The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) recently published the H1b Modernization Rule which will go into effect on January 17, 2025. It has been welcomed by many stakeholders, but I want to highlight in this blog how it impacts the IT consulting H1b employees and firms.
Submission of client contracts and matching approval period
Based on this new rule the submission of contracts with layers starting from petitioner to end-client will be required. For last few years, United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) did not insist on any supporting documents like Contracts / Purchase Order / client letters, but now after this new rule USCIS will require submission of these documents to prove existence of employment or bona fide job offer. This will also mean USCIS approving H1b only for the time period listed in the Contract / Purchase Order / Client letter. This will entail filing repeated H1b extensions if the approval period is for a shorter term. So looks like, the last few good years of able to get a three year approval without contractual documents will be things of the past. There were many IT consulting firms which were filing H1b petitions without a project and this cannot be possible any more. Even if a project existed, it was very difficult sometimes to obtain documents from end client relating to confirmation of an assignment. So paperwork for H1b petitions are definitely going to increase by way of submission of more documents and also respond to Request for Evidence (RFE) relating to existence of project. As many IT firms and consultants might be aware, this was a major issue some years back. So I will recommend filing of H1b extensions now under premium (before new rule kicks in) if you will not be in a position of getting contractual documents from clients.
H1b beneficiaries can form their own company and be employed
The new rule says that H1b beneficiaries who have controlling interest in a company will be able to be employed on H1b, as far as, majority of their work relates to specialty occupation. So, a H1b beneficiary who owns more than 50% shares in a company can work as Solutions Architect(say for example) as far as they devote majority of their time on duties related to Solutions Architect. So this rule allows H1b beneficiaries having majority ownership in a company to be an owner and also be involved in H1b duties and also be involved in duties administering or running the company as far as the duties are minimal. I feel, this is a game changer since many H1b beneficiaries can potentially start their own company and file their own H1bs. In such cases, as per the new rule, the initial H1b will be given validity of 18 months and then the first extension will also be valid for 18 months. But, I feel filing of employment based Green Card through their own companies might still pose some challenges unless the issue relating to employer-employee relationship is not properly addressed before the PERM process is started.
Impact on long pending H1b petitions
There are situations when a H1b petition is pending beyond the end date requested in the H1b petitions. In such cases, the new rule says that the employer can submit a new LCA for the period beyond the end date requested and get an approval. Although it is not clear how this will play out procedurally, I can safely say that USCIS may issue a RFE for a new LCA. But, I based on my experience will always suggest filing another H1b extension before the end date requested in the pending H1b petition while the H1b petition is pending. Before we some trend on how USCIS deals with such scenarios it is better to be safe and file H1b extensions while a H1b petition is pending.
Specialty Occupation issue
Specialty occupation is one major issue for which H1bs get denied. Basically, as per USCIS regulations in order for a position to be considered as a specialty occupation, the position should require a minimum of Bachelor’s degree in a related field. There were always some issues about this, where USCIS will question the requirement of employers. Many times immigration practitioners and employers will refer to Occupational Outlook Handbook (OOH) which sets out requirement for major occupations in software development, database administration, system administration. As per the current standard, we could argue that since the OOH says for a particular position Bachelors degree in a particular major is normally required the position is specialty occupation. As per the new rule USCIS is saying that “normally” does not mean “always”. So it makes the scope of specialty occupation more narrow. But the new rule is favorable when it says that employers can require major in different fields as far as the majors are related to the occupation. Prior to this new rule, the employers cannot require a Business Analyst to have a Bachelor’s degree in Computer Science / Business Analytics and USCIS will come back and say Computer Science and Business Analytics are not related. Now the onus is more on the employer to show that either Business Analytics or Computer Science can aid the beneficiary in fulfilling the H1b duties and these majors are directly related to the job. So, I will say one has to do proper analysis of the job duties and the requirement before the filing of the H1b petition.
H1b Site Visits and Obligation to Comply
As per the new rule, employers and H1b beneficiaries will have to mandatorily comply with any H1b site visit enquiries. Prior to this new rule, an employer or H1b beneficiary could refrain from cooperating on such H1b site visit enquiries. But based on the new rule as part of site visit the FDNS officers can visit the homes, client sites or petitioner’s office and interview anyone involved as part of the H1b petition including client managers and co-operation is mandated.
CAP GAP policy expanded
As most of you might be aware, CAP GAP policy allowed a F-1 OPT student to be employed till October 1st while a H1b petition is pending. But there were instances when the H1b petition remained pending beyond the requested start date of October 1st. Now as per this new rule, they are extending this CAP GAP till the following April 1st or till the H1b is adjudicated. So basically, additional six months have been added to the existing CAP GAP policy. Before this new rule the only option for someone who’s H1b petition remained pending after October 1st was to stop employment or opt for converting the case to premium which involved high premium filing fees. So this six months further extension on CAP GAP is a welcome change and the hope is that in that additional six months the H1b will be adjudicated.
Guaranteed approval if nothing has changed in H1b employment
The new rule also says that if the terms of employment remains the same then the H1b petition should be approved. For example, the employer remains the same and the job duties are same then H1b petition should be approved. Based on this rule, I feel we can also stretch this criteria to H1b petition with a new employer as far as the duties remain the same and the requirements for the job also remain the same. So, it will be important to highlight in the H1b petition that material terms of employment has not changed and try to get an approval. But, if USCIS feels the prior H1b was approved in error then USCIS can re-adjudicate the new H1b petition. Overall, I feel this is a welcome change since many of the H1bs we find that the H1b beneficiary is employed in the same job and in the same industry and salary level is more or less the same and the requirements are also same. It will benefit H1b beneficiaries who have worked in the past on H1b for some years and continue to work in the same role with similar employers.
Introduction of new H1b forms
USCIS will be introducing new I-129 form for H1b and starting January 17, 2025 only the new forms can be used. They are likely to add many new fields in the forms asking for additional details to reflect the above changes. That is why it may make sense to get the H1b petitions like H1b extensions filed before the new rule kicks in, if you feel some of the rules will work against you.
Can the Trump Administration change or revoke the new rule
Trump administration cannot revoke these new rules through an executive order. But, what the new administration can do is to publish a new rule, wait for the comment period and then publish it in Federal Register. This cannot happen in few months and I feel it can easily take another 9 to 12 months based on the past. But, if revoking the rules is an high stake agenda for the new administration then can try to push through a new rule in around 4 months. Only time will tell and right now it is not clear if for the new Trump administration H1b issue is top priority. Focus I think, will be more on deportation of people who entered illegally or overstaying illegally or immigrants involved in crime.
In summary, I will say the new rule is a mixed bag. It increases the work load by way of requiring contracts with clients but says prior H1b approval will take precedence if there is no material change in employment. The new rule also benefits self employment by H1b beneficiaries and F-1 students to be employed while their first H1b petition remains pending for an extended period.