A major change to the H‑1B visa cap selection process may be on the horizon. On July 17, 2025, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) submitted a proposed rule titled “Weighted Selection Process for Registrants and Petitioners Seeking To File Cap-Subject H-1B Petitions” to the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) for review under Executive Order 12866. The rule, identified by RIN 1615‑AD01, seeks to replace the current random lottery with a wage-based or merit-weighted system.
Though the full regulatory text has not yet been published, several key developments, public reactions, and historical precedents offer strong clues about the rule’s likely direction—and its implications for employers, startups, universities, and international students.
Public Reactions: Elon Musk Approves
Shortly after news of the proposal surfaced, Right Angle News Network tweeted:
“BREAKING – President Trump’s administration is moving to end the unfair H‑1B visa lottery, replacing it with a merit-based, salary-ranked system that prioritizes highly skilled, top-earning workers.”
In response, Elon Musk simply replied: “Great.”
The endorsement reflects enthusiasm from leaders in the tech sector for a selection model that favors high-salary, highly-skilled candidates. But while large corporations may benefit, others may be left out under a purely wage-driven system.
Why the Full Rule Text Is Not Public and What We Know from the Trump-Era Blueprint?
Until OIRA completes its review, DHS is prohibited from releasing the full proposal. The current stage is considered pre-decisional and deliberative, meaning the public won’t see the actual regulatory text until it is published in the Federal Register as a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM). At that point, stakeholders will have an opportunity to submit public comments, typically over a 30–60 day window.
Although the language of the current proposal is not yet public, the policy concept is not new. In fact, it closely resembles an earlier attempt made during the Trump administration. In 2020, DHS finalized a rule that would have:
- Replaced the H‑1B random lottery with a wage-ranked selection system, giving priority to higher-paid positions in descending order from Level IV to Level I
- Worked in tandem with a Department of Labor rule that raised prevailing wage minimums by 30–60 percent for H‑1B, E‑3, H‑1B1, and PERM filings
That attempt, however, failed due to procedural errors, not because the substance of the policy was deemed invalid.
The last time DHS and DOL tried to implement a wage-based H‑1B selection system and raise prevailing wages, both rules were struck down by federal courts. The courts did not reject the underlying goals but ruled that the agencies failed to follow proper administrative procedures.
In Chamber of Commerce et al. v. DHS, the court vacated the DHS rule after finding that then-Acting Secretary Chad Wolf lacked lawful authority when issuing it. In Purdue University et al. v. Scalia, the court struck down DOL’s prevailing wage rule for bypassing the required notice-and-comment process under the Administrative Procedure Act.
Although those rules were vacated, they offer a preview of how the current proposal may be structured. The Trump-era H‑1B selection rule, published in January 2021, was titled “Modification of Registration Requirement for Petitioners Seeking To File Cap-Subject H-1B Petitions” and proposed a fundamental overhaul of how USCIS selects registrations when demand exceeds the cap.
Here is what the rule included:
- Replace the random lottery: The traditional random selection process for the 65,000 regular cap and 20,000 U.S. master’s cap would be eliminated.
- Wage-based ranking system: USCIS would rank registrations based on the offered wage level, using the Department of Labor’s Occupational Employment Statistics (OES) wage levels. Level IV registrations would be selected first, followed by Level III, Level II, and then Level I.
- No additional preference for U.S. master’s degrees: Although the master’s cap exemption would still exist, having a U.S. advanced degree would not increase a beneficiary’s selection odds unless the wage level was also high.
- Randomization within tiers: If registrations within a particular wage level exceeded the number of available slots, USCIS would conduct a random lottery within that tier.
- Stated objective: DHS justified the rule as a way to attract the “best and brightest” by prioritizing highly paid, highly skilled workers. It also aimed to reduce perceived abuse of the system by outsourcing companies that rely on lower-paid workers.
- Expected impact: DHS acknowledged that registrations at Level I—often used for recent graduates and entry-level professionals—would be unlikely to receive selections under this system. Even Level II registrations might face reduced selection odds if demand remains high.
- Status and outcome: The rule was finalized on January 8, 2021, and scheduled to take effect in March 2021. However, it was vacated by a federal court and later formally withdrawn by the Biden administration before implementation.
This history suggests that while the new DHS proposal may differ in details, its overall structure is likely to follow the same wage-ranking logic—and this time, the agency appears to be carefully following the proper rulemaking process to withstand legal challenge.
OIRA Has Approved Other Immigration Rules Recently
Other recent immigration-related rules approved by OIRA include:
- Civil monetary penalties for immigration violations (RIN 1653-AA96)
- Electronic bond notifications by ICE (RIN 1653-AA85)
These approvals signal that OIRA is actively moving immigration rules forward. Given the structured process and high-level interest, the current H‑1B selection proposal stands a strong chance of clearing review and reaching the NPRM stage soon.
The Policy Debate: Fairness vs. Exclusivity
The core goal of this proposal is to reward employers who offer the highest salaries. While that might sound merit-based, it also raises significant concerns:
- Startups and small businesses often cannot match the compensation packages of Fortune 500 firms. A strictly wage-based model could shut them out of the H‑1B system entirely.
- Many H‑1B workers are placed at federal agencies such as the FDA or U.S. Census Bureau via technology vendors. These vendors are bound by federal contract rates, which may not support Level 3 or 4 wages.
- IT consulting firms, which serve as intermediaries, typically offer Level 2 wages due to margins taken from client billing rates. Their H‑1B employees could be disadvantaged in a wage-based lottery.
- Many international students on F‑1 visas transition to H‑1B after graduation. Because they are recent graduates, employers often file at Level 1, making them noncompetitive under a wage-priority model.
- Additionally, petitioners in high-cost metropolitan areas such as Silicon Valley, San Francisco, Seattle, New York, and Washington, D.C. may be disproportionately disadvantaged. The prevailing wages for Level 3 or Level 4 positions in these markets are often extremely high. Employers in these regions may face the paradox of having high compensation offers that still fall short of their local Level 3 or 4 thresholds, reducing their competitiveness in the selection process.
If implemented without nuance, the policy could incentivize beneficiaries to bypass smaller firms or consulting companies in favor of large tech employers who can offer Level 3 or 4 wages. That risks reducing diversity in employment pathways and stifling entrepreneurship.
Final Thoughts
The current H‑1B proposal (RIN 1615‑AD01) may signal the end of the random lottery system—but it’s not just about efficiency. It raises critical questions about equity, access, and the future of employment-based immigration in the U.S.
Stakeholders should closely monitor the Federal Register for the NPRM release and be ready to submit comments. The rule is likely to move forward—but how it’s shaped will depend, in part, on how robustly the public engages during the comment period.