Whether officers working under such an agreement are treated as federal or state actors could decide which immunity rules apply. That question will matter more as Texas sheriffs face a Dec. 1 deadline under the state’s 287(g) mandate.
A problem the government barely counts
No federal agency publishes a current count of citizens arrested or removed by immigration officers. A 2021 Government Accountability Office report found that from fiscal 2015 through the middle of fiscal 2020, ICE arrested 674 potential U.S. citizens, detained 121 and removed 70. GAO recommended that ICE track these cases better, and DHS agreed. ProPublica counted more than 170 citizens held by immigration agents from January 2025 through early October 2025, a figure it called almost certainly incomplete.
If immunity defenses defeat a suit by a citizen the government admits it removed, the main remaining checks on such errors are agency policy and congressional oversight. The case joins other challenges to fast-moving arrests, from a class action over warrantless arrests in Virginia to detentions of work-permit holders at Alabama traffic stops and airport arrests on domestic flights.
What to watch
- The response: Morales García’s lawyers will answer the motion to dismiss in the Western District of Texas.
- Pitman’s ruling: whether any claim survives immunity, and against which defendants.
- DHS and DPS: neither had responded to the Tribune about the filing; any public statement would be the first since the government’s concession.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Texas Tribune: Feds seek dismissal of lawsuit by deported Texas man (Nov. 20, 2026)
- Texas Tribune: U.S. citizen deported after Central Texas traffic stop (April 23, 2026)
- Texas Tribune: Deported U.S. citizen returns to the United States (Aug. 30, 2026)
- Texas Tribune: Deported citizen’s case and 287(g) partnerships (Sept. 2, 2026)
- GAO-21-487: Immigration Enforcement, Actions Needed to Better Track Cases Involving U.S. Citizenship Investigations (July 2021)
- ProPublica: More than 170 U.S. citizens held by immigration agents (Oct. 16, 2025)
- 8 U.S.C. 1401(a), 8 U.S.C. 1481 and 28 U.S.C. 2680(a); Afroyim v. Rusk, 387 U.S. 253 (1967); Egbert v. Boule, 596 U.S. 482 (2022)
- Featured image: AI generated