AI Generated Image
A federal judge in Oakland on September 30, 2026 vacated the government policies that put the $100,000 H-1B fee into effect, and barred federal agencies from enforcing them under both the original 2025 proclamation and its September 2026 extension.
U.S. District Judge Haywood S. Gilliam, Jr. of the Northern District of California granted in part a preliminary injunction motion in Global Nurse Force v. Trump (No. 4:25-cv-08454-HSG). The court found the plaintiffs likely to win their claims that the Department of Homeland Security, USCIS, the State Department and CBP violated the Administrative Procedure Act. The agencies skipped notice-and-comment rulemaking, did no small-business impact analysis, and did not consider alternatives or the reliance interests of employers.
The agencies may not enforce the fee policies until they complete notice-and-comment rulemaking and the analysis required by the Regulatory Flexibility Act. The court did not enjoin the proclamations themselves, and did not decide whether the President exceeded his authority.
At a glance
| Motion or request | Ruling | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Preliminary injunction (Dkt. 75) | Granted in part, denied in part | Agency fee policies vacated and remanded; agencies enjoined from enforcing them. Relief against the proclamations themselves denied for now. |
| Government motion to dismiss (Dkt. 104) | Denied | The case continues; the court said the issues are too complex for dismissal at this stage. |
| Provisional class certification (Dkt. 76) | Denied without prejudice | Not needed now, since vacatur already protects everyone; plaintiffs may refile. |
| Government request for bond | Denied | No security required from plaintiffs. |
| Government request to stay pending appeal | Denied | The order takes effect now. |
| Case management conference | Set for October 27, 2026, 2:00 p.m. | Joint statement due October 20, 2026. |
Background: the $100,000 fee
Proclamation 10973, signed September 19, 2025, requires a $100,000 payment with new H-1B petitions. It cites 8 U.S.C. §§ 1182(f) and 1185(a), which let the President restrict the entry of noncitizens. The administration said the fee targets “systemic abuse” of the program.
Before the proclamation, statutory and regulatory H-1B fees topped out at about $7,595 per petition. The court noted USCIS had never raised H-1B fees without advance notice, and past increases were far smaller: $1,125 in 2024 and $10 in 2019.
The proclamation was set to expire after 12 months. On September 18, 2026, Proclamation 11069 extended it through September 21, 2027, without substantively changing the fee.
The agencies then built the working rules through memos, FAQs and an October 20, 2025 USCIS update. Those materials limited the fee to new petitions, exempted renewals, required payment through Pay.gov, and set a narrow “national interest” exception process by email. The court calls these the “Agency Policies,” and they are what was vacated.
The plaintiffs and their harm
Five employers moved for the injunction. Each told the court it could not afford the fee and could not fill the role domestically.
| Plaintiff | Who they are | Harm described to the court |
|---|---|---|
| Global Nurse Force | Staffing agency placing international nurses with U.S. healthcare facilities | Says the fee eliminates its U.S. H-1B placement business; one D.C.-area health system paused plans to hire 60–70 specialized nurses. |
| Nephrology Associates of the Carolinas | Small kidney-care practice in rural North Carolina | Only qualified candidate after a nine-month search needs H-1B; exception request unanswered for nearly a year; about 100 new patients on a waitlist. |
| BAE Industries | Automotive parts maker near Detroit | Senior quality engineer on H-1B since 2019 had to return to India; company cannot pay the fee; exception request filed Nov. 14, 2025 still unanswered. |
| Lower Brule Day School | K–12 school on a Sioux reservation in rural South Dakota | All 10 applicants for two 2026–27 teaching posts are foreign nationals; the fee is about twice a starting teacher’s salary. |
| Global Village Academy Collective | Nonprofit running three tuition-free language-immersion charter schools in Colorado | Relies on native-speaker teachers, hired 10 on H-1B for 2025–26; state funding cannot cover even one fee. |
How the court reasoned
The court stressed it was not judging whether the fee is good policy, only whether the agencies followed the law.
Standing. The government argued the harms were speculative and that employers should first seek an exception. The court disagreed. It said an agency cannot defeat standing by never ruling on exception requests, noting Nephrology Associates had waited almost a year.
Reviewability. The government invoked consular nonreviewability. The court held that doctrine covers individual visa decisions, not challenges claiming the executive exceeded its authority, citing the Ninth Circuit’s Washington v. Trump.
Agency policies can be reviewed. Relying on the Ninth Circuit’s Nebraska v. Su (2024), the court held that agency actions implementing a presidential directive are still subject to the APA. It rejected the argument that a proclamation, unlike an executive order, leaves agencies no discretion; the proclamation itself gave the agencies room to implement it and grant exceptions.
Arbitrary and capricious. The agencies considered no alternatives and no reliance interests of employers, as Su and the Supreme Court’s DHS v. Regents require.
No notice and comment. The policies decided who pays, how, and who qualifies for an exception, so they are legislative rules that needed public comment. The court rejected the “good cause” and “foreign affairs” exceptions, noting the one-year extension undercut the claim of urgency.
The President. The court deliberately did not decide the claims against the President directly, following the Supreme Court’s approach in Trump v. Hawaii of resolving the case on the agency claims instead.
What the order does, and doesn’t do
The order stops the agencies from collecting the fee through their current policies, nationwide, but leaves the door open for them to reimpose it through proper rulemaking.
It does:
- Vacate the agency policies implementing the fee and send them back to the agencies.
- Bar DHS, USCIS, CBP, the State Department and their staff from enforcing policies under Proclamation 10973 and its extension, Proclamation 11069.
- Keep that bar in place until the agencies complete notice-and-comment rulemaking and Regulatory Flexibility Act analysis.
- Apply beyond the five plaintiffs, because the court used APA vacatur, which the Ninth Circuit says is not limited by the Supreme Court’s 2025 Trump v. CASA ruling on universal injunctions.
It doesn’t:
- Strike down or enjoin the proclamations themselves.
- Decide whether the President had authority under §§ 1182(f) and 1185(a) to impose the fee.
- Prevent a fee adopted through rulemaking. DHS has already proposed a rule setting a $103,265 fee for certain H-1B petitions (91 Fed. Reg. 54,817, Aug. 25, 2026). If finalized after notice and comment, it could satisfy the procedural defects the court identified, subject to new challenges.
Related cases and what comes next
This is the third court to rule on the fee, and the courts are split, which makes Supreme Court review likely. Judge Gilliam said as much in the order.
| Case | Court | Outcome | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Global Nurse Force v. Trump | N.D. Cal. | Agency policies vacated; enforcement enjoined pending rulemaking (Sept. 30, 2026) | Case management conference Oct. 27, 2026 |
| California v. Mullin | D. Mass. | Agency policies declared unlawful and vacated | First Circuit denied a stay pending appeal |
| Chamber of Commerce v. DHS | D.D.C. | Fee upheld; President acted within the INA, policies did not violate the APA | On appeal to the D.C. Circuit |
Because Mullin already vacated the same policies, the court said employers are now “doubly protected.” The Northern District order adds a second, independent block in a different circuit, so reversal of either ruling alone would not revive the policies.
The government is expected to appeal to the Ninth Circuit. The parties must file a joint case management statement by October 20, 2026, and appear at a public Zoom conference on October 27, 2026 at 2:00 p.m.
Source: Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Plaintiffs’ Motion for a Preliminary Injunction, Global Nurse Force v. Trump, No. 4:25-cv-08454-HSG, Dkt. No. 130 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 30, 2026). This article summarizes a court order and is not legal advice.