AI Generated Image (not the actual court filing)
Three churches are asking a federal judge to make the government disclose how far Homeland Security Investigations went in watching congregations during last winter’s Minneapolis immigration operation.
HSI surveillance of churches is now a formal question in federal court in Minnesota. On Nov. 18, three Twin Cities congregations filed a friend-of-the-court brief backing a defense motion that seeks the full record of undercover work by Homeland Security Investigations, ICE’s investigative arm, in the prosecution of 15 people charged over protests at the Whipple Federal Building, MPR News reported. The churches are First Universalist Church and Hennepin Avenue United Methodist in Minneapolis and St. John the Evangelist Episcopal Church in St. Paul.
The case, known locally as the Minnesota 15, began with a June indictment charging conspiracy to impede or injure federal officers, the offense defined in 18 U.S.C. 372, tied to blockades at the building that houses the Fort Snelling immigration court and ICE offices. According to MPR, much of the evidence comes from undercover agents who joined Signal chats and attended meetings, and records produced so far show HSI obtained years of financial records from labor unions and sent agents to gatherings at libraries, parks, union halls and churches under operation names including “Project Whipple Shield.”
The church episodes in the court file are specific. An agent attended a Sunrise Movement meeting at First Universalist on Dec. 13, 2025, and reported no crime but wrote that “further attendance was determined to be necessary to rule out violations of law,” MPR reported. Agents later circled the church during a memorial service, according to its senior minister, Jen Crow. In April, an undercover agent at a Direct Action Minnesota meeting at St. John’s ran the plates of cars parked outside; prosecutors describe that group as an “antifa affinity group.”
The legal fight is about discovery, not guilt. Defense counsel for lead defendant Isaac Sant argues the government’s first production left out material from the undercover agents’ phones and laptops. Prosecutors answered in September that the request is “extraordinarily broad,” unnecessary to the defense and could endanger informants and agents. Criminal discovery runs on Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 16 and the government’s constitutional duty to disclose evidence favorable to the defense, and judges routinely balance those duties against protecting confidential sources. Amicus briefs are uncommon at this stage of a criminal case; this is the second, after one filed in August by the Cato Institute, a libertarian think tank, with the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression and the Society for the Rule of Law. “There’s not criminal activity to justify the wide dragnet of surveillance that occurred here,” the churches’ lawyer, Irina Vaynerman, told MPR. The U.S. Attorney’s Office in Minnesota declined to comment on the brief.
Why it reaches beyond one prosecution. The charges followed NSPM-7, a September 2025 presidential memorandum on “Countering Domestic Terrorism and Organized Political Violence,” and the Minnesota file is one of the most detailed public records of how DHS investigators have put it into practice around immigration enforcement. Whatever the judge orders on discovery will shape how much of that record becomes public. It also bears on a long-running question for immigration agencies: DHS’s policy of limiting enforcement at “protected areas,” including places of worship, was rescinded in January 2025, and investigative monitoring of meetings inside churches is a different activity from arrests there, one that rarely surfaces in public records at all. For congregations that host immigrant-rights groups, the practical effect is already visible. Crow told MPR some members have stopped attending in person.
The next step is the judge’s ruling on the motion to compel. Related coverage of federal tactics in Minnesota includes a judge blocking a search of an immigration lawyer’s seized phone, the Omar search warrant dispute and the Senate probe of the Appleton detention facility purchase.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources: MPR News, “Twin Cities churches go to court seeking full details of federal surveillance during ICE ops” (Nov. 18, 2026); 18 U.S.C. 372; Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 16. Featured image: AI generated (not the actual court filing).