AI Generated Image (not the actual petition in this case)
A federal judge says USCIS demanded criminal-trial proof from a citizen sponsor when its own precedent required only a preponderance of the evidence.
A federal judge has ruled that USCIS used the wrong burden of proof in an Adam Walsh Act I-130 case, throwing out the agency’s denial of a Georgia man’s petition for his wife, a Mexican national, the Tampa Free Press reported. U.S. District Judge Royce C. Lamberth of the District of Columbia filed the memorandum opinion in Castaneira v. Noem on Nov. 12, 2026, according to the court’s opinion index, and the ruling matters to every U.S. citizen and green card holder whose criminal record blocks a family petition unless the government finds they pose “no risk” to the relative they want to sponsor.
The case turns on a gap in the Adam Walsh Act process. The 2006 law bars a citizen or permanent resident convicted of a “specified offense against a minor” from filing Form I-130 unless the Secretary of Homeland Security, in “sole and unreviewable discretion,” decides the petitioner poses no risk to the beneficiary. Congress never said how much proof that finding requires. A February 2007 internal USCIS memo from Michael Aytes filled the space, telling officers to deny unless the petitioner showed, “beyond any reasonable doubt,” that he posed no risk. That is the standard used to convict in a criminal trial.
How the Castaneira case reached this point
Ryan Castaneira’s Georgia convictions came from online exchanges with an adult undercover officer posing as a minor, and USCIS denied his petition under the Act. He sued without a lawyer in 2022. Lamberth dismissed the case in July 2023, holding the no-risk decision and its standard beyond judicial review, as other circuits had.
The D.C. Circuit partly reversed on May 30, 2025. It agreed that the no-risk judgment itself cannot be second-guessed and that Castaneira’s offenses fall under the Act even though no actual child was involved, but held that if USCIS has bound itself to an evidentiary standard through precedent, a court can review whether the agency followed it. The precedent at issue is Matter of Chawathe, a 2010 decision of the USCIS Administrative Appeals Office that adopts the preponderance standard “except where a different standard is specified by law.” The panel treated the Aytes memo as internal guidance, not binding precedent, and sent the case back.
On remand, District Judge Lamberth found that USCIS was bound by Chawathe under the Accardi doctrine, which requires agencies to follow their own rules, according to the Tampa Free Press. “The immense amount of daylight between those burdens makes the Agency’s adjudication substantially defective and likely to prejudice Plaintiff,” the judge wrote, as quoted by the outlet. The outlet reported that government lawyers argued Chawathe never applied to Adam Walsh Act waivers and that a recent Supreme Court decision removed the court’s jurisdiction, and that Lamberth rejected both, noting USCIS had applied the preponderance standard in similar cases in 2012. He dismissed a separate claim attacking the 2007 memo directly, the outlet said, and sent the petition back to USCIS for a fresh decision.
What the ruling changes, and what it does not
The no-risk call stays with USCIS. Nothing in the ruling orders approval; USCIS can deny again if it weighs the evidence under a more-likely-than-not standard. The Board of Immigration Appeals held in Matter of Aceijas-Quiroz (2014) that it cannot review these determinations, so federal court is the only outside check, and only on legal and procedural questions.
The ruling is narrow, but the reasoning travels. The decision binds the parties in this case. Other petitioners in the D.C. federal courts can cite it, while elsewhere they face appeals courts that have held Adam Walsh Act decisions unreviewable.
USCIS has a cleaner path than an appeal. The D.C. Circuit said plainly that “nothing in the Act required the agency to adopt any particular standard.” That suggests the agency could restore a heightened standard by putting it in a regulation or a designated precedent decision rather than an internal memo. Doing so would reset the dispute on firmer ground for the government. An appeal to the D.C. Circuit is also possible; the government generally has 60 days from judgment to file a notice of appeal.
For families with pending or recently denied cases, the denial notice itself now matters: language applying a beyond-a-reasonable-doubt test is the kind of legal error this court has found reviewable. Related coverage includes a recent Fourth Circuit ruling on the green card burden of proof, the reopening of older green card cases at USCIS, and the detention of an I-601A waiver holder before a consular interview.
What to watch
- A government appeal: whether the Justice Department files a notice of appeal to the D.C. Circuit.
- USCIS policy: any rule, Policy Manual update or precedent decision setting an explicit standard of proof for no-risk determinations.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, 2026 opinions index (Castaneira v. Noem, No. 22-cv-1485, Doc. 58, filed Nov. 12, 2026)
- D.C. Circuit opinion, Castaneira v. Noem, No. 23-5204 (May 30, 2025)
- D.D.C. memorandum opinion, Castaneira v. Mayorkas (July 2023)
- Matter of Aceijas-Quiroz, 26 I&N Dec. 294 (BIA 2014)
- Tampa Free Press, report on the Nov. 2026 ruling (Nov. 15, 2026)