AI Generated Image (does not depict the real facility or the people in this story)
Philadelphia immigration hearings for dozens of people with pending removal cases have been moved, on short notice, into the ICE field office at Eighth and Cherry Streets, where a judge appears by video and relatives are kept outside, the Philadelphia Inquirer reported on Nov. 18. The community group Asian Americans United told the paper it had counted at least 50 people summoned over two weeks, some with hearings that had been set a year out and at least one notified the day before.
No one is known to have been detained at these appearances, the group said. The fear comes from location, not law: for someone in removal proceedings, walking into an ICE building is not the same as walking into a courtroom, even when the hearing inside is identical.
- Where: the ICE office at Eighth and Cherry Streets, not the immigration court in the Nix Federal Building at Ninth and Market, according to the Inquirer.
- How: people wait on the third floor, then are called one at a time into a back room with a judge on a screen. Family and friends are barred from the building.
- Notice: letters and text messages, some arriving days ahead. Some hearings were pulled forward to immediate dates; others were moved to next month.
- Official response: DHS referred questions to the Justice Department, which runs the immigration courts, and DOJ did not immediately respond, the paper reported.
What the statute allows, and where it pushes back
Nothing in the Immigration and Nationality Act requires a removal hearing to take place in a courthouse. Section 240(b)(2)(A) lets an immigration judge conduct proceedings by video conference, and the immigration courts have for years run detained dockets out of ICE facilities. What is unusual here, if the Inquirer’s account holds across the cases, is the use of an ICE building for people who are not in custody, at the first stage of their cases.
Most of the summonses were for master calendar hearings, the opening appearance where a respondent admits or denies the charges in the Notice to Appear, designates a country of removal and tells the judge what relief they intend to seek. Section 239(b)(1) bars scheduling the first hearing sooner than 10 days after the Notice to Appear is served, specifically so the person has a chance to find a lawyer. For a hearing that has already been set and is then moved, section 239(a)(2) requires written notice of the new time and place. Neither provision sets a long runway, and a hearing advanced from next year to next week can comply with both on paper while leaving little practical time to retain counsel.
The stakes of not showing up are high. Under section 240(b)(5), a judge who finds that written notice was provided can order removal in absentia, and reopening such an order later requires proving lack of notice or exceptional circumstances. A text message alone would be a weak foundation for such an order. One Philadelphia lawyer told the Inquirer his client simply received a continuance and that, in his case, the appearance “wasn’t any trap.”
A pattern in a court system under pressure
The Philadelphia shift fits a broader rearrangement of where and how immigration hearings happen, from remote judges presiding by video over New York respondents who must still appear in person to hearings at the Dilley detention center that now include families not in custody. EOIR is also absorbing a leadership change, with Jamee Comans taking over as chief immigration judge, and a final rule cutting the BIA appeal deadline to 10 days takes effect Dec. 17.
Outcomes in those courts have moved sharply. According to data compiled by TRAC at Syracuse University, as cited by the Inquirer, the asylum grant rate in immigration court fell from 32 percent at the end of the Biden administration to 5.5 percent under the current one. Asian Americans United objects to holding the hearings inside an ICE building at all. “ICE is a removal agency,” organizer Elena Emelchin Brunner told the paper. The Justice Department had not responded to the Inquirer’s questions about the change.
The open question is whether this is a Philadelphia scheduling choice or the start of a policy. EOIR has not, as of this writing, announced a new hearing location for the Philadelphia court or published guidance on non-detained hearings at ICE offices. If such a notice appears, it would be the first document that lets lawyers test the practice directly. In the meantime, anyone in Philadelphia with a pending case has a simple, urgent task: check the EOIR Automated Case Information portal or call 1-800-898-7180 for the current date and location, and keep every notice received, including text messages, as proof of what was and was not sent.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Surprise ICE summons to dozens of Philly immigrants is ‘causing a lot of panic’, The Philadelphia Inquirer (Nov. 18, 2026)
- 8 U.S.C. 1229 (INA section 239), initiation of removal proceedings and notice, Legal Information Institute
- 8 U.S.C. 1229a (INA section 240), removal proceedings, video hearings and in absentia orders, Legal Information Institute
- Asylum Denials Rise to 94% Amid the Remaking of the Immigration Court, TRAC, Syracuse University
- Automated Case Information portal, Executive Office for Immigration Review
- Featured image: AI generated (does not depict the real facility or the people in this story)