AI Generated Image
A new count says more people have lost legal status since January 2025 than have been deported. The number largely holds up on the government’s own records, but what it measures is narrower and more legally varied than the word “delegalization” suggests.
More than 1.3 million immigrants who were protected from deportation in January 2025 have since lost legal status or protection, and with it permission to work, according to a special report released Nov. 19 by the American Immigration Council, a pro-immigration research and advocacy organization. The figure adds up three programs the administration has wound down: Temporary Protected Status, the parole process for Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans and Venezuelans known as CHNV, and Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals.
The timing matters. The count arrives as the Venezuelan TPS case sits in the Ninth Circuit, as a new Congress prepares to take up bills aimed at people with old removal orders, and while the government has published no single tally of its own. For employers reverifying workers and lawmakers weighing a fix, the scale is the starting point.
How the council reached 1.3 million people who lost legal status
The report calls its total conservative. It counts only TPS, CHNV and DACA, to avoid double counting, and leaves out hundreds of thousands of people whose CBP One parole was cut short. The components:
- TPS: about 1.3 million holders from 17 countries as of March 2025, of whom more than 1 million have lost status. About 274,000 from El Salvador, Sudan and Ukraine remain in limbo.
- CHNV parole: more than 530,000 people used the process, and parole was terminated for all of them. About 195,000 had no route into TPS or Cuban Adjustment Act status.
- DACA: more than 533,000 active recipients in early 2025, down about 96,000 to roughly 436,000 by June 30, 2026, based on USCIS quarterly data the report cites.
What the Federal Register confirms
DHS’s own termination notices state how many people each decision covered. Five TPS notices alone cover more than 700,000 people:
| Program | People covered, per DHS notice | Notice published |
|---|---|---|
| Haiti TPS | about 348,187 | July 1, 2025 |
| Venezuela TPS (2021 designation) | 268,156 | Sept. 8, 2025 |
| Honduras TPS | about 72,000 | July 8, 2025 |
| Nepal TPS | about 12,700 | June 6, 2025 |
| Nicaragua TPS | about 4,000 | July 8, 2025 |
| CHNV parole | about 532,000 | March 25, 2025 |
The report’s sharpest line, that more people have been “delegalized” than deported, also survives a check. DHS reported 483,200 removals in fiscal 2026, up 9% from 442,640 the year before, the Associated Press reported. Even both fiscal years combined, a period that starts before January 2025, come to about 925,800, below the council’s 1.3 million.
The DACA figure needs more care. A drop in active recipients is not the same as revocations: it also reflects people who did not renew and people who moved to a green card. The report treats the whole decline as lost protection, and readers should weigh that number accordingly.
“Legal status” covers three different things
The word doing the most work in the debate is “legal.” TPS under section 244 of the Immigration and Nationality Act is a statutory status that protects against removal and comes with work authorization, but it is designated country by country and the statute limits court review of those decisions. Parole under section 212(d)(5) is permission to be in the country, granted case by case, and is not an immigration status at all. DACA is deferred action, a decision not to pursue removal for a period. All three can end by agency action, without a new law.
That distinction is also the administration’s core argument. In ending CHNV, DHS wrote in the Federal Register that “parole is inherently temporary, and parole alone is not an underlying basis for obtaining any immigration status,” and that the programs “do not serve a significant public benefit.” The Supreme Court let those terminations proceed in May 2025 while litigation continued. The Federation for American Immigration Reform, which favors lower immigration, has argued that “TPS has been turned into a back-door amnesty program.” A USCIS spokesperson told NPR last December that “the American taxpayer will no longer bear the financial burden of unlawfully present aliens.”
The council answers that these people did what the system asked. “The point of the rule of law is supposed to be to encourage compliance,” senior fellow Dara Lind said in the group’s release. Senior fellow Aaron Reichlin-Melnick said the shift “is happening because of a lack of action from Congress.”
What changes for the people counted
Once TPS or parole ends, the practical effect is immediate. Work authorization tied to the program lapses, so employers face reverification. Time spent in TPS or on valid parole does not count as unlawful presence, but the clock toward the three- and ten-year reentry bars generally starts once that protection is gone, which is likely to push more people toward asylum or other relief claimed in removal proceedings. People with a pending application may be in a period of authorized stay, but DHS and ICE have said in recent detention cases that a pending application does not confer legal status.
The open question is whether Congress responds. The council’s recommendation is blunt: “the only solution to delegalization is legalization.” Bills such as the Protect Our Neighbors Act and the Dream and Promise Act are early markers, but neither has advanced. In the meantime, the numbers will move with the courts, starting with the Ninth Circuit’s Venezuelan TPS ruling and the fate of El Salvador TPS, one of the groups the report places in limbo.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- American Immigration Council, “Mass Delegalization” special report (Nov. 19, 2026) and full report PDF
- American Immigration Council press release (Nov. 19, 2026)
- DHS, Termination of Parole Processes for Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans and Venezuelans (Federal Register, March 25, 2025)
- DHS TPS termination notices: Haiti, Venezuela, Honduras, Nicaragua, Nepal
- Supreme Court, Noem v. Doe, No. 24A1079 (May 30, 2025)
- Associated Press via KJZZ, ICE fiscal 2026 removals (November 2026)
- Federation for American Immigration Reform, “Temporary Protected Status Exploited as Amnesty” (January 2025)
- NPR, Dec. 23, 2025, on immigrants losing legal status