AI Generated Image (does not depict the real courthouse or the people involved in this story)
A federal judge in Brooklyn on Friday refused to free Oscar Belgal, the man shot by ICE officers during an Oct. 8 arrest attempt in Manhattan’s Marble Hill neighborhood, leaving him in immigration detention while his deportation case moves forward, the Associated Press reported. U.S. District Judge Hector Gonzalez found that agents may have served an arrest warrant before giving Belgal a Notice to Appear, but called the misstep “merely a technical error” that does not require his release.
The ruling pulls apart three questions that the case’s video and headlines have tended to blend: whether the arrest was lawful, whether the force was lawful, and whether Belgal should stay locked up. A habeas petition answers only the last one. It also shows how little weight one federal court gives to errors in the order of ICE’s paperwork, an argument detainees are pressing nationwide.
A warrant that came before the charge
The ordinary power to arrest someone in removal proceedings, 8 U.S.C. 1226(a), runs “on a warrant issued by the Attorney General.” DHS regulations at 8 CFR 236.1(b)(1) tie that warrant, Form I-200, to the charging document: an arrest may happen when the Notice to Appear is issued or at any point afterward. Belgal’s lawyers at the Legal Aid Society told the court that ICE did not prepare his Notice to Appear until the day after the shooting, as reported in October.
Gonzalez accepted that the sequence may have been wrong but rejected the broader claim that agents had no valid warrant at all, according to the AP. The same judge earlier released an Ecuadorian man who was arrested with no warrant, Courthouse News reported in October. Read together, the two rulings suggest a line: a missing warrant can win release, while a warrant issued out of order, standing alone, is unlikely to.
The shooting claims go somewhere else
Legal Aid argued that agents violated due process through an “unreasonable use of extreme force.” Gonzalez said a habeas case is “not an appropriate venue” for that argument, the AP reported. Damages claims against federal officers generally start with an administrative claim under the Federal Tort Claims Act, and constitutional suits against individual agents have been sharply limited since Egbert v. Boule (2022), in which the Supreme Court refused to extend such claims to an excessive-force suit against a Border Patrol agent.
The accounts of Oct. 8 remain far apart. Federal officials said the officers fired because they believed their lives were in danger and that Belgal smashed his car into two government vehicles and “accelerated toward other officers,” according to the AP. His lawyers say the agents never identified themselves before breaking a window and firing several shots. NYPD security video shows a plainclothes officer striking the driver’s window with a gun barrel and a second officer drawing a weapon as the car pulls away. Belgal, 28, was hit in the shoulder and neck; his 5-year-old son, in the car, was not hurt.
The AP reported that Belgal entered the United States unlawfully in 2021, later pleaded guilty to grand larceny and received probation, and was arrested in 2025 on allegations of attempting to sell controlled substances, a case still pending. “It is unconscionable that Mr. Belgal should have to endure another day in detention,” the Legal Aid Society said in a statement.
Bond is now the real fight
Gonzalez noted that Belgal can still ask the immigration court for release on bond. That remark carries weight. Under the Laken Riley Act’s provision at 8 U.S.C. 1226(c)(1)(E), people who entered without inspection and are charged with or convicted of theft or larceny face mandatory detention, and an immigration judge could not set bond. On the record the AP describes, that provision would appear to reach him, which makes the pointer toward a bond hearing notable. The AP account does not say which statute the government invoked, and the ruling itself could not be reviewed, so whether he is held under the discretionary authority of Section 1226(a) remains the open question.
A bond hearing would not be easy. Under the Board of Immigration Appeals’ decision in Matter of Guerra, 24 I&N Dec. 37 (BIA 2006), an immigration judge may weigh arrests and pending charges, not only convictions, in judging danger and flight risk, which puts the open drug case squarely in play. The larger question of who gets bond hearings at all is before the Supreme Court in Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha, with argument expected in early 2027.
What to watch: a bond request before an immigration judge; any appeal of Friday’s ruling to the Second Circuit; the federal investigations into the shooting by Homeland Security Investigations and the FBI; and the pending state drug case. The AP account does not say whether the October orders barring his removal remain in place.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Associated Press (via ABC News): Federal judge denies a request to release man shot by immigration agents in New York (Nov. 20, 2026)
- 8 U.S.C. 1226, Apprehension and detention of aliens
- 8 CFR 236.1, Apprehension, custody, and detention
- Egbert v. Boule, 596 U.S. 482 (2022)
- Matter of Guerra, 24 I&N Dec. 37 (BIA 2006), EOIR Volume 24 precedent decisions
- Courthouse News: NYC man shot by ICE seeks immediate release, urgent medical care (Oct. 14, 2026)
- Immigration Analytics: Judge Orders DHS to Name the Law Holding the Man ICE Shot in Manhattan (Oct. 14, 2026)