AI Generated Image (does not depict the real site or the people involved in this story)
An Alabama court’s pause on three ICE construction site practices is headed to the Eleventh Circuit, and the outcome will shape how far agents can go on private job sites across the Deep South.
The fight over ICE construction site raids has moved up a level. The federal government is appealing a September order from the Southern District of Alabama that temporarily stayed three Department of Homeland Security practices for entering private construction sites and holding workers there, Law360 reported this week. The order came in a lawsuit brought by Leonardo Garcia Venegas, a U.S. citizen and Baldwin County construction worker whom immigration agents detained on the job and released once his citizenship was confirmed.
For contractors, site owners and the workers they employ, the case is one of the clearest tests yet of where the Fourth Amendment draws the line between a public street, where the Supreme Court has given agents considerable room, and the fenced, posted interior of a job site.
What Judge Beaverstock paused, and on what authority
Chief U.S. District Judge Jeffrey U. Beaverstock’s Sept. 21 order in Garcia Venegas v. Homan, No. 1:25-cv-00397, did not grant the preliminary injunction Garcia Venegas asked for. It granted his motion “to the extent that the alleged policies will be temporarily stayed and otherwise, DENIED.” The tool was Section 705 of the Administrative Procedure Act, which lets a court postpone agency action to prevent irreparable injury while a case proceeds. The court had already found in May that the three practices exist and that Garcia Venegas has standing to challenge them; the government, according to Courthouse News, has denied that any such policies exist.
The order addresses three practices:
- Warrantless entry: officers going into non-public parts of private construction sites without a warrant or the owner’s consent. The court measured this against DHS’s own regulation, 8 C.F.R. 287.8(f), and wrote that it was “not persuaded by the Government’s position that it never needs a warrant to enter a construction site.”
- Preemptive detention: holding workers on a site without individualized reasonable suspicion. The court found this practice “likely violates the Fourth Amendment,” testing it against the reasonable-suspicion standard in 8 C.F.R. 287.8(b).
- Continued detention: keeping workers in custody after they show evidence of citizenship or lawful presence, such as a REAL ID or Alabama STAR ID.
One finding stands out for employers: the court held that Garcia Venegas, “as an employee has a reasonable expectation of privacy in his workplace.” The government had argued, Courthouse News reported, that a worker has no privacy interest in a site he does not own and that a construction site is an “open field.” The court record describes encounters at sites in Foley on May 21, 2025, and in Fairhope on June 12, 2025. At a hearing on the motion, a DHS official testified that agents do not treat a REAL ID as reliable proof of lawful presence, according to the Alabama Political Reporter.
Why the appeal matters beyond Baldwin County
An appeal sends the dispute to the Eleventh Circuit, whose rulings bind federal courts in Alabama, Georgia and Florida, three states with heavy construction employment and active immigration enforcement. A published decision there would settle, for that region, whether a posted construction site is protected business premises or open ground that agents may walk onto at will.
The backdrop is unsettled. In September 2025, the Supreme Court stayed a Los Angeles order limiting roving immigration stops, and Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s concurrence in Noem v. Vasquez Perdomo accepted that location and type of work can contribute to reasonable suspicion. The Alabama order rests on different ground: entry onto private property and detention after a worker shows identification. The open question is whether the Eleventh Circuit reads Vasquez Perdomo broadly enough to reach job sites.
There is also a procedural fight. On Oct. 19, the government asked the district court to reconsider or clarify the order, arguing that the stay works as a de facto preliminary injunction and that the classes conditionally certified for discovery are too vague, according to the docket summary kept by the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse at the University of Michigan Law School. That framing matters: interlocutory appeals generally run from injunctions under 28 U.S.C. 1292(a)(1), and a Section 705 stay with the practical effect of one can be reviewed. How the appeals court labels the order is likely to shape how broadly the relief reaches, a question sharpened since Trump v. CASA curbed universal injunctions in 2025.
What contractors and workers should take from it now
Filing an appeal does not by itself suspend the stay. The order governs one lawsuit in one district, not the nation, and it does not touch Form I-9 inspections, which begin with a written Notice of Inspection. The regulation behind it is national, though: 8 C.F.R. 287.8(f) already requires a warrant or consent to enter non-public areas of a business, which makes a site owner’s consent the hinge in many of these encounters.
The case is also growing: an amended class complaint filed Oct. 13 added two agents as defendants and damages claims under the Federal Tort Claims Act. It fits a broader run of courts testing ICE tactics, from a Maine ruling that a warrantless arrest of a teenager was unlawful to the Alabama traffic-stop detentions of young people holding work permits, while states have lost recent bids to regulate agents directly, as in Connecticut and California.
What to watch
- Whether the government asks the Eleventh Circuit to stay Judge Beaverstock’s order pending appeal.
- The district court’s ruling on the Oct. 19 motion to reconsider or clarify the stay and the conditional classes.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Order, Garcia Venegas v. Homan, No. 1:25-cv-00397 (S.D. Ala. Sept. 21, 2026), ECF 106
- Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse, Garcia Venegas v. Homan case docket summary
- Law360, “Feds Appeal Halt Of ICE Construction-Site Arrest Policies”
- Courthouse News Service, “Alabama judge freezes ICE construction site tactics after US citizen targeted”
- Alabama Political Reporter, “Federal judge orders halt to warrantless construction site raids” (Sept. 22, 2026)
- 8 C.F.R. 287.8, Standards for enforcement activities