A U.S. Border Patrol agent patrols near Metaline Falls, Wash., in August 2023. U.S. Customs and Border Protection photo (public domain). File photo, not from the events in this story.
A Seattle magistrate judge ruled that re-detaining a Port Angeles man without notice or a hearing violated due process, a question that reaches people who have lived for years under ICE supervision orders.
A federal magistrate judge in Seattle has ruled that re-detention without notice was unconstitutional for Noune Phompor, a 47-year-old Port Angeles, Wash., man born in a Laotian refugee camp, and he walked out of the Northwest ICE Processing Center in Tacoma on Nov. 20. The Peninsula Daily News reported that U.S. Magistrate Judge S. Kate Vaughan of the Western District of Washington signed the habeas order on Nov. 19, nearly three months after Border Patrol agents arrested him on a removal order that dates to 2009.
The case matters now because people released years ago, when their home countries would not take them back, are being picked up again as those countries accept returns. Phompor’s lawyers did not argue that ICE can never re-detain such a person. They argued that it cannot do so with no process at all, and the court agreed.
A 2009 order that Laos would not honor
According to the newspaper’s reporting, Phompor arrived in the United States as a child in 1981 with his refugee family and grew up in Fresno, Calif. A 2007 California drug possession conviction led an immigration judge in Eloy, Ariz., to order him removed on Nov. 16, 2009. Laos was not accepting deportees then, so he was released and reported to immigration authorities under supervision, the paper reported.
Border Patrol’s Blaine Sector arrested him during a lunch break on Sept. 1. In a social media post at the time, quoted by the Peninsula Daily News, the agency said agents had apprehended “a Laos citizen illegally present in the U.S.” with “an extensive criminal history,” and that he was awaiting removal. His habeas petition, as quoted by the paper, said agents gave him only “a cursory notice of revocation of his release” and told him for the first time that a travel document existed. A temporary restraining order in October stopped ICE from moving him to Arizona to stage his removal, the paper reported.
What the re-detention ruling turned on
Federal regulations already require some process when ICE revokes a supervision release. Under 8 C.F.R. 241.4(l), a person returned to custody must be told the reasons for the revocation and given an initial informal interview promptly afterward to respond. Phompor’s attorney, Thomas Kaplan of Columbia Legal Services, told the newspaper that the judge found that “providing effectively no pre-detention process” was constitutionally deficient, weighing the liberty interest, the risk of error and the government’s interest. That three-part weighing is the familiar due process test from Mathews v. Eldridge, and the practical effect is to ask what the government should do before, not after, it takes someone back into custody.
The order itself was not publicly available for review, so its description rests on Kaplan’s account; the paper reported no government response.
Similar process arguments won in the Maine case of a Special Immigrant Juvenile teenager arrested without a warrant and are central to fights over immediate re-arrests after court-ordered release, though not every petitioner wins, as the denial of release for a man shot by ICE in New York shows.
The vacated conviction is the bigger fight
Release does not end the case. According to the habeas petition as quoted by the paper, a California court in October vacated “the sole conviction underlying” the removal order because of legal error affecting his ability to understand the immigration consequences of his plea. Under the Board of Immigration Appeals’ decision in Matter of Pickering, 23 I&N Dec. 621 (BIA 2003), a conviction vacated for a legal defect in the underlying proceedings no longer counts for immigration purposes, while one erased only for rehabilitation or hardship still does. That distinction is likely to decide whether his lawyers can reopen the 2009 order and have it withdrawn, which Kaplan said is the relief he is now pursuing in immigration court.
The ruling’s reach depends on Laos. The paper noted that the U.S. government labeled Laos a “recalcitrant” country on deportations in 2018, and the Asian Law Caucus, an Asian American civil rights group, told the Peninsula Daily News that more than 4,800 people ICE considers Lao nationals have removal orders. The open question is whether other judges in the circuit will demand the same pre-detention process before those cases move. Kaplan said the habeas case is closed unless the government appeals; any appeal would go to the Ninth Circuit.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- Peninsula Daily News: Port Angeles man released from ICE facility (Nov. 21, 2026)
- Peninsula Daily News: Lawyers fighting to free detained Port Angeles man (Oct. 24, 2026)
- Peninsula Daily News: Port Angeles man arrested by ICE officials (Sept. 8, 2026)
- 8 C.F.R. 241.4, continued detention and revocation of release (eCFR)
- Matter of Pickering, 23 I&N Dec. 621 (BIA 2003), EOIR precedent decisions, Volume 23
- Featured image: U.S. Customs and Border Protection photo by Jerry Glaser (public domain)