When someone is caught by immigration authorities but is not kept in a detention center, they may be allowed to live in the community while their immigration case is ongoing. But how do the authorities make sure that the person follows the rules and shows up to court? That’s where ICE’s Alternatives to Detention (ATD) program comes in.
❓ What Is ATD?
ATD stands for Alternatives to Detention. It is a program run by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). The goal is to help people follow immigration rules without locking them up in a detention center.
Instead of keeping someone in jail while their case is going on, ICE can allow them to live outside, under supervision. This is often for people who:
- Have families or children
- Are not dangerous
- Have no serious criminal history
👨💼 What Is ISAP?
ISAP stands for Intensive Supervision Appearance Program. It is the main part of the ATD program. People in ISAP are still under watch by ICE, but they are not in a detention center.
ISAP uses:
- Case managers who check in with the person regularly
- Electronic ankle monitors in some cases
- Phone calls, mobile apps, or in-person check-ins
These tools help make sure the person:
- Knows their rights and responsibilities
- Attends immigration court hearings
- Keeps ICE informed of where they live
✅ Why Is This Program Important?
- It reduces the need for detention, which is expensive for the government
- It helps families stay together while waiting for their immigration case
- It increases the chances that people show up to their court hearings
Studies have shown that many people in ISAP do show up to court and follow the rules.
💡 Simple Example
Let’s say a mother and her child are caught crossing the border and ask for asylum. Instead of sending them to a detention center, ICE may put them in the ISAP program. A case manager helps them find legal help and reminds them when to go to court. They may have to check in regularly or wear an ankle bracelet for tracking.
This way, they can live freely, stay with family, and still follow the immigration process.
🔍 How Many People Are in ATD or ISAP Today?
As of mid-2025, about 183,756 individuals are in the ATD-ISAP program. In comparison, about 56,000 people are being held in immigration detention centers. Cities like San Francisco, Chicago, Miami, and Los Angeles have the most participants.
😮 Are Children in ISAP Too?
Yes, families with children can be placed in ISAP. However, children are not tracked with ankle monitors. The monitoring is usually on the parent or guardian. Families still get support from case managers and are expected to follow court rules.
🚪 How Do the Monitors Work?
Some people are given ankle monitors (GPS devices), which must be worn at all times. Others may use a phone app called SmartLINK to check in.
Are ankle monitors visible?
Yes. They are worn on the ankle and can be seen if the person wears shorts or skirts. This can be embarrassing for some people in public.
Do monitors need to be charged?
Yes. Ankle monitors must be charged daily, usually for 1 to 2 hours. Not charging it may cause problems or alerts to ICE.
📱 What Is SmartLINK?
SmartLINK is a phone app used by ICE to track people and help them check in. It asks users to take selfies, confirm locations, and attend court.
About 87% to 90% of ISAP participants now use SmartLINK instead of ankle monitors, making it the most common method today.
💸 Who Pays for ISAP Monitoring Devices?
The cost of monitors or the SmartLINK app is paid by ICE, not the person being monitored.
| Monitoring Tool | Cost to ICE (per day per person) |
|---|---|
| GPS ankle monitor | ~$2.75/day |
| SmartLINK App | ~$1.00/day |
| Voice ID (phone) | ~$0.17/day |
| Detention (compare) | ~$152/day |
ICE pays private contractors to run these programs. Participants do not have to pay for the monitoring devices.
💬 How Can a Family Member Request ISAP?
If someone is in immigration detention, their lawyer or family member can contact the local ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) office and ask for that person to be put in ATD/ISAP. ICE reviews each case based on:
- Criminal history
- Immigration violations
- Family situation
- Health or safety concerns
ICE may agree to release them with conditions if they qualify.
📽️ Why Isn’t This in the News More Often?
ATD and ISAP don’t get as much media attention because they happen quietly in the community, without arrests or court drama. But they affect thousands of families and cost millions of taxpayer dollars.
🔎 Final Thoughts
The ATD and ISAP programs are tools ICE uses to watch over non-detained immigrants in a fair and effective way. While these programs are not perfect, they help balance immigration enforcement with human dignity, especially for families, children, and others who pose no threat to society.
If you or someone you know is part of ATD or ISAP, it’s very important to:
- Follow all instructions
- Show up to court
- Stay in touch with your case manager