ICE Special Response Team officers with ERO Boston attend a pre-operation brief in Warwick, R.I., in May 2025. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement photo (public domain). File photo, not from the events in this story.
Nearly three weeks after Massachusetts barred warrantless civil arrests in its courthouses, state court data show ICE is still making them, and the only official empowered to enforce the ban has not yet gone to court.
PROTECT Act courthouse arrests have continued in Massachusetts despite the state’s new ban. Immigration agents have made nearly three dozen arrests at Massachusetts courthouses since the law’s courthouse provision took effect on Nov. 3, WBUR reported on Nov. 22, citing Massachusetts Trial Court data. The first contested arrest came on day one. Since then the law has become a live test of whether a state can keep federal civil immigration enforcement out of its own courthouses, and Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell’s office says it is still weighing how to respond.
What the courthouse provision actually requires
Gov. Maura Healey signed Chapter 163 of the Acts of 2026 on Aug. 5; its courthouse section, a new Chapter 221D of the General Laws, took effect 90 days later. It bars a civil arrest anywhere in a state courthouse unless the officer presents a warrant or order issued by a judge or magistrate to a designated judge in that building, and it forbids civil arrests inside a courtroom even with such a warrant. An ICE administrative warrant, signed by an immigration officer rather than a judge, does not qualify.
The statute labels a violating arrest false imprisonment under state law, but it gives the arrested person no right to sue under the courthouse section. Enforcement runs through the attorney general, who may seek declaratory or injunctive relief in Superior Court; individuals keep habeas corpus. A separate state civil rights claim in the act carries the same defenses, including qualified immunity, that apply in federal suits under 42 U.S.C. 1983.
That design explains the standoff. Trial Court policy tells court security to log and report apparent violations, not to stop them. Until the attorney general files, no one is positioned to ask a judge to halt the practice.
How the arrest count has grown
The figures come from Trial Court records relayed to reporters. They are not identical in scope; GBH noted it was unclear how many of the 28 arrests it was told about were civil rather than criminal.
| Period | Reported arrests | Reported by |
|---|---|---|
| Nov. 3 (first day) | 5 | MassLive and WBUR, citing Trial Court data |
| Nov. 3 to Nov. 12 | 22 | CBS Boston, citing court security records |
| Nov. 3 to Nov. 18 | 28 | GBH, citing the Trial Court |
| Nov. 3 to about Nov. 20 | Nearly three dozen | WBUR, citing Trial Court data |
For scale, GBH obtained Trial Court records through a public records request showing 614 ICE arrests in Massachusetts courthouses during all of 2025. Based on those figures, the pace since Nov. 3 is roughly in line with last year’s, which suggests the law has not yet changed ICE’s behavior.
WBUR reported that Rhyan Oliveira, 24, was arrested in the lobby of Framingham District Court on Nov. 17 after a judge released him on conditions in a state felony case; it found no federal criminal charges against him. Other arrests were reported at Marlborough District Court and the Fall River Justice Center.
The Supremacy Clause argument and its limits
ICE’s position is blunt. “Sanctuary politicians do not control federal law enforcement,” a spokesperson said, citing the Supremacy Clause, in statements reported by WBUR and CBS Boston. Andrew Arthur of the Center for Immigration Studies, which favors lower immigration levels, told WBUR that “states can’t regulate the activity of the federal government, and courthouses are public places where anybody can go.” Jen Klein of the Committee for Public Counsel Services, the state’s public defender agency, told WBUR the practice “dismantles due process.”
The case law cuts both ways. States stand on firm ground when they decline to help: a federal judge in New York dismissed the Justice Department’s challenge to that state’s Protect Our Courts Act in November 2025 on Tenth Amendment grounds. They stand on weaker ground when they dictate how federal officers act. This month a federal judge blocked Connecticut’s mask, ID and force rules as applied to federal agents, and California’s agent-identification law was permanently enjoined. Massachusetts courts have history here too: in Ryan v. ICE, the First Circuit in 2020 vacated an injunction against courthouse immigration arrests, finding it unclear that the common-law privilege against civil arrest at court reached immigration arrests.
Chapter 221D sits between those poles: it governs state buildings, but by making a federal officer’s arrest unlawful under state law. An attorney general suit is likely to be removed to federal court and met with an intergovernmental immunity defense. No lawsuit by either side over the provision has been reported.
The practical effect for now is that a Massachusetts court date carries much the same arrest risk it did before Nov. 3. Campbell’s office told GBH on Nov. 18 that it is “actively evaluating all available legal options to protect access to our courthouses.”
What to watch:
- Whether the attorney general files a Chapter 221D enforcement action in Superior Court, and whether the federal government removes it or sues first.
- The Trial Court’s first annual report on courthouse arrests required under the new chapter.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.
Sources
- WBUR: ICE continues courthouse arrests, despite state’s new PROTECT Act (Nov. 22, 2026)
- Massachusetts Acts of 2026, Chapter 163 (PROTECT Act)
- Office of Gov. Maura Healey: PROTECT Act signing release (Aug. 5, 2026)
- Massachusetts Trial Court policy on interactions with ICE
- GBH: Advocates call on Campbell, Healey to investigate PROTECT Act violations (Nov. 18, 2026)
- GBH: Over 600 ICE arrests in Massachusetts courthouses in 2025 (March 17, 2026)
- CBS Boston: ICE arrests continue despite PROTECT Act (Nov. 17, 2026)
- MassLive: ICE arrests at Massachusetts courthouses continue (Nov. 13, 2026)
- Boston Globe: ICE arrest at Marlborough District Court (Nov. 18, 2026)
- New Bedford Light: ICE arrests Haitian man in Fall River courthouse (Nov. 20, 2026)
- New York Attorney General: Protect Our Courts Act challenge dismissed (November 2025)
- Featured image: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement on Flickr (public domain)