AI Generated Image (does not depict the Hennepin County Jail or any person in this story)
DHS has made a Hennepin County jail release the opening case in a daily “Sanctuary Insanity” series. Underneath the rhetoric sits a real legal standoff over what Minnesota jails may do with an ICE detainer.
The Department of Homeland Security says the Hennepin County Jail released an Ecuadorian man arrested for criminal sexual conduct even though ICE had asked the jail to hold him, and it blames Minneapolis-area “sanctuary politicians.” The Hennepin County ICE detainer dispute behind that complaint is older and narrower than the headline suggests: the sheriff says Minnesota law forbids her jail from holding anyone on an ICE detainer alone, and the state’s attorney general agrees.
According to the Nov. 20 DHS release, ICE lodged a detainer on Nov. 11 against Oscar Daniel Chisag Zumbana while he was held at the jail after an arrest for criminal sexual conduct. DHS said the jail released him without honoring the detainer or notifying ICE, that he entered the country illegally in 2021 and was released by the previous administration, and that he “remains at large.” The release does not say whether he has been charged or convicted, or whether a judge set bail or ordered his release. An arrest is not a finding of guilt.
“This is sanctuary insanity at work,” Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said in the release, adding that sanctuary policies “only serve to protect criminal illegal aliens while putting every single American at risk.” DHS called the release part of “a new daily series.”
What the Hennepin County ICE detainer policy actually says
The jail is run by the Hennepin County Sheriff’s Office, not the city of Minneapolis. Sheriff Dawanna Witt has described the rule in plain terms. “We have a longstanding policy that requests from any agency to take custody of someone are honored when accompanied by a judicial warrant,” she said in a statement reported by FOX 9 in August. An ICE detainer (Form I-247A) is a request signed by an immigration officer, not a judge, so the jail does not hold people on it.
The part of the policy that matters most in this case is notification. Holding someone past release and telling ICE when he will walk out are different acts. Witt told MPR News in February, “Right now, we do not make notifications,” and said she was “not interested in being sued.” Some Minnesota sheriffs choose differently; Benton County’s sheriff told WCCO his office notifies ICE of releases for people with detainers. The Hennepin County Board passed a resolution on Feb. 12 backing the current policy and telling the sheriff not to expand cooperation voluntarily, FOX 9 reported.
The state law question
On holding, Minnesota law leans heavily toward the sheriff. In Opinion 3-a, issued Feb. 6, 2025, Attorney General Keith Ellison concluded that “Minnesota law prohibits state and local law enforcement agencies from holding someone based on an immigration detainer if the person would otherwise be released from custody.” Keeping someone past release is a new arrest, the opinion says, and ICE’s administrative warrants (Forms I-200 and I-205) are not valid arrest warrants under state law because they are issued by immigration officials, not judges. The opinion relied in part on Esparza v. Nobles County, a 2019 Court of Appeals decision affirming an injunction against a county that held people for ICE. The decision is unpublished and came at a preliminary stage, so it is not binding precedent.
Notification is a different matter. The Nobles County injunction expressly let the county keep telling ICE about release dates, and the attorney general’s opinion addresses holding, not notice. That leaves release notification largely a local policy choice, and it is where Hennepin County and DHS actually part ways.
The federal case for cooperation
DHS’s argument is practical as much as legal. When White House border czar Tom Homan announced the end of the Minnesota enforcement surge in February, he said ICE now had “the ability to arrest criminal aliens in the safety and security of jails” across Minnesota, according to FOX 9. The argument is that a handoff at the jail door is safer than a later street arrest, and that a released suspect may not be found again, the risk DHS says played out here.
The pressure has gone beyond press releases. In August, Witt said federal subpoenas warned that refusing to hold certain inmates “could be considered tampering with a witness,” FOX 9 reported. “Threats of prosecution will not cause me to abandon our legal responsibilities,” she said. A DHS spokesperson responded that “ICE will not be slowing down on enforcing federal law.” No charges have been reported.
The size of the problem is disputed. DHS has said more than 1,360 Minnesota inmates had active ICE detainers, while a FOX 9 reporter estimated about 300 noncitizens were held in Minnesota jails, the station noted in its August report. Neither figure is backed by public data that can be checked.
Where this goes next
Both sides point to the Legislature. The sheriff’s office has said lasting change “must come through clear statewide policy direction and legislation,” a position it gave MPR News, and the attorney general’s opinion notes that Minnesota already requires notice to ICE in narrow cases, such as certain convicted felons under Minn. Stat. § 631.50. A bill widening that notice duty, or a 287(g) agreement of the kind Texas now mandates, would change the picture. Absent either, a daily DHS series is likely to keep naming individual releases while the legal rule stays where it is.
Similar fights are playing out over California’s SB 54 and Washington’s Keep Washington Working Act, and some sheriffs who embraced ICE agreements lost reelection this month. In Hennepin County, the open questions are concrete: whether Chisag Zumbana is charged and found, whether federal prosecutors act on the subpoena threats, and whether the 2027 session takes up release notification.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Homeland Security, “Sanctuary Insanity” release on Hennepin County, Nov. 20, 2026
- Minnesota Attorney General, Opinion 3-a on immigration detainers, Feb. 6, 2025
- Esparza v. Nobles County, No. A18-2011 (Minn. Ct. App. Sept. 23, 2019) (unpublished)
- FOX 9, “ICE threatens Hennepin County sheriff with federal prosecution over access to inmates,” Aug. 5, 2026
- FOX 9, “Feds threaten Hennepin County Sheriff with prosecution over jail’s ICE detainer policy,” Aug. 6, 2026
- FOX 9, “Hennepin Co. board tells sheriff not to alter ICE policy,” Feb. 12, 2026
- MPR News, interview with Sheriff Dawanna Witt, Feb. 5, 2026
- MPR News, “How do immigration detainers in county jails work?” Feb. 3, 2026
- WCCO/CBS News Minnesota, “Dawanna Witt denies deal with ICE,” Feb. 13, 2026